Stars earned in battle should be based on percent destroyed.

[ProfChaos]

Hope this is the right place to post this; apologies if it's not.

As SC has made major changes to shielding I think it's time to change how stars are earned across the board.

With lower shield threshold (now 30% deconstruction) 40% should gain you the 1st star, a nice high standard for a solid attack and the 2nd star at 70% and the 3rd rewarded at 100% for perfection.

Hope to see SC make this change. It would go well in conjunction with the evolved attacking/ shielding/ bonus systems.

[Radiating]

While this would be interesting, SC is aiming for original intent, one of which is that the TH counts as a star. So, I don't think it'll happen, because that'd make the TH useless.

[Moraw]

wow, this'd change wars A LOT, i like this idea but i don't think it would be implemented into the game.

[Reav3R]

Bad idea, this would basically make TH worthless in wars.

[IlDiavolo]

I really like that idea...it would stop gowipers sniping for townhall and 50%.

TH would be still extremely valuable for protecting the queen because of high HP.

I would like to see that in war. We don't see that in farm mode imo.

[ProfChaos]

I don't see how it would make the TH useless. It is still the highest HP structure and would need to be destroyed to get all three stars, likely to get two as well.

As the TH is now a resource and can be taken down by scummy gobs no one would not defend it in war or multiplayer.

I feel like removing the star from the TH would reward more full attacks to gain the high percent 2nd star and stop the mad dash to get the TH & 50%. SC clearly wants us making better and more full attacks.

Coincidentally the 70% 2nd star was not a random thought but directly tied to the new full league bonus on an attack and above the threshold for the new 14 hour shield.

[evildead]

I don't know if the ppl that agree with this r lower lvls but I'm lvl 132 TH10 and trying get TH and 50% against other high/max TH10 is extremely hard. I'm not going to put the idea down then not offer another solution so here is my solution. Get rid of the 3 star system and make it a 5 star system. A star is earned at 25%, 50%, 75%, 100% and as always TH is a star. In total 5 stars. A minimum of 2 stars is needed for a shield to be incurred. I find this would help more during war too since so many mid-low attacks and up with high 90% plus TH atm. Getting so close to perfection and still only getting the same reward as 50% plus TH doesn't seem fair but that is the current system. If u feel this idea can work but needs a little tweak then write ur tweak so we can read it.

[bobofclashofclans]

Stars earned in battle are based on a % destroyed.

See here:

You destroy 50% of the base, 1 star
You destroy 100% of the TH, 1 star
You destroy 100% of the base (not counting heroes and decorations) 1 star.

It is % based. No need to change it. If you cant get the TH and 50%, look at your attack strategy. There are many TH10's that 3 star other TH10s.

[bobofclashofclans]

I don't know if the ppl that agree with this r lower lvls but I'm lvl 132 TH10 and trying get TH and 50% against other high/max TH10 is extremely hard. I'm not going to put the idea down then not offer another solution so here is my solution. Get rid of the 3 star system and make it a 5 star system. A star is earned at 25%, 50%, 75%, 100% and as always TH is a star. In total 5 stars. A minimum of 2 stars is needed for a shield to be incurred. I find this would help more during war too since so many mid-low attacks and up with high 90% plus TH atm. Getting so close to perfection and still only getting the same reward as 50% plus TH doesn't seem fair but that is the current system. If u feel this idea can work but needs a little tweak then right ur tweak so we can read it.

I do like this idea. Its a good breakdown.

[ProfChaos]

I'm confused if you're supporting or nay saying one idea or another.

But I think the idea is clear....an attack that results in 50% destruction and the TH for two stars is not nearly equal a very high percentage attack but neglects to destroy the town hall, 70-99%.

As the TH holds a fair share of loot and has very high hp it will be defended and used in base design, but that shouldn't necessarily mean that it is worth a star.

SC could have eliminated the TH snipe augmentation of the game long ago if they had gone to a victory system purely based on overall percent destroyed and it is still a viable and interesting option.