All about clan war

[bambambiii]

Not sure if Im the first person who introduce this idea but if I do copy someone's, I prefer to mention it once again.

1: Clan war rewards should be expand in larger scope.

Giving extra bonus loots to the player who got the most heroic attack & defense. For example, 15% bonus of your total war loots given.

or

Extra war loots bonus given to member who can score 3 star. Perhaps in a % as well. Each extra war loot bonus is reduced according to the rank. For example Townhall 10 vs Townhall 9 will get less extra war loot bonus compare to Townhall 10 vs Townhall 10.

2: We hate players who request to join for war but leave in the middle of it.

My idea is to create some sort of record for leavers during war. Players who abandoned the clan during war will actually get recorded and this record can be view by all other players. Therefore, clan leader & co can actually sort out who is reliable to take into war and who is the spoilers.

3: It would be absolutely good if there is a seperate chat from clan war & clan chat. Probably "whisper" chat is good too

That's all for it. Any comments and new ideas pls share so that Supercell can notice it

[Radiating]

Not sure if Im the first person who introduce this idea but if I do copy someone's, I prefer to mention it once again.

1: Clan war rewards should be expand in larger scope.

Giving extra bonus loots to the player who got the most heroic attack & defense. For example, 15% bonus of your total war loots given. Would lead to internal competition and not team work.

or

Extra war loots bonus given to member who can score 3 star. Perhaps in a % as well. Each extra war loot bonus is reduced according to the rank. For example Townhall 10 vs Townhall 9 will get less extra war loot bonus compare to Townhall 10 vs Townhall 10. Any ideas on percentage?

2: We hate players who request to join for war but leave in the middle of it.

My idea is to create some sort of record for leavers during war. Players who abandoned the clan during war will actually get recorded and this record can be view by all other players. Therefore, clan leader & co can actually sort out who is reliable to take into war and who is the spoilers. People can just wait until the war is over an leave. And, what about people who visit others?

3: It would be absolutely good if there is a seperate chat from clan war & clan chat. Probably "whisper" chat is good too Having a seperate chat would cause too much server strain...

That's all for it. Any comments and new ideas pls share so that Supercell can notice it

Responses in bold.

[bambambiii]

Responses in bold.

#Would lead to competition not teamwork
- Competition or teamwork is actually depends the clan members themselves and strategy. Most heroic attack doesn't mean u gotta attack the top ranking in the clan war and vice versa. If u do so, whats the point if u cant even star it? That is why clan startegy is the key! It actually enhance participating members to learn and try their very best to star their opponents. If u say it will lead to competition, I do say it will be a healthy one.

#Any ideas on percentage?
- I'd prefer percentage in range of 10%-15%. Don't really know what exact percentage should it be because giving too high will cause imbalance of the war loots. Too less... not really motivating...

#People can just wait the war is over and leave. And what about the people who visit others?
-I do agree on that. Anyway it is just my draft suggestion. That's why I'd love if someone could comment and especially add on some interesting features or ideas to correct it. What do you mean by people who visiting others?

#Having separate chat will cause server strain
-Agree on it and I have no comment if Supercell about to reply this because I love the smoothness of gameplay instead of adding more & more features but causing server strain and lagging gameplay.