Does supercell need to nerf max th9

[CoachDalsberg]

Those clans want TH9s because TH10 is just too horribly unbalanced. TH10 needs a major offense boost right now.

Could not agree more. I went from th7 to th10 with five builders working around the clock. The moment I hit th10 I realized that upgrading defenses did not matter. I have maxed my infernos, but apart from that I have stopped raiding (and more or less playing the game) and focused on walls and wars. Maxed troops 2 star me sometimes, and I reckon they will no matter how much I upgrade my defenses as 8m spent on the last x-bow upgrade gives me soooo little that I honestly don't care.

Worst part is that with the clan perks I can't even help my clan with exclusive troops as the th9s with perks can donate almost the same as me.

You may say th9 is balanced, but I challenge you: let golem lvl4 be th10 exclusive and the difference shows.

[BFMatteus]

Those clans want TH9s because TH10 is just too horribly unbalanced. TH10 needs a major offense boost right now.

Agreed.

OneHive Raids made a good video on this, talked about Town Hall level 10s and the unbalance of the Town Hall level. It's just too hard to 3 star a proper Town Hall level 10 base with proper placed max traps, max defenses, max building, etc.

[OnyxDS]

Those clans want TH9s because TH10 is just too horribly unbalanced. TH10 needs a major offense boost right now.

SC will never buff TH10 offence as it would totally destroy multiplayer trophy play. What TH10 needs, and might just possibly get, is a big DEFENCE buff - so that 2* becomes hard to achieve. TH10 isn't supposed to be balanced so that 3* or not is finely balanced. It's supposed to be the lose/1*/2* outcome which is balanced.

[charizzle]

SC will never buff TH10 offence as it would totally destroy multiplayer trophy play. What TH10 needs, and might just possibly get, is a big DEFENCE buff - so that 2* becomes hard to achieve. TH10 isn't supposed to be balanced so that 3* or not is finely balanced. It's supposed to be the lose/1*/2* outcome which is balanced.

If the third star is impossible to get what's the point of having it? Offense should always be strong enough to 3 star a base if you have the proper planning and deployment yadayada. It should be hard but do-able, just like th9 is.

[OnyxDS]

If the third star is impossible to get what's the point of having it? Offense should always be strong enough to 3 star a base if you have the proper planning and deployment yadayada. It should be hard but do-able, just like th9 is.

It's for other TH, and for hitting bases weaker than you. Very few clans consist only of max TH10. There's no need for 3* to be the objective, as long as the game is balanced so that ONE of the stars is obtained by skilled attackers and not by poor attacks. The problem at the moment is that the borderline in TH10 is in the wrong place - mid 2*, so that everyone - great or average attacker - gets 2*. War is fixed if either 2* or 3* is marginal. But multiplayer is totally broken if 3* is achievable at TH10, and would function much better than now if 2* was harder to achieve.

[Liberation]

there no such thing th9 can 2 star th10 except the base is totally rush or very bad position.they want all th9 so they can meet clan war with the same amount of th9 and th9 v th9 can easily 3 star each other

What are you saying? A maxed TH9 with maxed out TH9 troops can very easily 2 star a mid TH10.

[GrimReaper88]

SC will never buff TH10 offence as it would totally destroy multiplayer trophy play. What TH10 needs, and might just possibly get, is a big DEFENCE buff - so that 2* becomes hard to achieve. TH10 isn't supposed to be balanced so that 3* or not is finely balanced. It's supposed to be the lose/1*/2* outcome which is balanced.

If this is actually a fact, I can say for the first time that I understand why TH10 clans mod, carry on .

[OnyxDS]

If this is actually a fact, I can say for the first time that I understand why TH10 clans mod, carry on .

Well, if they rebalanced TH10 so that 2* was tricky, then 3* might be impossible no matter how many carrots were consumed. Which would make every TH10 bunny war a tie, but TH10 FP war interesting.