Does supercell need to nerf max th9

[TullSadum]

...it's what I have been saying for some time now:
Reduce Th9 and 10
to close the too big gap between Th8 and Th9 and the one between Th9 and Th10
and
to make room for Th11

reduction in the way of only one XB for Th9, 2 for 10, 3 for 11 and only one IT for Th10, 2 for Th11
anyone who already built the then extra buildings will not loose them, but cannot refill them until the new Th lvl is achieved.

I am not saying that these ought to be the only changes, but this concept is one to start off from, or at least to consider.

Have Fun
TS

[TheConfuzed1]

.. and so is TH10, if you don't freakin' rush to it!

It's not about TH level as much as it is about upgrading the stuff you have at that TH level .. Your troops don't get magically stronger, just because you have a lava-flowing TH10 on your base .. :-)

/Affront

You're completely wrong. Jake from One Hive even made a video about it:

[BarneyyStinsonn]

No

10 No's.

[fre3dom]

lol...
just lol...

don't you know max th9 usually bought th10 matchup? Max th9 sometimes become a liability because it's hard to 2 star TH10 with infernos. Let alone 3 stars. while they can be destroyed (3 star) easilly by th10 with proper army

[Ajax]

...it's what I have been saying for some time now:
Reduce Th9 and 10
to close the too big gap between Th8 and Th9 and the one between Th9 and Th10
and
to make room for Th11

reduction in the way of only one XB for Th9, 2 for 10, 3 for 11 and only one IT for Th10, 2 for Th11
anyone who already built the then extra buildings will not loose them, but cannot refill them until the new Th lvl is achieved.

I am not saying that these ought to be the only changes, but this concept is one to start off from, or at least to consider.

There is no possibility whatsoever that this will be considered by Supercell. They may change the statistics of various items to make them less powerful, but they will never take away items that have already been given at any TH level.

Doing it while allowing those who already have them to keep what they have will result in those without being treated as second class TH9s, and would be almost impossible to balance, as well as adding unnecessary complexity to the codebase.

Doing it without allowing those who had them to keep them would result in howls of outrage, a lot of players leaving, and demands for gem refunds from anybody who had paid to get/upgrade those items.

[SnarfVader]

TH9 is balanced. They need to leave it the hell alone and balance TH10!

This is very true. It is also the reason IMO Th9 is the best lvl to war at. Combines the challenge of taking on tough bases that are difficult to 3* with the very real possibility of success if properly executed. TH10 does not have this balance. I recommend checking out OneHive's podcast from last week where they discuss this very issue. Have a good one, a Clash On!

[Hamidal]

I ask because I see clans recruiting all th9's and refusing th10's. It is well known that a max th9 should be able to two star a mid th10 and three star a mid-max th9. Which th10 are likely to get the same result but cost much more in war weight doing so.

This is causing the game to stagnate as players are staying at th9 eventhough they are fully maxed. So what can supercell do? Well what they need to do is make it easier for th10 to three star one another and much harder for th9 to two star a th10.

How will that be accomplished? Well for one they could make a troop thats only unlocked at th10. Two they nerf jump earth quake a bit and force th9 to deal with th10 higher walls without spells.

Th9 3 staring max TH9 true you still need a lof of skills and practice
TH9 2 staring mid TH10 wrong and absolutely wrong, attacking mid TH10 and you are more likely to get no star

the reason is that its more difficult to 2 stars a TH10 as TH10 than to 2 stars TH9 as TH9 and is an special event to 3 stars a TH10 as TH10 compared to TH9/TH9 which can happen more for skilled TH9, and also its more frequent to see TH10 1 staring TH10 than we will see it between two TH9s

[LordSauron]

th9 is for boys, th10 is for manly man bro!

[hemirt]

why cant everyone just adapt soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo tired of people wanting to nerf stuff

[Alisreal]

Is it just me, or can i never take the OP seriously because of his name?

The threads don't help.