New Game mode / base style option (Boom Beach style attack / defense mode)

[SirAzura]

I think it would be fun to be able to make a base layout like Supercell's newer game "Boom Beach" where it's more like a D-Day style attack and defense. There could be normal base layouts and war base layouts (what we already have), and then have a third option (maybe a different world ranked bracket?) where you can set up your base like Boom Beach (having the enemy attack from one side like a beach front and working their way through the defenses to the other side with the town hall). I think with the tools that we're provided already in this game that it would be a fun challenge mode. Especially for players with completely maxed out bases who have been playing a long time so that the game is spiced up with some more variety. Thoughts? Constructive Criticism?

[ironagedave]

I think it would be fun to be able to make a base layout like Supercell's newer game "Boom Beach" where it's more like a D-Day style attack and defense. There could be normal base layouts and war base layouts (what we already have), and then have a third option (maybe a different world ranked bracket?) where you can set up your base like Boom Beach (having the enemy attack from one side like a beach front and working their way through the defenses to the other side with the town hall). I think with the tools that we're provided already in this game that it would be a fun challenge mode. Especially for players with completely maxed out bases who have been playing a long time so that the game is spiced up with some more variety. Thoughts? Constructive Criticism?

Because they are two quite different variations of the same theme I would vote no initially, however I would be open to something like this on more levels of goblin campaign - (i still don't know what the goblin king looks like it's time for the big showdown) or that it was part of some sort of regular rewards and/or challenges.

I just don't think it should be intergrated in a mainstream kind of way because there are significant differences and some people may not even like the boom beach game - but they do like clash. Also would it make Boom beach more redundant?

[SirAzura]

Because they are two quite different variations of the same theme I would vote no initially, however I would be open to something like this on more levels of goblin campaign - (i still don't know what the goblin king looks like it's time for the big showdown) or that it was part of some sort of regular rewards and/or challenges.

I just don't think it should be intergrated in a mainstream kind of way because there are significant differences and some people may not even like the boom beach game - but they do like clash. Also would it make Boom beach more redundant?

I mean it wouldn't be a required thing. I'm talking about a completely separate and optional ranked bracket / mode for people to play and experiment with. People might not like boom beach, but that doesn't mean that a similar style of base set up in Clash wouldn't be really fun. I'm only using Boom beach to give people a better visual idea of the base layout of attackers only coming from one side and having the base on the other side (kind of like a chess board i guess?). I'm not suggesting that we use Boom beach mechanics like the U-Boats, flares, emps, etc etc...

[ironagedave]

I mean it wouldn't be a required thing. I'm talking about a completely separate and optional ranked bracket / mode for people to play and experiment with. Like I said I am kind of open to this People might not like boom beach, but that doesn't mean that a similar style of base set up in Clash wouldn't be really fun. No disagreement here from me tbh there needs to be some more variation in clash particularly so that it can envolve new troops perhaps battle seiges etc. I'm only using Boom beach to give people a better visual idea of the base layout of attackers only coming from one side and having the base on the other side (kind of like a chess board i guess?). I'm not suggesting that we use Boom beach mechanics like the U-Boats, flares, emps, etc etc... but the principles (ie the mechanics) are the same flares uboats etc is just window dressing items imo

Comments in red, I think you got an idea in the making but just think a little more out the box other than things that already currently exist i.e. clan wars, boom beach etc. what we need is something refreshing and enticing to keep the interest in clash going.

[SirAzura]

Comments in red, I think you got an idea in the making but just think a little more out the box other than things that already currently exist i.e. clan wars, boom beach etc. what we need is something refreshing and enticing to keep the interest in clash going.

Yep, I totally get where you're coming from and appreciate your input. Mayhaps if not this style / layout, then a different game mode? I can't really think of anything else off the top of my head. I just really enjoy the thought of how different base layouts could be if you could put your town hall to one side of the board and they have to attack from the other end. I think it would lead to radically different army compositions and strategies. Also, if we had access to the attack options of boom beach (like a flare that directs armies where to attack for example)in clash, people could destroy so hard just with that. I think a beach front invasion style attack/ defense mode would be a lot harder to accomplish (and more rewarding upon success) in Clash with the current tools provided.

[Radiating]

Only problem here is you now have two of pretty much the same game cannabalizing each other: that'd certainly be bad for profits so I don't see this happening.

[Temur]

I would add in some type of ship that fires stuffif this were to happen