Results 1 to 5 of 5

Thread: Clan search - define by (minimum) age [e.g. already many 18+ clans in existence]

  1. #1
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Apr 2015
    Posts
    79

    Clan search - define by (minimum) age [e.g. already many 18+ clans in existence]

    EDIT: this is by no means a thread to change the application grounds to a clan (which is ruled out). Only to add an extra search criterion, which could even be added through search by clan description as quite a lot of clans already have 18+ in their name or description!

    TLDR: Please add a search function for clans to define by age. Preferably by the ages of 12+,16+,18+,(23+),(30+). Reason: people want to play with their own age group, strategy to win wars rather problematic with younger players as they (sometimes/usually) lack insight or the will to listen to rational tactics, which is not negative for their age, but undesired by the older players who play to win. Also behavioristic differences apply and no real problems should arise by defining clan search by age.

    This suggestion is posed as a possible solution for a problem that is most probably a problem for the (relatively) older players among us and not so much for the high school attendees. The thing is that I, and probably a lot of others, would really like to play the game with people of my own age. For me personally that is 18-28 (or older idc). Given the huge amount of clans that state ''18+ clan'', or have a name like 18+ or 18 plus, there is a need among the adult community to be able to distinguish the youngster community from the adult community. Especially now that communication has become key to winning Clan Wars. Communication is usually what lacks in the clans where there are a lot of high school attendees (or even pre school (!) ). Not only communication lacks often, but what I also find lacking the sense for coordinated strategy.

    Even though 18 years or 28 years is no guarantee that the problems of communication and lack of sensible strategy will disappear, however, the thing I find most disturbing are the ever ongoing discussions and the utter lack of insight that results of earlier stated problems. The goal is thus not solving those problems, as they are inherent to human nature, but rather to minimize the problems.

    The problem for us 18+ people is, however, how in the world do we find these 18+ clans? Not all 18+ clans are called 18+ or a variation of that. So what I propose is to add a search opportunity that adds the define by preferred age. Possible categories could be <none>, <12+>, <16+>, <18+>, <30+> etc. This age defining should not be an official requirement to join - which is usually already the case in many 18+ clans - but rather a wish or preferred age.

    This, however, would not be a guarantee for us to find clans with only 18+ year olds. People can still lie about their age and join a clan that is actually looking for e.g. 18+ members. The thing is: if you can search for preferred age, the average age should go up as supply and demand is able to find itself. Thus adding the search function to define by age would be an improvement of our game experience.

    Given the player base, many (perhaps most) of which are probably between 12-18, this should by no means be seen as a way to divide the player base while decreasing the playability for the rest of the population. As the majority is probably <18, the results should be that the 18+ community has a chance to easier find like minded individuals, which is now already the case in the 18+ clans etc, and the <18 community should not experience negative results because of it. Because they are the majority to begin with if I am not mistaken and if they are able to behave as an 18 year old, which 16+ should be able to do online, they would still be able to play with everyone, whereas the 18+ community would not have a negative relation with it, because they are under the impression of the player being 18+, thus solving the problems.
    Last edited by Flippert2812; October 17th, 2015 at 11:05 AM.

  2. #2
    Forum Contender devil9394's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    In bed, just pretending I'm a carrot.
    Posts
    4,796
    The problem is, there is no way in which the accounts will be linked to a number, their age. SuperCell won't ask now every player how old they are, and even if they did, players could still lie about that.
    Unfortunately, nothing can be done for this matter. My clan is also for 18+ and what we usually do is ask for a Facebook account to look at before accepting in the clan; with this requirement, we check their age and decide whether to keep or not. If they don't have Facebook, they cannot join our clan. This is just a solution for this matter, there may be more of them but you will need to try.
    Quote Originally Posted by BRLESNAR View Post
    Mr.Devil does have a quality that he gives formal and good posts. A man of intellect, sorry, a demon of intellect.
    Quote Originally Posted by DaOneNOnly799 View Post
    It seems that we have a devilish devil here; that even the devil himself approves.
    "Trust those who seek the truth but doubt those who say they have found it."

  3. #3
    Senior Member AhsenAshraful's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2015
    Location
    Pakistan
    Posts
    216
    Quote Originally Posted by devil9394 View Post
    The problem is, there is no way in which the accounts will be linked to a number, their age. SuperCell won't ask now every player how old they are, and even if they did, players could still lie about that.
    Unfortunately, nothing can be done for this matter. My clan is also for 18+ and what we usually do is ask for a Facebook account to look at before accepting in the clan; with this requirement, we check their age and decide whether to keep or not. If they don't have Facebook, they cannot join our clan. This is just a solution for this matter, there may be more of them but you will need to try.
    Mr. Devil, may people have wrong date of birth on facebook. Many people fake their age on facebook.
    Moving away from the once great land that was Clash.

  4. #4
    Forum Contender devil9394's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    In bed, just pretending I'm a carrot.
    Posts
    4,796
    Quote Originally Posted by AhsenAshraful View Post
    Mr. Devil, may people have wrong date of birth on facebook. Many people fake their age on facebook.
    I am for one year in my clan and never had any issues, I suppose there will always be a risk of false information but at least this option filters some of that. It's easy to distinguish an account just created from an old one from the date of the photos, events, number of friends, likes, etc.
    Quote Originally Posted by BRLESNAR View Post
    Mr.Devil does have a quality that he gives formal and good posts. A man of intellect, sorry, a demon of intellect.
    Quote Originally Posted by DaOneNOnly799 View Post
    It seems that we have a devilish devil here; that even the devil himself approves.
    "Trust those who seek the truth but doubt those who say they have found it."

  5. #5
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Apr 2015
    Posts
    79
    @devil. You could solve that problem by adding a preferred age in the clan section and then have the search engine relate to that if the searcher so desires. This won't solve poser problem (as already explained in original post), but it would at least give 18+ clans the opportunity to have a different name than 18+ as they are otherwise hardly findable.
    Last edited by Flippert2812; October 17th, 2015 at 11:09 AM.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •