So I have two accounts, a TH9 and a TH8. Having to defend on my 9, while annoying, isn't the end of the world, although I agree with all of the anti-update arguments on how it's ruining the argument. TH8, on the other hand, is pretty much screwed. Here goes:
So, as a 9, I can defend against most farming armies. Sure, they might get a couple storages, but my DE isn't getting hit that badly (I also don't have as much DE, but that's another story of brokenness from the update). My TH8, on the other hand, has zero ability to defend its DE from TH8s. Of course, the game is designed to pick on the little guys, and TH8s can pick on TH7s.. but TH7s never have a decent amount of DE, and there are far fewer rich TH7s than rich TH8s. TH8s also can't survive and raid efficiently in leagues where the league bonus is anything substantial. If a TH8 wants to save for something like golems, even with the reduction in DE given to 9s it's still a guarantee that you're getting hit for 1600 DE every third raid, and there aren't any efficient raid armies to get it back. 3 dragon raids are going to cost over a million elixir, and I can rely on loonion to get maybe a thousand DE per raid, but given the fact that I have to sleep one of the shield cycles it's never going to get there.
Sure, SC defenders can make the argument that TH8 sucks go to TH9, but I already have a higher account and used to really enjoy TH8 warfare. Now that they get the donated spell they can just run mass hogs with 45 hogs and any base will fall easy.. Thanks for ruining TH8, Supercell.



In terms of defense I doubt you will get hit often as most guys down here have barch armies and basically every defense is drop one troop and surrender. Even 40/40 hero max TH10s are skipping my full DE storage just for slower but profitable snipes.
