I think there should be more available ranks for clan mates!
Like a lvl between elder n member & a lvl between elder n co!
If u agree plse help me
Yes
No
Maybe
I think there should be more available ranks for clan mates!
Like a lvl between elder n member & a lvl between elder n co!
If u agree plse help me
nah. maybe the ability to have something between leader and CO or be able to select what CO's can do. Like changing the badge or sending mails or even being able to kick out other CO's.
Really, kicking out CO's is the only thing i wish we could have as an option. Our clans leader has been pretty busy with life so the rest of us CO's are really running the clan and being able to boot CO's would be nice.
Ranks are fine. Reality is, there are not that many clearly defined roles in the game and ranks needs to reflect roles to a great extent. Come up some roles and abilities for any new rankings and people might listen.
It often suggested that hidden weapons and traps should be invisible to "new" members to thwart spying but there are too many clans just promoting willy-nilly to overcome this issue. Creating new ranks would just mean these clans promote more often.
Warden's comments on co kicking co, are a different kettle of fish, but maybe sollved by having a rank between co and Leader. I'm Leader of long term stable clan so it's hard to see the benefit.
Some ppl r great elders but not co material! Not fair for them to b in same class as a noob because the noob puts forth effort!Originally Posted by Warden3140
Thats why ATLEAST 1 new rank is needed
Thats the reason I want more options to b able to give ppl that EARN it!!
Am I only one that feels we need more ranks for clan mates?
Yes.. At the very least one additional rank would be nice.. Just as any leader needs incentives and tools to assist in producing desired behavior.. Especially for war clans!!!
I think the rank of advisor should be added. THIS person knows everything the leader knows but is their to hand down advice or orders if the leader can't be as active at times. They could look to his/her advisors.
Sorry I didn't read much into this thread yet time is short. If this has been mentioned. Again sorry.
Why would you want to boot another co? There is only one reason I would boot another co, and I will cover that in a second. First, the road to obtain Co in my clan, and elder, are earned positions. Elder in my clan requires weeks of leadership observing a member offer aid and guidance to other members and leadership. It is not handed away based on donations. Co requires a greater level of commitment with more things required over a period of months to be granted CO.
All elder/co leader appointments has to be voted on by the majority of the co-leadership team, then it is voted on by the elders and co's combined. If an individual passes both votes, they are promoted.
We find that when it is earned, there is a greater level of participation by the members and leadership. It builds a solid clan. We have had many of the same members and have 3 clans with a similar structure and it proves to be very effective. We have built a brotherhood (with some sisters in there too, of-course). All elder/leaders have proven a level of trust and we cherish that. Disputes among the leadership are very brief and usually handled outside of clan chat using a messaging system. Even though we disagree from time to time, the clan comes first. Its not just about 1 person. And if you don't accept that, you would never have been promoted in the first place.
With that said, here is the only reason I would want to boot another Co or even an elder. The player stops playing.
If you want to boot for any other reason, perhaps you should look at how titles are awarded in your clan.
Below is a running thought, by no means do I claim to be the first. It may contain some errors, offer some suggestions if you wish. It is just a thought, nothing more.
Now to expand slightly on removing/demoting cos or leader for inactivity, there could be a voting system added to allow the current co leaders/elders to vote out another co, and by proxy of this ability, also grant a vote ability to remove the Leader should that person stop playing. Removing a leader would require the entire clan to vote for removal, and grant the leader a period of time, say 2 weeks (14 days) to respond to any votes to remove him/her. The leader could convince the clan to allow continued stay with title and thus have the ability to reverse the decision by that notion
*For both Co and Leader removal, the vote system would have 3 options, YAY, NAY, NOLO. (Names of options arent set in stone)
*Nolo is the default vote for all members, effectively undecided/no participation. Upon logging in for the first time after a vote initiation you will be required to view your vote. You will be able to cast a vote of YAY, NAY, or NOLO. If you do not select Yay or NAY, NOLO will be preselected. NOLO will invalidate your spot on the vote roster. Basically your vote wont count in the end tally.
*Yay is in favor of removal.
*Nay is against the removal.
*Voters will be allowed to change their vote at any time as often as they wish within 14 days. The votes will be handled anonymously to prevent chastising a specific member(s) because they wish to keep the contested member.
*For COLEADER removal or demote to elder, all Coleaders and elders would have to vote YAY to remove the contending co or demote the co to elder for possible booting by a co, should that be the decision.
*For LEADER removal or demote to elder, all members, elders, and cos will have to vote YAY. In order to vote a leader out, the clan will have to select which co-leader they wish to name as the new leader before their vote will be allowed.
After a period of 14 days, the vote will lock in and the leader will be demoted and the new leader promoted.
*Now, some will say this isnt fair because some leaders have multiple accounts as co-leaders. To that, all you need is to screenshot the admittance of having the 2nd account in chat and which character it is and report that to SC. The violation will then be handled per the terms of use/service and code of conduct.
*If a person is on a ban exceeding 48 hours, they will not be tallied in the vote roster, thus be unable to vote.
*Any person listed as NEW in the clan roster will not be included in the vote roster.
*Any person that joins following the vote initiation will not be included in the vote roster, regardless of rank within the clan.
*The member up for vote would be allowed to vote as well.
*The vote tally will be based upon YAY or NAY.
*The YAYs must be 75% of the NAY/YAY total. This means that convincing other clan member will be required to remove members of leadership.
*None of this will affect a leader's ability to remove a co, however during the leader vote removal period, the leader cannot remove a co but can remove an elder or member.
*During a Co removal vote period, only the leader can remove an elder. A co will only be able to remove a member during the vote period to remove a co.
*Any member or elder removed during a vote period will have their vote revert back to the default NOLO.
*And an important step, a vote removal of a co or the leader can only be done once in 90 days. This is to prevent abuse that could arise from repeating the vote continuously.
*An elder or a Co would have to que the removal process and would require a 2nd co or elder agreeing to start the vote period. This is to prevent just 1 rogue individual from starting the process.
*A Co is required to initiate the process to remove/demote the leader.
*If a co starts the process, another co would have to vote in favor of starting the vote period
*An Elder or Co is required to start the process to remove/demote a co-leader.
*If an elder starts the process to remove a CO, a Co or elder must 2nd the vote period initiation
*If a clan only has 1 co and no elders, 4 members would be required in place of the 2nd to begin the process.
*If a clan has no co and only 1 elder, 6 members would be required in place of the 2nd to begin the process.
*If a clan has no appointed co or elders, then the process cannot be started.
Last edited by bobofclashofclans; December 4th, 2015 at 05:04 PM.
That is exactly what I'm after
Posting Permissions
