there should be some sort of penalty for clan hoppers. i know theres the 24hr wait thing or whateva for leaving during wars but there should also be another penalty like it should cost a certain amount of gems to join and leave.. also more builder huts would be nice! or even bein able to upgrade the builders so they build faster would be kool too.. and it would be super kool if we could purchase gems with gold/elixer...
Eh, I wouldn't be joining any clans (Though I am already in one) if you had to pay gems just to get in.Originally Posted by xoBATMANox
Also, the gems purchasable with gold and elixir, and the upgrading Builder Huts idea is ruled out, sorry.
Last edited by Vexives; November 11th, 2015 at 10:45 PM.
It is not a coincidence that every time this topic surfaces in a new thread the OP is a fresh spawn.
Make it worthwhile for people to stay in your clan and they will. And be mindful of who you recruit. Why is what you want (for people to stay in your clan) more valid than what they want (to leave your clan)?
Reddigulous
NinjaSonicElite
what about the ones who join. saying theyre down for wars.. donate and recieve troops.. then leave for no reason... during preperation day. having to pay with gems will stop them from clan hopping! like seeing someone not eligable for wars shows they leave during wars n i dont put them in war..
Have members sit out for the first war, and if they stay, put them in. If they leave, they leave. So what?
If they leave when you put them after you sit them out, then they're just trolling. Too bad, so sad.
maybe a "member timer" ?
lvl 74 TH8 | #LRY9CVL | Gem Squad Leader | #LRGOVVCO
For starters: Grammar: *they're, *receive *preparation, *eligible, *don't.
Your first mistake was believing what some stranger from global told you. Your second mistake was letting a "new" player into war...
We ask our players to backup tall claims with affirmative action. Our clan has never, NOT ONCE lost a player during prep day.. Why? Because we manage our clan like a.. well... Clan No new players for war, Period. They must show strong replays, period.
The same player that jumps ship because you won't let him war being new- is the exact same player who will leave during prep day.
Nothing will stop them from hopping if they are hoppers. Nothing. Trust me.
And you can't take someone's word on being 'down for wars'. If they are a hopper then they are also likely to lie about being a hopper. However, you can force them to prove their loyalty. Leave them out of wars for the first week they are there. If they are hoppers they will likely leave. If they are not they will likely stay (assuming your clan has something to offer them).
Also, please understand there are some valid reasons for leaving a clan during prep day. Perhaps a player finds themselves brought to war even when they were opted out and their clan is verbally abusive or racist. Just saying...
Reddigulous
NinjaSonicElite
Its fine to leave after the war. But during a war that just offsets the balance of the war. that could be a loss of 6 stars right there! And if 2 leave that could make a difference between winning or losing. I did put in a thread here about two weeks ago on the topic.
Or supercell should allow two more attacks to the player that is the closest level to the one that decided to bail out on you during the war. However, they say that loyal members just do not do that. It can happen anytime loyal player or not. But most likely a hopper than a loyal player. I rarely had a loyal player do that only just twice in 3 months. You just never know???
When I first started I had many hoppers sometimes 3 during a war. Now I just make sure they sighn in on our website. If they do they are probably going to stay during the war.
You can check out how we implement this. go to gamasharks.tripod.com to see our clan war sign up.
Last edited by prosper12; November 12th, 2015 at 01:32 AM.
NO WAY! How much would it be anyway? 250 gems? THATS WAY TOO MUCH! 1 gem is way to much. It should be 0. If they leave they leave. Screw them. IF they don't stay they don't care.
Posting Permissions
