Not 30%..... NO loot

[ErwinB]

for sure it is selfish. but tell me:
Why should i let me heros die and let them recover for more than 1h, if i can surrender and have them available again without recover time?
or why should i deploy all of my troops, if i can get all your loot with half of them?
so you tell me just for the "respect" i should lose elixir (troop cost) or time (hero recovery)?


Great idea. and every time you use your heros, they will be down for more than 1h to recover

1. If you need to use your heroes for a 29% raid, you're obviously doing something wrong
2. At 29% you wouldn't get ALL my loot... I see one goblin raid after an other on my base and they gain about 25% of the available loot... (Not 25% of the entire loot, either gold or elixer)
3. No, for the "respect" I need to lose resources
4. Not a reply to something you said, but a reply in general to those who say it happens only on the minorty of players... Could be right, you need to have loot in your base... So those who say it never happened to them, probably aren't worthed to get raided with goblins ��

Fyi: I'm talking about my maxed th 8 that is upgrading to a th 9... Gold and elixer are full (6 million), the loot when attacking me is (depending on the attackers th) around 650k.

[EquiNoX26]

1. Where did i said, that i need them to get 29% destruction? i need my heros, respectively my AQ to snipe your DE storage after i funnneld her into the core. When i have your DE i use her ability to heal her, if necessary, and quit.
Why should i let her die, if i have already all the DE that i need?
2. Even if i dont get all your loot, i get some of your loot in the most efficent way.
If you offer 650k, your collector must be full or even half full. stotage cap for a th8 is 300k, so 350k are in the collectors. i am a th9 so i can get 280k loot from your collectors and 240k from your storages.
If i use a mass gob army with some WBs and hero support i will usually get all of your collectors.
This means i get 280k loot for an invenstment of 36k elix (210 gobs, 5WBs, no spells)
the efficency of this raid is ~777% (280k/36k*100%)
And now show me an army comp, that will wipe out your base at the same efficency level.
The maximum cost for this comp have to be less than ~67k elixir (540k*100%/777%)
I would say it isnt possible to wipe out a max(?) TH8 base with troops and spells, that cost less than 67k.
Maybe you can prove me wrong, but i highly doubt it.
So i can either
wipe out you base for all of your loot with a bad efficency or
"milk" your base for ~half of your loot, but with the maximum efficency.
What would you do?
3. dont know what you what to say with that point

[chesapeake]

Why don't we just drop the % requirement for a shield?

Attacker deploys 1/3 army capacity? Shield.

Simple. Ends the 29% problem. You can still use smash n grab armies for quick hits, but you'll likely be giving a shield then.