Leaving The Clan when participating in clan war

[barbayani]

Hi,

We have a problem most of the times with new clan members. The problem is when we start the clan war someone leaves the clan. So this means we start it with -2 wars.

So in the future can you create a new system that game not allows the person to leave the clan who is participating in clan war.

This can be helpful for most of the clans !

Thanks

[Pardus]

I don't think this is a thing that should be prevented by SC, don't put people in war who you are not 99% sure will stay. Supercell's job is to keep the game fresh and balanced not to play police

[awesomness2016]

Requested constantly. Never going to happen. This is a clan management problem and not a Supercell problem. It can easily be solved by not letting new players you are not sure will be loyal participate in wars....you already have the power to do this.


Forcing people to stay does not guarantee they will attack, and even if they do they could drop a troop and surrender, or maybe even fill your requests with goblins and wallbreakers.

[kyleksq]

First and foremost: If you have a problem with players leaving during prep day- you have a clan management issue. In no way, shape, or form is this SC's problem.

Solution: Consider not letting anyone *new* go to war. The same player that will leave your clan because of this rule, is the same player that would leave during prep day anyway. Better to lose them before war.

Why this is a terrible idea: What guarantee would forcing someone to stay in the clan provide? -- None. What motivation does the stuck player have to build a proper war base vs a troll base giving the enemy an easy 3 star? None. What solution would locking a player in the clan provide? None.

Manage your clan better, or join a clan that is more effectively managed.

Clash on!

[MrJackrabbit]

Easy solution. Grow slower. If you have a solid group of 10 attackers war 20v20 even if 10 leave you should still do good. A few will stay and maybe make you core stronger then you can expand larger. Building a clan is a marathon not a sprint. Good luck. Even -2 you will have more than enough attacks.