Why Town Hall 10 Should Have Access to Grand Warden (Level 5)

[Wells549]

There is a balance problem at th10. A lot of it has to do with the BK and AQ upgrade times. It is much faster to upgrade your xbows and infernos than it is the royals. As most people ( myself included) do when they fist get to th10. I am even farther behind because I stopped at 20/20. Got bored in wars (with goho had little trouble of 3 starring max 9's.) Only since I got to 25/25 am I able to get 2 stars on max 10 bases consistently. But still struggle on good layouts.

I was thinking instead of the warden, maybe add a level to the golems (definately), hogs (maybe) and/or valks. But since I had this idea last year did not think of the warden (obviously). It may be a much better and easier fix to just add the warden to 10.

Also I think that the th9 needs to be balanced the other way a little to encourage people to stay longer. If you increase the attack power of th 10's and defense of th 9's it could help both war and multiplayer.

Anyway, very well thought out solution Ash.

[Jinx483]

Doesn't make sense.

You need near maxed heroes to 3 star at th10. Its just how the game was built. The same goes for th11. Granted the wardens ability makes it a little easier, you still need those high lvl heroes.

Stay th9 if u want. You need to put some serious time in to be able to compete at th10 and th11. Just how it is. Not everyone should be able to rush through and be able to 3 star th10s as a mid th10 with no heroes. Same for th11.

They will be adding to th11 , I understand thats what they did when th10 came out, developed it slowly.

Sure farming sucks at th10, we've all been there. Should the game just be easy? No.

Edit:
What's the imbalance at th10? You can't 3 star easily without putting time andor money into the game? Is it possible it was done purposely? Th10 is not as easy as th's 7-9. Maybe this was to encourage full(er) army attacks, which its clear, that this is super cells idea from the start. Maybe it was accidental. Either way, if they want to make the end of the game extremely difficult, then so be it.

[Biz]

Doesn't make sense.

You need near maxed heroes to 3 star at th10. Its just how the game was built. The same goes for th11. Granted the wardens ability makes it a little easier, you still need those high lvl heroes.

Stay th9 if u want. You need to put some serious time in to be able to compete at th10 and th11. Just how it is. Not everyone should be able to rush through and be able to 3 star th10s as a mid th10 with no heroes. Same for th11.

They will be adding to th11 , I understand thats what they did when th10 came out, developed it slowly.

Sure farming sucks at th10, we've all been there. Should the game just be easy? No.

Edit:
What's the imbalance at th10? You can't 3 star easily without putting time andor money into the game? Is it possible it was done purposely? Th10 is not as easy as th's 7-9. Maybe this was to encourage full(er) army attacks, which its clear, that this is super cells idea from the start. Maybe it was accidental. Either way, if they want to make the end of the game extremely difficult, then so be it.

This^

When some of us hit th10 we had a choice of the loot penalty hitting th09s to attack or come across the gemmers who maxed their bases.
We did what SC suggests. We adapted.

[Wells549]

Doesn't make sense.

You need near maxed heroes to 3 star at th10. Its just how the game was built. The same goes for th11. Granted the wardens ability makes it a little easier, you still need those high lvl heroes.

Stay th9 if u want. You need to put some serious time in to be able to compete at th10 and th11. Just how it is. Not everyone should be able to rush through and be able to 3 star th10s as a mid th10 with no heroes. Same for th11.

They will be adding to th11 , I understand thats what they did when th10 came out, developed it slowly.

Sure farming sucks at th10, we've all been there. Should the game just be easy? No.

Edit:
What's the imbalance at th10? You can't 3 star easily without putting time andor money into the game? Is it possible it was done purposely? Th10 is not as easy as th's 7-9. Maybe this was to encourage full(er) army attacks, which its clear, that this is super cells idea from the start. Maybe it was accidental. Either way, if they want to make the end of the game extremely difficult, then so be it.

Don't have an issue with needing max Heroes to 3star a th10. This "balance" issue, and maybe I did a poor job of expressing, is the time difference of catching the attack ability to the defenses. Combine this with some poor war matchups and people get frustrated. Personally, I am fine with failed attacks (it's just a game and I've learned more from my failures than great attacks), but some take this too seriously. But with max hogs and L4 golems you can, with a good amount of consistency, 3 star max th 9's, with lower than 20 royals. Also have seen people do the same with loons ( not me I totally suck at loons)And I don't see the loot problem as being as bad as a lot of people do here on the forums. Just more "nexting".

Your point though about putting the effort to upgrade the royals is dead on. I made a mistake in going to th10 with 20/20 heroes. Would recommend to anyone to wait until 30/30.

I was only throwing out an idea I have kicked around for a while now. Unsure if is a good one or not. A lot of people seem extremely frustrated with this update, and I see the gameplay/social aspect has suffered some. And I like to see people offer solutions instead of just complaining.

[TheRealBigBadJohn]

/signed

we need this now!!!

[QueenBeeq]

my bet is eventually Th10 will get it but for right now its the only compelling reason to upgrade to Th11. Once TH11 has more content then they may make him available sooner.

[irmtfan]

So you think with 40/40 heroes 3* a max th10 is as easy as 3* a max th9 with a th9 offense and max 30/30 heroes!
No!
You even cannot 3* a th10 in 50% of wars!
High percent yes but 3* is too rare!
Again I repeat 3* a max th9 by a max th9 is common!
But 3* a max th10 by a max th10 is rare = 10% of attacks or less!

[Yolksters17]

I like the TH10 challenge. People say TH9 is where the real war players go to ball, but I disagree.

If you want to be in the elite, TH10 is where you prove it. Cant do it? Go get GW and laugh away your sorrows.

Maybe that was their initial and continuing thoughts about the difficulty of TH10...?

[Jinx483]

So you think with 40/40 heroes 3* a max th10 is as easy as 3* a max th9 with a th9 offense and max 30/30 heroes!
No!
You even cannot 3* a th10 in 50% of wars!
High percent yes but 3* is too rare!
Again I repeat 3* a max th9 by a max th9 is common!
But 3* a max th10 by a max th10 is rare = 10% of attacks or less!

So yes, 3 star at th9 is easier. So why shouldn't th10, the next level in the game, be more difficult? As games progress, they get harder.

It takes much more skill, yes. Much harder, yes. But look up elite clans that 3 star most bases in a war, all th10/11 vs all th10/11. Replays are there. Mostly air, yes. I've seen some goho's. There is more than 1 strat. Now at th11, its easier with a 20 gw and the invincibility.

Bottom line is that i don't have a problem with th10 NOT being another th9. I'm kind of ok with how difficult it is. And SC is too becuase people who don't want to work for it will pay for it.

[Ace2k]

Love this idea.