Why Town Hall 10 Should Have Access to Grand Warden (Level 5)

[Micker99]

GW shall be exclusive for TH11

otherwise, wat Advatage does TH11 have over TH10?! In offensive?!

same troop lvl ( except witch nd minion )

same spell space

same camp space

There will be no difference if TH10 has GW

if they have him, they wont go to TH11 nd they will abuse cw matchmaking system again

Exactly, there would be almost no incentive to upgrade to th11. The GW is the entire offensive upgrade for th11. Sure every th10 would love a level 5 GW! Just like a TH8 would love a level 5 AQ! TH11s upgrades are insultingly low, this would make it a complete waste to upgrade. I would rather be a th10 with a level 5 GW, then go to TH11 for minimal upgrades and a huge loot penalty.

When TH11 gets 20 more troop space, extra spell slot, new levels for current heroes, upgrades to troops besides nerfed witches, then we can talk about it lol.

[Dcrazy187]

Exactly, there would be almost no incentive to upgrade to th11. The GW is the entire offensive upgrade for th11. Sure every th10 would love a level 5 GW! Just like a TH8 would love a level 5 AQ! TH11s upgrades are insultingly low, this would make it a complete waste to upgrade. I would rather be a th10 with a level 5 GW, then go to TH11 for minimal upgrades and a huge loot penalty.

When TH11 gets 20 more troop space, extra spell slot, new levels for current heroes, upgrades to troops besides nerfed witches, then we can talk about it lol.

Honestly all those things you just mentioned could happen in the next update.(camp space,hero upgrades, spells,ect..) as well as th10 getting access to GW. Right now th11 needs a buff to defense IMO. When they finally start getting more defensive upgrades th10 troops as well as GW lv5 would be way out of reach for a th11. We are still in baby stages of th11. Buffs I'm sure are coming when th10 first came out we only got 1 inferno tower the following update gave us the second inferno along with better upgrades we should see that coming soon also.

im sure SC wants to balance 10 and I doubt they nerf current defenses at th10 because that does hurt th11. A buff to offensive is a easier way to go.lv5 GW might be simple fix and they can tweek his stats if needed.

[LordHalestorm]

No. Just no. I say this not because I'm TH10.5 and I don't want TH10 to have it, but because level 5 GW would unbalance the offense way too much. In other words, swing the pendulum too far the other way.

I'm consistently getting 70+% against TH10/11 and I haven't even really figured out how to actually use him properly.

[GrrArgh]

Wow, I can't believe this thread has as much support as it does?! I agree it is a well thought out post as they normally are from Ash, but this idea is ridiculous and completely unnecessary. Folks like Micker99 and Daz have already raised enough great counter arguments so no need for me to add any more.

Adding the GW to TH10 would be a massive mistake and I for one would be incredibly a upset if it ever happened anytime soon. There are loads of other ways to balance TH10 in the coming months which I'm sure will happen, adding the GW would the exact opposite while rendering the TH11 that much more useless for the time being until it gets more firepower added.

[Gestaltcal]

Nonetheless th10 is the still by a long shot the most unbalanced TH in the game.

Aside from extra levels, th10 has no exclusive troop. Pretty much, every other level does.

With the advent of th11 exclusive troops will now, never happen...so..why not drop the GW to th10.

Appreciate you want to keep your toys at th11 to yourself but, be slightly less disingenuous guys.

Many other new level troops/defences will be rolled out in the coming months.

[G0dPower]

Wow, I can't believe this thread has as much support as it does?! I agree it is a well thought out post as they normally are from Ash, but this idea is ridiculous and completely unnecessary. Folks like Micker99 and Daz have already raised enough great counter arguments so no need for me to add any more.

Adding the GW to TH10 would be a massive mistake and I for one would be incredibly a upset if it ever happened anytime soon. There are loads of other ways to balance TH10 in the coming months which I'm sure will happen, adding the GW would the exact opposite while rendering the TH11 that much more useless for the time being until it gets more firepower added.

The only alternative solution to balancing th10 put up was nerfing infernos, which has pretty big implications on its own, including completely breaking th11, which is already struggling to stop witch-heavy gowiwi. Besides thats been said is that we should believe SC will add in some new troop/mechanic change after an indefinite period of time that will balance th10.

Regardless, if SC is going to do anything, they should really do it soon. If they're ever going to implement this, they should do it now before even more people jump to th11 to get the warden, and if not, just say its not going to happen.

[Billius]

Let's take one of the two new elements (Eagle being the other) in the long-awaited TH11 upgrade and give it to TH10's. LOLOL
TH9's should have Level 1 Inferno.
Th8's need to have xbow support.
... TH1 should have cc.

We can call it "upgrade redistribution". Free perks. Who would vote no?

[Clcabatbat]

If you want grand warden, upgrade to th11. Same as townhall 8, who wants archer queen they should upgrade to th9.

[G0dPower]

Let's take one of the two new elements (Eagle being the other) in the long-awaited TH11 upgrade and give it to TH10's. LOLOL
TH9's should have Level 1 Inferno.
Th8's need to have xbow support.
... TH1 should have cc.

We can call it "upgrade redistribution". Free perks. Who would vote no?

From the OP:
Q: Then why not add AQ to Th8? Heroes are available every other town hall, keep it that way!
A: Heroes being available every other Town Hall level is arbitrary (as there is only a three hero sample size) but there is a very good reason why AQ being added to Th8 makes no sense. Because Town Hall 8 is already balanced! They do not need additional access to a hero to help balance things. Offense and defense are already appropriately balanced at Th8. Just as I would never advocate for Th9 to get access to Grand Warden because Town Hall 9 is already balanced (or at least was) perfectly.

Q: But if you give Town Hall 10 level 5 Grand Warden there will be no incentive to upgrade to Th11!
A: Wrong! If you give Town Hall 10 access to level 5 GW it will finally incentivize players to stay Town Hall 10 and even max out because they'll have plenty of firepower for the Town Hall. (Just as most Th9 players currently do) There are four reasons that players will still want to upgrade to Th11.

1. Players will want to have access to level 3 witches, level 7 minions, and any additional added levels of troops in the future.
2. Players will want to eventually add the additional defenses (Eagle Artillery, new Xbow, new Wizard tower (and levels), Archer Tower, and Cannon.
3. Players will want access to level 6-20 of Grand Warden.
4. Players who max Th10 will have nothing left to do, so will naturally be inclined to upgrade to Town Hall 11 and continue with their natural progression.

Q: What will make Town Hall 11 special?
A: New defense, new troop levels, new defensive levels, additional Grand Warden levels, new art, and access all additional new content added in the future.

[Jspray]

If they give warden to th10 then I will be signing the petition to return my base back to a th10.....