Do not implement these new Shield changes - or revert them immediately!

[blombardo]

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...=1#post5850389

"Conversely, players who try to work around the shield system will get no shield at all."

A very effective way to earn money is to push trophies - by sniping town halls - and taking advantage of the win bonuses awarded by higher level leagues. This can be done every 5 minutes and doesnt require spending 90 minutes building a proper war attack army.

A very solid way to get a shield - so that you can prepare for clan war - is to leave a th outside and let it get sniped easily.

I can see by the decisions made by supercell in the past; the powers that be want to make it so that they encourage giant full powerhouse style army camps - that take ages to build... to promote players to use GEMS to speed up the process... because supercell - is a business - and wants to make money.


This shield decision has nothing to do with improving game play - it is being implemented to improve the companies bottom line.

Getting 1 star - and a shield - and a win with sniping the TH is a staple of the game play.

You should not take this away from us.


-What about those of us who use Super Queen walk? 4 healers - high level queen - we can kill 60% of a base using just those units... that is 20% or less of our army capacity -- so your telling us that we will not get a shield every time someone does that to us?

This decision your making is NOT going to improve gameplay; I think it will hurt it significantly.

Here is an OLDER 14 page post talking about this exact issue from a while back:
"Stop with the Exposed Town Hall Attacks"
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...-Attacks/page4

Just about every reply there also agreed that leaving TH's out for a shield - is a good thing that should be left alone.

[Abushagrath]

Stop it ,,, sc become crazy

[WernerDerChamp]

"Conversely, players who try to work around the shield system will get no shield at all."

-What about those of us who use Super Queen walk? 4 healers - high level queen - we can kill 60% of a base using just those units... that is 20% or less of our army capacity -- so your telling us that we will not get a shield every time someone does that to us?

This decision your making is NOT going to improve gameplay; I think it will hurt it significantly.

I think that too, NO shild for a TH outside? To reduce the shild time to one hour or even 30 minutes would be a soulution (because you can get offline for a few minutes without worrying about loosing your CC-Troops for war)

- In my clan it works this way, you request, if you need bigger troops someone will answer that he's building it. If you are just a few seconds to late, someone might allready attack you, and he will go for 3 stars mostly, so the castle will be cleared. And if you get lucky, you will not even get a shield.

The thing with the queen is terrible, Queen and 7 Healers behind and you can get 2 stars at TH 8, loosing a massive amount of loot and the next one might do it again, maybe your storages are empty in an hour.

In Legend League, that system (attack without breaking shild) will result into even less targets.

I hope that the Village Guard fixes all these problems

[RyanIndy317]

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...=1#post5850389

"Conversely, players who try to work around the shield system will get no shield at all."

A very effective way to earn money is to push trophies - by sniping town halls - and taking advantage of the win bonuses awarded by higher level leagues. This can be done every 5 minutes and doesnt require spending 90 minutes building a proper war attack army.

A very solid way to get a shield - so that you can prepare for clan war - is to leave a th outside and let it get sniped easily.

I can see by the decisions made by supercell in the past; the powers that be want to make it so that they encourage giant full powerhouse style army camps - that take ages to build... to promote players to use GEMS to speed up the process... because supercell - is a business - and wants to make money.


This shield decision has nothing to do with improving game play - it is being implemented to improve the companies bottom line.

Getting 1 star - and a shield - and a win with sniping the TH is a staple of the game play.

You should not take this away from us.


-What about those of us who use Super Queen walk? 4 healers - high level queen - we can kill 60% of a base using just those units... that is 20% or less of our army capacity -- so your telling us that we will not get a shield every time someone does that to us?

This decision your making is NOT going to improve gameplay; I think it will hurt it significantly.

I agree this sucks bad!! Im sure the th is still worth a star and loot bonus...new should all protest and all leave th out and rack up loot bonuses until we are full!

[DutchdestroyerNL]

Yup a th is a star worth. So supercell must give a free shield.

I want keep the old shield system. Not this new ♥♥♥♥ shield system.

BTW: lets make from this thread a petition to let people sign to keep the old shield system.

[WernerDerChamp]

Yup a th is a star worth. So supercell must give a free shield.

I want keep the old shield system. Not this new ♥♥♥♥ shield system.

BTW: lets make from this thread a petition to let people sign to keep the old shield system.

I agree

At least 30-90 minutes, that will cause less people to put out TH, but still makes it possible to give some cups away if you don't want to loose your shield. And attacking will instantly break any TH shilds.

I've allready started a thread about this new system:

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...st-of-the-loot

[PoliceNaviDot]

You know all those storage raids you find when searching with 400K+ of each resource?

Me neither!


That's because near about anybody who has that much loot, is going to want to keep it. So, they stick their town hall outside, and pay 7 cups for a 12 hour shield.

With the new system, they will not be able to hide behind a shield, so there will be MUCH more loot going around the economy. Especially from those that quit because of the shields!

[WernerDerChamp]

You know all those storage raids you find when searching with 400K+ of each resource?

Me neither!


That's because near about anybody who has that much loot, is going to want to keep it. So, they stick their town hall outside, and pay 7 cups for a 12 hour shield.

With the new system, they will not be able to hide behind a shield, so there will be MUCH more loot going around the economy. Especially from those that quit because of the shields!

ER, you can't get only 400 k out of storages only when attacking TH 10, 350k from TH9, 300k from TH8, 250k from TH7 and 200k from TH 6 and lower. If you don't find a abandoned base you will mostly not get much more than this. And don't forget TH difference...

[blombardo]

You know all those storage raids you find when searching with 400K+ of each resource?

Me neither!


That's because near about anybody who has that much loot, is going to want to keep it. So, they stick their town hall outside, and pay 7 cups for a 12 hour shield.

With the new system, they will not be able to hide behind a shield, so there will be MUCH more loot going around the economy. Especially from those that quit because of the shields!

Your wrong --

Why ?

I get a shield... --- then I can attack.. and not break my shield...

so I still have a shield... I'll get all my stolen dark and gold back when I revenge that player... so they will break even... and I will still have a shield... so nobody else will get my loot


--OR I wont have a shield... and I'll get attacked again and again and again until I'm 100% broke and can never upgrade anything...

Either way - the players loose with this new setting - and supercell wins.. because players will have to GEM for a shield - for an army - or for whatever.... which seems to be their goal...

[WernerDerChamp]

Your wrong --

Why ?

I get a shield... --- then I can attack.. and not break my shield...

so I still have a shield... I'll get all my stolen dark and gold back when I revenge that player... so they will break even... and I will still have a shield... so nobody else will get my loot


--OR I wont have a shield... and I'll get attacked again and again and again until I'm 100% broke and can never upgrade anything...

Either way - the players loose with this new setting - and supercell wins.. because players will have to GEM for a shield - for an army - or for whatever.... which seems to be their goal...

I think that too. The village guard is the last chance for SC to fix it, or I will probably quit, when I can't upgrade my TH 9 things anymore