Perfect War - Loot and XP Multiplier

[AMGINE84]

Today my clan was lucky enough to celebrate our 3rd perfect war victory since its inception just over a year ago. I would assume this is quite a rare occurrence in most clans, and the first time it happened I was slightly disappointed to find out there wasn't even a visual cue when we collected all the stars.

I think it would be nice if there was some recognition in the form of an extra reward for clans who manage to play a perfect game:

[WarrenJames]

As great as that sounds... that might be too much of a reward. What I mean is, it may put too much emphasis on total destruction, and cause more disappointment and greif in players when they fail to get that, even by a minor mistake on attack, or technical issues like device falling into the toilet or parents taking a key member's device right when they need to do that last important attack, or whatever of many annoying situations.

Not to say I don't like it. It is common in several games, and is not a bad idea in of itself, but it is best served on single player games, where retrying isn't a major issue, and you are beating up a computer opponent, not other players. We want competition, but not too much of an inconvenience. We play to have fun, not be disappointed when reminded of falling short of a possibly unrealistic goal.

[Monto6]

i support the idea but not a x2 on everything, just extra exp clan like 25 or 50.

[AMGINE84]

As great as that sounds... that might be too much of a reward. What I mean is, it may put too much emphasis on total destruction, and cause more disappointment and greif in players when they fail to get that, even by a minor mistake on attack, or technical issues like device falling into the toilet or parents taking a key member's device right when they need to do that last important attack, or whatever of many annoying situations.

Not to say I don't like it. It is common in several games, and is not a bad idea in of itself, but it is best served on single player games, where retrying isn't a major issue, and you are beating up a computer opponent, not other players. We want competition, but not too much of an inconvenience. We play to have fun, not be disappointed when reminded of falling short of a possibly unrealistic goal.

That makes sense. Disappointment would be very high if the clan falls short by just a few stars and people lose out on a significantly bigger reward. Perhaps a small reward would better suit this idea.

I would like to see some more visual feedback though. Such as a different colored progress bar or larger font/different color of the percentage points.

[AMGINE84]

i support the idea but not a x2 on everything, just extra exp clan like 25 or 50.

You're right, x2 is probably too much. I would already be perfectly happy with a few more experience points. Just a nice little surprise that isn't mentioned or even hinted at on the War Results page unless you make it to 100%. Like how Legend League isn't mentioned on the League levels info page, keeping it a bit of a mistery

[WarrenJames]

That makes sense. Disappointment would be very high if the clan falls short by just a few stars and people lose out on a significantly bigger reward. Perhaps a small reward would better suit this idea.

I would like to see some more visual feedback though. Such as a different colored progress bar or larger font/different color of the percentage points.

Give it some thought on what would be a good reward. I can't think of a good example off hand, mostly because I'm thinking about a different topic... which is understanding these rants about the Personal Break system, and what is the driving force behind it all.

Take your time. Supercell is likely more than half way into working out a set of updates and Features for Clan Wars; since people have said that the current update lacked Clan War content, and just seems to make sense that changes to it would be next.

In short, if it isn't being worked on already, it has missed the current development cycle and will have to come about much later.

[OMCKG]

this will be very unfair for clans of TH10s. Seriously, do you expect players to 3 star maxed th10s? No. While clans with all TH7s can 3 star each other easily and with the xp bonus can level up much more quickly than clans full with maxed th10s.

[AMGINE84]

Give it some thought on what would be a good reward. I can't think of a good example off hand, mostly because I'm thinking about a different topic... which is understanding these rants about the Personal Break system, and what is the driving force behind it all.

Take your time. Supercell is likely more than half way into working out a set of updates and Features for Clan Wars; since people have said that the current update lacked Clan War content, and just seems to make sense that changes to it would be next.

In short, if it isn't being worked on already, it has missed the current development cycle and will have to come about much later.

I'll see if I can flesh out the details a bit more rather than just proposing a concept.

Good luck with the PB thing. My own issues with it are that, because play time is now cumulative, I can no longer anticipate when I will be forced to take a break unless I play a 3 hour session, which can lead to problems during war. It also seems a bit silly for a game company to limit play time so drastically. Anyway, just my two cents...

[N1NJ4W4RR10R]

Xp bump would be nice, but that loot would be insane

[AMGINE84]

this will be very unfair for clans of TH10s. Seriously, do you expect players to 3 star maxed th10s? No. While clans with all TH7s can 3 star each other easily and with the xp bonus can level up much more quickly than clans full with maxed th10s.

3 starring maxed TH10s is difficult but certainly not impossible. The reward doesn't have to be a multiplier. In fact, as discussed above, it probably shouldn't be. Even if it's slightly easier for TH7s to achieve this I doubt it will be a weekly occurrence for most clans. And if it is, good for them. 50 v 50 clans grow faster than 10 v 10 clans so I don't really see why that should be a reason not to do it.