Broken Clan Wars, Too Easy Enemies

[Ajax]

We always see one side of the coin.

Of course people who are always matched with much stronger clans complain in the forums because they are the affected ones.

But if thousands of clans are matched with stronger clans, that means thousands of clans are matched with weaker clans.

But of course, they won't come to the forums and complain because this bug benefits them!

Until now.


That screenshot proves that there's a serious bug affecting clan wars matchmaking.

No it doesn't.

Why do you think it proves any such thing?

It isn't even a strong indicator towards that IMO.

BTW, the top screenshot, showing the two #38 bases doesn't show a significant level of mismatch IMO.

Clans are being matched with much stronger or weaker clans.

It's time Supercell acknowledge this and fix it soon.

It happens. It is rare - the comments on here may be quite frequent, but that is the nature of this sort of forum, you hear about the exceptions, not about the many times that number which are the norm.

Our clan has fought a total of 101 wars - 51 of those at 25v25, a few at 30v30, most of the rest at 20v20. In that time, we have had a few overwhelming victories, but only 2-3 altogether where there was a serious mismatch (either way) looking at the bases. The overwhelming victories were mainly because they didn't attack well and/or didn't use a lot of their attacks.

Mismatches do happen, and I think they are exacerbated by particular sizes and TH mixes in the clan - the more unusual the combination of size and TH mix, then the more likely a mismatch is.

But I don't think they are common enough overall to be able to say there is a bug.

[2222]

The only thing the screen shot shows and at least one comment that followed is that some people still mistakenly believe their mirror number is supposed to be their "match." It doesn't work that way.

[Crunkstation]

Lol, similar to us, for some reason we hold an advantage most of the time which I dont really understand if its random so we moved to declaring in the Asian time zone for more of a challenge, and it worked, much closer wars now which we have to work hard for! Try it!

[neosluf]

I don't get it. It's like when people show replays of 3 starring an abandoned base with a big army when they could have taken the loot with barch. No one is impressed.

Clan war is about the challenge of competing against your peers, plus the extra loot from winning is nice. But you deliberately keep your TH's low so that your peers are basically abandoned and/or infrequent players... resulting in no challenge. So what exactly are you trying to achieve? I can understand people going to .5 to balance out their wars whilst they upgrade their offense etc, but to just keep the TH deliberately low, and then do the same on multiple accounts each. Where's the fun?

Lols most of us last 2014, me just started 2015 so most of us has low th and IT IS NOT INTENTIONAL, we are still in our way to progressing.

The thing we want to achieve is
- Get to Level 10 Clan as fast as possible to help donators improving their donated troops for the farmers.


We have so many accounts in order to do 45 vs 45 or 40 vs 40 always.


We immediately kick members who are poor in attack or inactive.

The reward for being good in war is free donation of Level 5 dragons just for farming or any max troops for those with 15 cc capacity.

[PCShark11]

Just a side point, but how many real life wars have ever been evenly matched?

[Nazrhael]

lvl34... ♥♥♥♥. Come back in 2 years.

[Ajax]

Lols most of us last 2014, me just started 2015 so most of us has low th and IT IS NOT INTENTIONAL, we are still in our way to progressing.

It doesn't matter whether it is intentional or not.

Clans of that size with so many low level bases will screw up the matchmaking to some extent, but even more than that, you will usually get matched with clans who are much less active than you, which is probably the main reason you are winning so often, rather than actually being mismatched on the average strength of the bases.

The thing we want to achieve is
- Get to Level 10 Clan as fast as possible to help donators improving their donated troops for the farmers.

That will take quite a while.

I don't think any clan has reached level 10 yet.

We have so many accounts in order to do 45 vs 45 or 40 vs 40 always.

Fair enough, but as above, clans of that size with a lot of low level bases will rarely be properly active clans in war.

We immediately kick members who are poor in attack or inactive.

The reward for being good in war is free donation of Level 5 dragons just for farming or any max troops for those with 15 cc capacity.

None of this makes any difference.

[FisherPrice]

Low level TH wars are often hilarious.

[Sean007]

Neosluf can you please tell me the townhall makeup of your clan. How many townhall 10/9/8/7/6/5 etc. ?

[cjruiz]

OMG, all people do is complain. Most are complaining that the enemy is too hard now you are complaining that they are too easy. dam some people are never satisfied.