War clan castle donations should count

[OGDevastator]

It would help greatly to promote war cc donations if they counted toward a player's troops donated. I am unsure why it has not been that way from day 1, but if possible it would help morale for filling war cc.

Another addition relating to this is some kind of log for the war cc to show who has donated to them. Keeping players accountable in a clan is important, and knowing who has given to war cc is everything.

[Xav1]

Having war cc donates count towards FIN achievement is ruled out. Here is a statement from SC regarding the subject :

Troop donations made in Clan Wars will not count toward the Friend in Need achievement (or yield XP).

We'd like to make sure your clan mates donate Clan War troops for a single purpose: to win the War. We want Clashers to be motivated by the cause, and not for gems and achievements. We're not saying that every player would donate troops without consideration (most Clashers are loyal), but many would give away the cheapest troops available (like Goblins) simply to climb the achievement ladder.


Now that you can drop unwanted Clan War troops, this would be far too easy to exploit, especially given that, in Clan Wars, there is no cool down period between donations.


Again, most Clashers honor sportsmanlike behavior, but there are players who make the most of loopholes. We don't want fair players to feel like they're getting the raw end of the deal. We believe this to be a reasonable resolution.

[DrizzleDrake]

While I don't think clan war donations should get any achievements or xp (who cares about levels anyways?) there should at least be a way to keep track of who is donating into the war effort. War prep is really resource intensive (a few lava hounds here and a couple of dragons there can really add up). There's often a lack of people willing to deal with the up front costs but are all for the war rewards they get in the end. In several cases with various clans I've been in, the few that donate make up the majority of war prep. They eventually get sick of being the only ones and leave causing the clan to fall into chaos and finger pointing. We gotta find a way to make clan mates accountable for their contributions (or lack there of) to the war effort.

[fubba101]

While I don't think clan war donations should get any achievements or xp (who cares about levels anyways?) there should at least be a way to keep track of who is donating into the war effort. War prep is really resource intensive (a few lava hounds here and a couple of dragons there can really add up). There's often a lack of people willing to deal with the up front costs but are all for the war rewards they get in the end. In several cases with various clans I've been in, the few that donate make up the majority of war prep. They eventually get sick of being the only ones and leave causing the clan to fall into chaos and finger pointing. We gotta find a way to make clan mates accountable for their contributions (or lack there of) to the war effort.

I agree with this statement, I just want the donated troops to show up next to my profile where it says "donated troops". I don't care about the achievements, I just want people to know I'm donating.

[mtommy2597]

A separate record box for war donations would be good. The war donations shouldn't count toward xp because you can just keep dumping them for new troops and it would be easy unlimited xp.

But it would be nice if the donators got some recognition. War troops aren't cheap.

[WernerDerChamp]

I would say, there should be a counter showing how much you've donated in CW, but the counter will count down if someone dropps the troops. Also it won't count for the mission (==> no gems).
But donations for Clan War will be shown in the clan screen.
To counter missuse, Leaders (no Co-Leaders!) should be able to remove troops from every village

[N1NJ4W4RR10R]

They don't so it doesn't in courage very low lvl people to donate if a high lvl person tells them not to, I think anyway