War Spectator Request To Avoid Spies (includes images)

[DiamondMinah]

Why not just reform the clan ranks altogether, in doing so you could implement it that new people in a clan cannot spectate wars.

Ranks:

New Recruit

Member

Recruiter

Elder

Co-Leader

Leader

[ashyam95]

Why not just reform the clan ranks altogether, in doing so you could implement it that new people in a clan cannot spectate wars.

Ranks:

New Recruit

Member

Recruiter

Elder

Co-Leader

Leader

I think this idea has been mentioned before in the forums. So the problem with this is that if you have a friend join your clan or one of your clan mate hop over to a feeder clan and come back. He/she would be tagged as "New Recruit". So he/she wouldn't be able to spectate the war even though you know the person is not a spy. You'll have to promote the player as elder and demote to get the "New Recruit" tag off of the player. Thats the flaw I've noticed people mention about this. Hope you understood what I meant.

[AlchemicalSnypr]

I like the idea of approval for new members. We war constantly and can't trust any recruits during war.

[Chazzaaaaa]

I love this idea - it's well explained.

However, I'd like to see only co-leaders+ having the ability to grant permission for a new-comer to view the war tab.

*Supports*

[ashyam95]

I like the idea of approval for new members. We war constantly and can't trust any recruits during war.

I love this idea - it's well explained.

However, I'd like to see only co-leaders+ having the ability to grant permission for a new-comer to view the war tab.

*Supports*

Thanks for the support!

Edited: Elders can no longer take an action.

[Ziaka]

I really like this idea..

I think the players against it love to spy and have mastered the technique.

I personally don't mind spys, they aren't going to beat us anyway. My clan is war 24/7 and is set to anyone can join at 1200 trophies. So bring it spies!


P.s. whoever said spies weren't intended don't know world history. Has there ever been a war without spies? Anyone know Benedict Arnold?

[droidnafiz]

i think its much easy to just show the base without the traps and cc for every new tagged people. or just another bottom rank "member", so that co's can remove the new tag without making him elder

[Fluid02]

WAR SPECTATOR REQUEST

Problem:

I'm sure most of you must've encountered the problem of spies coming over to your clan and spying on your war bases. For a back to back war clan you might have to accept people mid war.

Solution:

So when a player with "NEW" tag enters the war map he will be prompted with a pop up which look like this:

So basically the player has to request one of the leaders of the clan to grant permission to spectate the war. They can do everything else like a normal member except spectating the war. Once they have requested for permission, a request message will be sent on the clan chat like this:

After accepting

Only the Leader or a Co-Leader can take any action to this request. After accepting the request the player can spectate the war and look at all the bases.

Thats about it. Hope you liked my idea. Your feedback and support will be highly appreciated.


Other ideas that I've posted:

• Base Performance
• Wall Trap

I think the best way is not to add anyone, when the clan is in war.

[bkimbro]

I like this as it would allow you to take in new members during war and not risk them being spies. Once the current war is over, they can become full fledged members.

[calebMcF]

Simple yet brilliant