Jake from Onehive summarises it all...

[chesapeake]

I agree with the points brought in the video.

I would love arranged wars so much. To have inter-clan skirmishes would be amazing. The 5 vs 5 sounds really cool too.

For farming/trophy pushing, the idea of matching based on war-weight sounds interesting. This would help early at a new townhall level guys/girls because they won't match with maxed or high-end players... both offensively and defensively. More dead bases would be nice as it would increase diversity among players. I go for storages now, but I don't care how someone else plays. I like the bonus idea. 50% still rewards nicely but higher damage equals double bonus? That would really encourage 3 star attackers but still reward a barch type player. Again, as it should be.

Great video. And thanks for posting this!

[Vanguard15]

On that I agree , but here lays the possibility of people differing in opion
And I don't agree with them 2 posting their videos here either..I believe you tube corner is the appropriate place at best for that

For the record I watch ONEHIVE RAIDS, and has helped me a fair bit

Looopy has the best answer really...!!

Youtube corner?lol..sounds like an exile

[chesapeake]

That depends on the quality of the current code base.

Adapting loot bonus can't be hard.

Removing PBT and VG and make it possible to be attacked while being online can be a hard update, but can also be not that hard.

Tackling ♥♥♥♥♥ing: the only solution I see is adding tests in the app to see if there is ♥♥♥♥♥ing software available on the device and if so refuse to start the app.

Matchmaking will probably also be a more difficult update.

But bottomline is, all those changes are possible and should be possible in a reasonable amount of time. Moreover people like CoC that much, that if they communicate they will implement this and that and it takes even up to a month: people will wait.

imo: loot bonus should be done first and that can be done in a couple of days.

You could create a defensive snap shot (just like war) when your base is about to be put in matching. Then, once you get a shield, the snapshot is removed. Depending on what happens, loot / trophies / traps / heroes are down next time you reload your village

I doubt it would be anymore difficult than clan wars to be honest

[perkunas]

The video is unnecessarily long but he makes great points.

[Evelknee]

I like Jake's videos and this one especially addressing the problems in Coc. However his opinion isn't very well received at supercell, his Twitter account got banned from clash con with no explanation given, as I'm sure this thread will. What does that tell us all?

[coachmoneyball]

Jake and Chief pat seem to be the two guys who understand whats going on better than almost every youtuber.

honestly SC could listen to those two and gain a whole lot imo.

[MaxFuro]

I like Jake's videos and this one especially addressing the problems in Coc. However his opinion isn't very well received at supercell, his Twitter account got banned from clash con with no explanation given, as I'm sure this thread will. What does that tell us all?

I don't care about Jake and his relation to SC and vice versa. It's about the content, the ideas in the movie... Please make abstraction of the messenger.

[Is0prene]

The video is unnecessarily long but he makes great points.

I thought about that too as i watched it, but then again they screwed up the game so much there are a billion things that need to be fixed, not very easy to sum it all up and still get your point across. I mean you cant say whats wrong, give a solution, then be done. You got to explain why or else nobody takes it seriously. That takes a long time.

[Skrags]

The video was only made 2 days ago, and makes some great points.
It's also very noticeable that Jake, and Chief Pat seem to be reaching out to each other, and sharing opinions, through social media, which can only be a good thing for the Clash community in my opinion.

If I was in charge of Supercell, I would openly and honestly :-

1) Employ Pat to design some new single player maps, and to run the PR department.
2) Employ Jake, to 'help' design all things war, balancing, matches, tournaments.
3) Lock them both in a room for 1 hour to test all new updates together.

Hell, I think I'd contribute myself.... $100 to kick us off?

[MaxFuro]

The video was only made 2 days ago, and makes some great points.
It's also very noticeable that Jake, and Chief Pat seem to be reaching out to each other, and sharing opinions, through social media, which can only be a good thing for the Clash community in my opinion.

If I was in charge of Supercell, I would openly and honestly :-

1) Employ Pat to design some new single player maps, and to run the PR department.
2) Employ Jake, to 'help' design all things war, balancing, matches, tournaments.
3) Lock them both in a room for 1 hour to test all new updates together.

Hell, I think I'd contribute myself.... $100 to kick us off?

Same feeling.