while I was in champs 3, my base was successfully barched for 50%. Using Ash's TH11 loot protection base, all maxed TH10 defenses. it was the perfect win - win scenario.
while I was in champs 3, my base was successfully barched for 50%. Using Ash's TH11 loot protection base, all maxed TH10 defenses. it was the perfect win - win scenario.
IGN: David | Clan: Mao Bear Nation | TH11 | GG: 1,780,630,354 | EE: 2B | HH: 8,525,288 | FIN: 260,443 | AQ/BK/GW: 40/40/20 | 275 Magma - 03/18/16
Why are these moderators and Clash team people (and some youtubers) ALWAYS test with the stupid maxed troop and claim it works? This is nonsense and this is why the update fail, and the reason why there are so much complain about this update. You don't even know your audience, what a real CHIEF! Gosh. If a real Chief gem for win, then gem for a gowipe, gohog, gowiwi, laloon, or whatever great army. Don't just show me gem base to max, but still use baby troops. It doesnt make sense! Why don't you use a lv20 hero, level 6 barb and archers to fight a Th10? That5's more reasonable and representative to the majority of the players trying to make progress.Originally Posted by LachNessMeownster
Incoming flaming yada yada.
OH BOY! People never learned and still proud of what they showing. Dang it!
Last edited by BigBully1990; December 29th, 2015 at 07:35 PM.
Thanks for risking your trophies for the experiment.
A few things of note:
1) most players do not have maxed heroes and are not able to farm with both heroes constantly
2) The grand warden is extremely powerful with mass troops - again most of us do not have a grand warden for attacking
3) The 50% you were able to get on the base would not provide much loot benefit in the leagues where this attack strategy was once useful.
That being said, I do not believe your single barch attack can convince the masses of players that is it still an effective farming strategy. This update has been brutal to efficient farming strategies.
I do thank you for taking the time to run the experiment.
TH9 - King 25/ Queen 27Began Jan 2015
Retired Jan 2016
Great thread. Wow
Could a mod close this thread... Oh wait... Seriously, how does this help anyone? Maxed heroes, AND 5 spells (so the army cook time is basically that of lavaloonion defeating the purpose of Barching entirely).
Remember when: You were having fun playing the game instead of reading the forum?
A mod made this thread
He didn't use all of them, and even so, the cloud time up there is huge, allowing you to just return to your base to get the spells that were cooking when you left...
About the heroes... At that league most players have maxed heroes, but if he wants to convince people he should try it out with 20/20 heroes and no GW.
Clash Royale: Pompeyo4 | Lvl 10| Best: 4140| 5013 Legend Trophies | 11/8/4/2 Cards
Pompeyo4.1 | Lvl 6 | Best: 3074 | 100~ Legend Trophies | 7/5/2/1 Cards
Winner of 20+ Tournaments | Mexican best: Top 1
Ash (Eternal625) video | Lvl 6 in Legendary Arena! | Legendary Arena as a F2P! | Lava Hound Deck Guide!
Wow that sounds amazing. Thanks for testing this out! I will certainly try that instead of using gowipe.
Clan: Faked Wargasm (open for recruitment!)
140 wins 3 losses, longest streak 118 wins. Current streak, 7 T_T <-- RIP WHF2
Stats: Lvl 119, Th 9, 434+ war stars, 540k gold/elixir stolen, ~2.4 mil de
Follow me on Twitter @the_benjy99 #FPC
wow to half this thread!!! it's just a random example!!!
it's merely stating that if it's possible to win an attack in legends with barch, it's likely possible lower down
Yes, not everyone has max heros, but then who is also attacking a max th10/11 base with max Heros defending it?!
PLENTY of bases in master/champion that are nowhere near as strong as those in legend...easy to find them with a few next's
It seems most of this forum just want an argument regardless.
Incoming flaming yada yada.
Please try and keep it civil.
With all the recent controversy about barching being nerfed and being forced to create larger armies, I wanted to conduct a little test, at the risk of losing my much loved legend trophies.
So, I decided to take a standard BArch army, and try for league bonus in legend.
Now obviously I wouldn't expect people to push to legend for the bonus, but a 150k (ish) bonus in champs is fairly decent for a barch attack, and rather easy for even a Town Hall 9 to achieve. I did it my whole farming life.
So, the army consisted of 80 Barbarians, 160 archers, 1 poison, 1 EQ spell (not needed), 5 lightning spells, (Which werent all needed, see video), heroes and Clan Castle troops.
Total army cost = 230k Elixir (remember not all spells will be needed, and they are half the army cost) and 180DE.
Total loot gained from league bonus is 340k Gold, 340k Elixir and 2400 DE.
That's a profit of 340k Gold, 110k Elixir (at least) and 2220 DE just in league bonus.
Then in the actual raid I made:
Total profit:
701,237 Gold.
200,866 Elixir.
2231 Dark Elixir.
And that is from one raid, on an army that took half an hour to cook. I urge clashers to move up the leagues a bit, and start looking at the league bonus as a viable source of income, instead of relying on collector bases.
And as a bonus! It's incredibly rare you dont get a shield up here!
-Lach
Sorry but your post can't be taken seriously.
Not everybody can be in Legend or Titan league (since the number of trophies is limited, bases distribution gets a pyramidal scheme).
Even considering the Champ and Master league (going lower the league bonus is not that significant), probably no more than 20% of total players can be there.
What about the remaining majority?
And you cherry picked 1 single attack..not a sequence of them..and with all heroes maxed (what about the rest of us who havent all heroes maxed and possibly upgrading too..).
I can't believe you didn't think about any of that while writing your post.
It's also possible that you buy a ticket for the national lottery and you win it.
Many things are possible, but people won't keep enjoying this game if the chances get too tiny.
To be valid the argument expressed by the OP , the league bonuses should be consistently higher .
Last edited by sonnet; December 29th, 2015 at 11:09 PM.
Posting Permissions
