Star Bonus, Treasury, Loot Cart and more!

[SkidsUP]

CP https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=FmSf-lMEQpk Gal https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fSbvjk565ds

[Earthmomma]

Yeah and roll back the whole th11 content as well, because farming at th11 is completely impossible with the old system if every league above crystal 3 is dry as hell because everyone is cheap shielded.

Yes Supercell messed up a lot by continuing th sniping for 3 years and it was really time to fix that. The same applies to barching inactive bases. We dont have a loot problem in the game. We have a skill problem that even high th10 player often cant attack a base at all because all they have ever done was barch. And we have an activity problem that most players dont attack at all and only live from their collectors. They did a lot in the last update to correct these problems.

Yanno, I'm part of the "skill problem."

I also gem.

And I'm still playing post-Update.

I would love to disagree with your points, but I don't. I kind of disagree with the way you present your ideas, but it's your internet too. Do your thing. Where would forums be without the heady whiff of ...whatever that is. Anyhow, yes, there is a lack of skilled players on the Game. They used to be Champs & above, and one could spot them easily.

One thing I do disagree with you on is that there was/is an inherent "problem" to be "addressed" by having less skilled players able to have an enjoyable gaming experience. I am opposed to this notion. The Game already rewards the more skilled with League. Now that everyone and their dog is milking with gobs in silver, league is even MORE meaningless. To see a player's skill level now, you have to see their highest cups. And Legends? Staring at clouds for literally HOURS? You have to be kidding me. Those poor people. The most skilled among us... rewarded thusly.

Yes, the Game now actually DOES encourage skill gain in both offense and defense. I am still playing because I believe, deep down, that getting the TH's in is the right thing to do in order to extend the lifespan of this Game.

Phone screens are not getting THAT much bigger. TH11 required the addition of new space on the grid as it is. SC -had- to slow the grind, or else the Game would have no ability to grow and live.

I have played a Game through its lifespan once. I want my time on Clash to be as rewarding, and as lengthy as possible. I want the time to GAIN the skill.

I am sick of people on the forums acting like I should already have it. SC just gave me the gift of time to develop, and gave itself the same. So, I won't always be part of the "skill problem", but I hope there are people who ARE... for years to come. I hope people get to enjoy Clash. It still is a Great Game. It is great, because it is HARD. So just let people be bad at it in peace. It's hard, you're good, we get it. Now I'm gonna go try for 60% on something.

[loveless2213]

As a TH10 I have so much DE that I have to keep donating golems

[youTubeLordBeardo]

Lack of DE!?!?!?!?!

You are playing a different game than I am. DE has never flowed so freely in my 13 months of clashing.

move up to a higher league if you have a high TH base. I lot more loot a lot bigger bonus

Cheers
LB

[BazJoe]

I am trying really hard to stay positive and while I do appreciate that something is being brought to the table, this seems entirely too complicated. I know I don't know how it works at this point but good grief.. Loot carts treasury star bonuses.. This "very small %" you speak of could mean entirely different things to anyone.. Why not just make it a safe place for keeping a portion of your loot? Also figuring out how to get your loot into said treasury sounds convoluted.. Why is it war loot goes in there and some % of losses sustained? What about a % of our raid loot? I am starting to confuse myself.. This loot cart, is it going to be yet another structure to try and defend? I think we all have enough to defend now and I am not interested in something else to spread my defenses thinner. Kudos on trying to do something though.. Just don't understand why it has to come to all this.

[Falc]

Well I did Congratulate them on making an Awesome game by writing a good review and five stars on playstore. I would wait now, till things get any semblance of order. I like a few changes for sure but changing the meta of the game has made me cautious to instant back slapping and instant criticism. Let's see how the dice rolls.

[AgentO]

Anyone else notice how this game is turning into boom beach? So they decided to bring the "vault" to clash. What is next the shock canon?

I still think the last update was a mistake and changed the game away from what most people liked in the game.

[Katipo]

Finding loot isn't a problem, if you aren't finding loot, you aren't raiding. The ultimate problem is keeping the loot that you raided. Understanding that this is a game of gains and losses is essential. You will lose loot. However, losing 2 hours of raiding time every day in terms of loot losses is not OK. It has been taking an average of 3 attacks on my base every night to get a shield. One attack kills my hero's, one attack my clan castle troops and the third takes all of my loot. Typically 400 - 800k gold and elixir and 2700 de, a day. That is unacceptable. Getting a little bit back, or getting a little bonus for attacking is trivial and quite frankly insulting.

The only way to try and save this game is to give a shield for destroying the town hall.

That will satisfy 95% of all the current problems with farmers, trophy pushers, casual players and hardcore war players. Argue if you will, but it is the only logical solution. Before the changes, 90% of the bases had their town hall inside anyway and if it was outside you still had the option to attack the base and steal the loot.

It seems that the only ones dissatisfied before were the game dev's, and they don't count as they obviously don't play their own game.

You are absolutely right. Finding loot is not the problem, keeping it is. This is exactly what I have been saying since he update. The changes introduced last time such as turning the TH into a loot store and incremental loot bonus means attackers are raiding with much more powerful armies. Supercell don't have the guts admit that they got it wrong. Instead of fixing their mistake by reversing the relevant changes, they have opted to put a band aid on the game.

[Coercion]

5 star system
You shall raid 5 times, and cook an army capable of getting at least 30% to get a star. Every day.

Loot crate
You must lose much loot to get crate.

Treasury
I thought all loot was precious.

[joelmor3]

I gave the last update a chance. ...no more chances....

Shallow. Instead of trying a hopeful solution, you give up. Yet, you're still on the forums...