Clan war . You can not leave now !

[Temur]

you can't just jail in a person when he is in war while he wants to leave that is a very bad concept It seems cruel

[Tucsy]

Bad idea.

1. If a person doesn't want to use their attacks, they WILL NOT use their attacks even if they are trapped in the clan during the war, so that's the point?

2. People might go out for other purposes other than purely leaving the clan such as going out to spy enemies or join other clans for higher troops, etc.

3. Imagine if you choose to opt out of war but the leader somewhat decides to include you in the war anyway... oh great I'm trapped for another 2 days.


As others have stated, penalising for not using both attacks would be a much better solution.

[Tucsy]

To join clan war, all members will deduct 100 gems, after using one attack, 50 gems will repay, after 2nd attack, another 50 gems will replay. If using this method, ppl that join war sure use both attacks, hahahaha

Maybe instead of gems people can 'deposit' a certain amount of gold, and will get half back with each attack. However, this would also lead to people pressing the attack button and surrender immediately after.

Like I said, if a person doesn't want to attack, you can't force them to since you have no control over their action. They can use both attacks with 0% damage and there's nothing you can do about it (other than kicking them out). The best solution for this is adopting better clan management, that's the ultimate solution for anything.

[LemoneyFresh937]

I can NOT BELIEVE this is still under discussion! We are never going to turn clans into a prison or a feudal lord type scenario! Nobody should have to pay a security deposit on their attacks, and they should have the freedom to leave whenever they want to.

[xSnippy]

How about you can leave but you get penalised for leaving during war?

You already are. You cannot war for the amount of time left in the war when you left. Also, some clans, such as my own, don't accept people who have left a clan during war into the clan. The penalty should be decided by those in the clan they want to join, not by code.

[LemoneyFresh937]

It's ridiculous that this thread still exists.

[Goempel]

Holding a player hostage is not the solution to your war deserters.

Clan management is. Don't bring people into war that you are unsure of. If you recruit someone new and instantly put them into war, that's your own fault. No one should be obligated to stay somewhere they don't want to be.

The person who leaves should still get penalized, because not only is it the fault of the leader, it is the fault of the pupil who left. The pupil who left obviously did not like the clan, however, that person shall not be entitled to leave the clan while the clan is facing off another clan in a clan war, if he/she does so, they shall get a minor loot penalty. This will repeat until the pupil realizes that they should not be leaving clans when they are in clan war.