Results 1 to 3 of 3

Thread: Leader Role Reassignment

  1. #1
    Junior Member ClasherRob's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Location
    Fuu Dogs 3
    Posts
    88

    Lightbulb Leader Role Reassignment

    I posted a similar thread in Problems & Bugs (Here) and it was suggested I post in this forum as well.

    As it currently stands, when the Clan Leader leaves the clan, his (or her) role is automatically (as I've been told) pushed to the co-leader who has been in the clan longest. I understand the reasoning behind this, but don't agree with it. Here's why:

    As a Clan Leader who respects my co-leaders, I do not kick, boot, or demote them without just cause. I know and trust all my co-leaders (some on a personal level), as many of you clan leaders do. This does not, however, mean that I can contact them all at any given time. There are times where co-leaders go on vacation/holiday; co-leaders may be on active duty in the military; or they could just be taking a break from Clash of Clans for personal reasons. Point being that a clan leader is not always in touch with his (or her) co-leaders at every moment.

    Additionally, as a clan with multiple sister clans, our co-leaders are constantly moving about for wars and other reasons. So, as they leave the co-leader with the longest time in clan changes to the next person, and the next, and the next. This means that any one of my co-leaders could be next in charge and I would never know who that is on any given day. Today it could be Jason, tomorrow it could be Dave. This adds a level of uncertainty to the game that causes more problems than it fixes.

    Yes, I could assign the new Leader before I leave. And when I am fully aware that I'm moving the Leader out of the clan, I do that. However, stuff happens, mistakes are made, and poof, I've accidentally moved the wrong account out of the clan. This just happened to me for the 1st time in 2 years of Clashing, but I'm sure it's happened to others. Or am I wrong?

    What I'm proposing is a simple safety net (a backup safety net, if you will, just for the Leader), a list of Co-Leaders on the Leader's "Leave" screen. This list would allow the Leader to aptly choose his replacement, as long as there are other co-leaders in the clan. If there are no other co-leaders, but there are still members/elders, then the Leader would be forced to abort the "Leave" screen. This way he (or she) could promote an elder to co-leader and try again. If, however, there are no other members in the clan (Leader makes 1), then the clan would be automatically closed.

    Thanks!
    ClasherRob (TH11, LVL140+, Champion II) (TH9, LVL100+, Masters II)
    Current Clan(s): (Leader) Fuu Dogs 2 & 3 (family: Fuu Dogs)

  2. #2
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Posts
    469
    Not a bad Idea. I see some use for it.

    You could also do something like this:
    If a leader leaves a clan, for the next 10 minutes, that leader can return and be automatically granted his title back. After 10 minutes, the newly appointed leader would become the new leader.
    Once the leader leaves, the secondary would be anointed leader unless the first leader returns within 10 minutes, upon which time the titles would return to what they were before the leader left.

    This would be that safety net with much less programming and graphical interface required to implement.

    The dual account deal is a no-go and they wont respond to a suggestion which states 'my other account'. SC said in the terms only 1 clash account per player, unless I misread.
    Last edited by bobofclashofclans; December 4th, 2015 at 05:19 PM.

  3. #3
    Junior Member ClasherRob's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Location
    Fuu Dogs 3
    Posts
    88
    Quote Originally Posted by bobofclashofclans View Post
    Not a bad Idea. I see some use for it.
    The dual account deal is a no-go and they wont respond to a suggestion which states 'my other account'. SC said in the terms only 1 clash account per player, unless I misread.
    IIRC, it was phrased "One account per device" (I could be wrong) which I do have multiple devices in use.

    Thanks for the input!
    ClasherRob (TH11, LVL140+, Champion II) (TH9, LVL100+, Masters II)
    Current Clan(s): (Leader) Fuu Dogs 2 & 3 (family: Fuu Dogs)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •