Clan Chat Activity

[pixlon]

It would be great if there was an feature so you can see how active a clan chat is. So if you are looking for a communicative or a more quiet clan, this little feature will help you. The chat activity can be low, normal, high or very high. To prevent a advantage of activity for larger clans, the weekly counted messages are divided by the amount of members.


0- 5 messages a day per member: low
6- 20 : normal
21- 50: high
More than 50: very high

Please give feedback! Would it be worth to implement it? At least it isn't complicated.
thx

[HungryHungryHippo]

It would be great if there was an feature so you can see how active a clan chat is. So if you are looking for a communicative or a more quiet clan, this little feature will help you. The chat activity can be low, normal, high or very high.

0- 25 messages a day: low
26- 75 : normal
76- 160: high
More than 160: very high

Please give feedback! Would it be worth to implement it? At least it isn't complicated.
thx

You forgot to take into account that depending on the day activity might variate. I don't know how often this status would change according to daily messages/weekly average/permanent average?

- In case of daily messages the status would be too variable and badly represented on days with lesser activity. This would mean clan are only able to recruit the appropriate audience on days they meet their average activity.

- In case of weekly averages it would all be about what day do we (re)start counting? If the postcount would start on mondays all clans who show more activity in the weekend would be greatly disadvantaged as they would have a negative score during the week and when their average finally gets on par the status will get reset again =(

- In case of a permanent record of the chat activity i think the data is just too much to save and keep cracking down in 1 average percentage. I know casual clans might face 100 messages a day but my clan for example deals with 500-1000 messages a day on average. This would simply be too much to preserve imo.

Also with the divisioning you are proposing right now large clans will greatly benefit compared to smaller clans. A clan with 10 members would have to post 5x the amount of post per person compared to a 50 member clan would have. I want to suggest that this divisioning will be calculated on ''Posts Per Person'' over a period of time. That would give all clans the same chance on recruiting members based on member chat activity.

[pixlon]

You forgot to take into account that depending on the day activity might variate. I don't know how often this status would change according to daily messages/weekly average/permanent average?

- In case of daily messages the status would be too variable and badly represented on days with lesser activity. This would mean clan are only able to recruit the appropriate audience on days they meet their average activity.

- In case of weekly averages it would all be about what day do we (re)start counting? If the postcount would start on mondays all clans who show more activity in the weekend would be greatly disadvantaged as they would have a negative score during the week and when their average finally gets on par the status will get reset again =(

- In case of a permanent record of the chat activity i think the data is just too much to save and keep cracking down in 1 average percentage. I know casual clans might face 100 messages a day but my clan for example deals with 500-1000 messages a day on average. This would simply be too much to preserve imo.

Also with the divisioning you are proposing right now large clans will greatly benefit compared to smaller clans. A clan with 10 members would have to post 5x the amount of post per person compared to a 50 member clan would have. I want to suggest that this divisioning will be calculated on ''Posts Per Person'' over a period of time. That would give all clans the same chance on recruiting members based on member chat activity.

I think the messages would be counted weekly and then divided by 7 so there is a average result. Then this number is divided by the amount of members in the clan.
Ps: Your old signature was better...