Loot, League Bonuses and Trophy Offers <-- Discuss it HERE!

[BenjaminB]

Good enough I suppose to encourage people to put their TH in.

Why the hell should we have to put our town halls in our bases?? Who gives a ♥♥♥♥? Clash was fun before this new update. Now I prepared my base for it and I got attacked 5 times in 10 minutes and never once got a shield. I lost 600,00 elixir. What the hell SuperCell?? You're messing up a great game.

[newupdateblowsdoublyhard]

Pre-Update life of a casual:
Collects collectors...doesn't raid because doesn't want to break shield. Gets raided after his 12 hours are up.

Post-Update life of a casual:
Collects collectors... raids because he can attack through his shield. Gets raided after his shield is used up.

Synopsis:
Nothing changed except allowing said casual to raid.
Before someone tries to retort in saying that he will lose shield time, let me state this point:

Yes he will lose 3 hours of his shield time but this is negated due to the net profit after said raid.
One barch collector raid can provide on average 250k, a storage raid will provide 200k-300k so we will keep our average attack at 250k. In the 3 hours that he lost, if he had max collectors, he would produce 63k gold/elixir. So in losing those 3 hours but gaining on average of 250k, his NET profit is always going to be 100k+. The new system allows for a casual to get an attack in here and there without worry. So in my conclusion, I state that this new system will allow casuals to have the freedom to raid and actually progress even faster than before.

Here's the difference between casuals before and after as I see it playing out.

Pre-update:
Sniped. 50-50 if he/she gets collector raided depending on loot. Most likely storage not touched unless he is saving up for an update

Post Update:
Collector raided. If the attacker decides to move in on storage(s) shield. If not he/she sits around the queue until he/she gets storage raided.

None of these scenarios you guys outline have their collectors with decent loot in them. It seems to be on the basis solely of storage's which is not all that useful. Even a fairly active player (non-casual) is going to have some loot in his collectors. Strange how thats never taken into account.

[Lilidan]

These threads have become so annoying, I think its fair enough to say that we should stop beating the dead horse, it's been dead for a week now and there is barely anything left of it.

The horse was beaten to death long ago, decomposed, fertilized the tree and now they are beating the tree.

[Barcher007]

"Casual players" won't do as well as hard core clashers!?!?! What the h#LL were they thinking? We need an update to focus on making sure casual players can do just as good if not better than hard core players. How about a loot tax on the top 1%?

[TheRealGinngie]

Here's the difference between casuals before and after as I see it playing out.

Pre-update:
Sniped. 50-50 if he/she gets collector raided depending on loot. Most likely storage not touched unless he is saving up for an update

Post Update:
Collector raided. If the attacker decides to move in on storage(s) shield. If not he/she sits around the queue until he/she gets storage raided.

None of these scenarios you guys outline have their collectors with decent loot in them. It seems to be on the basis solely of storage's which is not all that useful. Even a fairly active player (non-casual) is going to have some loot in his collectors. Strange how thats never taken into account.

I'm sorry but can you please provide some numbers so I can understand what you're saying?

So is it that you're trying to say the average looter would ignore the storages because of what's inside the collectors after sniping the town hall? I don't wish to retort unless I fully understand what you're trying to get at.

[noobishnoob]

Again this is just in theory. We need to see how exactly the update affects us.

[Fury8]

Why the hell should we have to put our town halls in our bases?? Who gives a ♥♥♥♥? Clash was fun before this new update. Now I prepared my base for it and I got attacked 5 times in 10 minutes and never once got a shield. I lost 600,00 elixir. What the hell SuperCell?? You're messing up a great game.

Wait till after the update before switching to a new layout. If you do it now it's like sticking an even bigger target on your back!

I did it for fun while experimenting with the timing bug yesterday and lost 6000 dark, mostly due to my own stupidity I have to add. Had a accidental spawn hole and then forgot to change back to farming base.

[TheRealGinngie]

The horse was beaten to death long ago, decomposed, fertilized the tree and now they are beating the tree.

This is signature worthy

[BoardGuest808888]

It's possible actually quite easy do a collector raid with less then 30% of your army.

Casuals will possibly get collector farmed then storage farmed before getting a shield now. So those that are calculating losses based on two raids a day may want to revise their figures.

If a player let his collectors farmed by others, then he is not a casual. He is clearly not playing anymore.

[ProfChaos]

It's possible actually quite easy do a collector raid with less then 30% of your army.

Casuals will possibly get collector farmed then storage farmed before getting a shield now. So those that are calculating losses based on two raids a day may want to revise their figures.

If in this scenario you are the defender, then you have an exceptionally poor base and should really take some time off from posting and work on it.