New members joining your clan are unable to see the current war.

[RedJon]

Just an idea for when you war preparations starts, any new members you except cannot see the war map until it has finished or if they are promoted to say elder or co-leader and then they can see it? This would help excepting new members without the worry of the new member being a spy, and also promoting a new member would help if say you wanted to help another clan and still participate in observing the war.
Also members in war can leave and return with no effect.

please let me know if this is a good or bad idea
thank you 👹👍🏻

[herranton]

Just an idea for when you war preparations starts, any new members you except cannot see the war map until it has finished or if they are promoted to say elder or co-leader and then they can see it? This would help excepting new members without the worry of the new member being a spy, and also promoting a new member would help if say you wanted to help another clan and still participate in observing the war.
Also members in war can leave and return with no effect.

please let me know if this is a good or bad idea
thank you 👹👍🏻

But then we wouldn't be able to spy.

[Radiating]

But then we wouldn't be able to spy.

That's the exact point of this idea. @OP I personally support it and I suggest you make a petition if you would like for your voice to be better heard.

[kyleksq]

Yes- this is a good idea.

Clans should be able to recruit and accept new players, without the dark cloud of concern lingering- wondering if you just let a spy into the clan.

Adding this feature would end all arguments about war spies.

[herranton]

Adding this feature would end all arguments about war spies.

Nah, it would just give us supecell's opinion about them, just like with de zappers. I can still make an argument that de zapping should be in the game. It doesn't end anything. Fwiw, I neither zapped nor spy, but I don't think either are problems.

[PokeManiac]

I don't understand why spying is wrong ? It's not a glitch or error. Pure talent , stealth and persuasion .

It's not a problem if you keep clans invite only and see who are your enemies.

[Oditio]

Just an idea for when you war preparations starts, any new members you except cannot see the war map until it has finished or if they are promoted to say elder or co-leader and then they can see it? This would help excepting new members without the worry of the new member being a spy, and also promoting a new member would help if say you wanted to help another clan and still participate in observing the war.
Also members in war can leave and return with no effect.

please let me know if this is a good or bad idea
thank you 👹👍🏻

It's a very good IDEA. Vote for you

[RedJon]

It's a very good IDEA. Vote for you

thank you for the response ����
i have started a poll

[thejbr12]

It's not a problem if you keep clans invite only and see who are your enemies.

This doesn't stop the spies who leave their clan before the war starts, then when the match is made request to join your clan.

You don't see how it's a problem? Some clans war nonstop and you can't recruit during war unless you don't mind spies. Your options are limited to: 1. Don't recruit ever; 2. Recruit between wars only, which may mean taking an entire day off from war to actually find some good members, rather than recruiting right along; 3. Recruit, but know you will get spies.

This is a good idea.

[hoopstime98]

This doesn't stop the spies who leave their clan before the war starts, then when the match is made request to join your clan.

You don't see how it's a problem? Some clans war nonstop and you can't recruit during war unless you don't mind spies. Your options are limited to: 1. Don't recruit ever; 2. Recruit between wars only, which may mean taking an entire day off from war to actually find some good members, rather than recruiting right along; 3. Recruit, but know you will get spies.

This is a good idea.

It also doesn't stop everyone and their brother who have minis these days. I have 3 accounts in 3 clans. Knowing who is in my clan right now does nothing to stop me from asking to join from another account. Minis as so common these days there's no way around that. I like the idea (or frankly, just don't let anyone who isn't in the war see traps).