Idea about WAR SPY!

[BJanGa]

Hi all Chiefs out there, welcome to my Thread about "The war spy"!
I have been thinking about starting such a thread for long time a go to see what the Clash of Clans Community really think about that idea but never had time for it until now!

Many war clans uses third party apps to avoid having a spy involved in their war and because of that they have their clan CLOSED all the time and do recruiting via another app.
As a farming clan we dont like to have our clan closed and dont like to complicate the normal join option with several other apps. It should be easy to join a clan as it is normally.But it has cost us a lot when it comes to war spy.

Now back to my idea about what to do to avoid a war spy!

1. No "NEW" tag guys should be able to see traps on war map or CC troops until themselves are involved and or are on war map!
2. No "NEW" tag guys should be able to open the war map. War map should stay disabled for all members with "NEW" tag until themselves are involved and or are on war map!

We dont war with new joiners, but there is for sure other clans which do that.If now the clan trust a new guy and want to let him/her see everything, they can promote them to elder and demote them back to member again to let them see everything if this member is not involved on war.

We have lost several wars because of that, we did lose previous wars because of the same problem.
If you come on or already have a better idea, I would love to see it, and add it here to have more options to avoid anyone who tries to play an ufair game.

[Jrap21]

Hey thats basically the same idea I have in my New Leadership Roles Thread (which is in my sig)

[Rue73]

Why not keep the clan closed when you are waring and recruit new members when you are not?
I keep our clan closed all the time and just open the doors if I have a new member come along.

[cargovroomvroom]

What if I wanted a visitor friend to critique a war base?

[BJanGa]

Hey thats basically the same idea I have in my New Leadership Roles Thread (which is in my sig)

Im so sorry, i didnt find any results when i searched before i made this thread.Tried several times but didnt find anything.

Why not keep the clan closed when you are waring and recruit new members when you are not?
I keep our clan closed all the time and just open the doors if I have a new member come along.

We do small back to back wars like 10vs10/15vs15, a bit difficult to keep our clan closed all the time or easier said 48 hours, because there is always someone who leaves us and who wants to join us back.
We do not use other apps like I said, and we are not a new beginner clan. We have many old friends who have left us because of some reason, and it is precisely why we want to allow them to join us back when they want without complicate it all for them. It should be as easy as it is to join your home clan.

The same applies when we want more new friends, all clans out there always want 50/50 players, (we want it).If someone leaves us then we dare not to have our clan open to those who want to join, because then you increase the risk of a spy with open clan.

What if I wanted a visitor friend to critique a war base?

If you now trust someone whit "NEW" tag, what you can do is giving him a rank or there should be ability for leader/co-leaders to let him see the warmap/cc troops/traps etc.

[Temur]

I saw an idea exactly like this and yes I want it