I agree that walls should be removed from the "weight".
I agree that walls should be removed from the "weight".
As a war upgrading th9, this would benefit me immensely. I have th8 level defenses, and all Lego walls so if this came in, I would almost always get matched with a th9 far weaker than me (lvl 7-8 walls and slightly higher defenses) However, this would also be incredibly unfair. My entire clan prioritizes wall over defenses, so we have many people with near max walls and lower defenses. This leads to solid match ups in war, but we still get the occasional curveball. If this update was implemented, this would make it so pretty much every war we would get matched with th9 at or below our level, leading to 3* after 3*. This would make wars a time for us to flex our muscles, but not necessarily improve or have the other clan be competitive. Overall, this is a decent idea, but this would ruin wars for those against clans who upgrade for war, while also making war boring for those who upgrade for war.
Originally Posted by Ali7861
I agree, I believe wall weight should be much less.
When tracking my progress with my clan leader I found that basically 10 walls weighed as much as a lv 12 to lv 13 cannon upgrade.
That is just far too much weight if you ask me. Lower the weight of walls!
Due to the high wall weight I barely farm on my max TH10 anymore. Just more walls which will get jumped with a Golem strategy anyway. And add more weight to our clan attracting harder opponents while I get no realistic benefit.
Last edited by daz258; October 5th, 2015 at 02:32 AM.
I am not sure how this makes any sense...I've never seen matchups in wars that are even with your setup, maybe your definition of solid is to be outmatched? Sorry I just don't understand how that could be fun all the time for less experienced clans.
I have a dream. Do you?
Wall weight needs to go down.... !!! We are a clan who discourage rushing, and comprise about 18 TH9s with barely 1-2 TH10s. Sometimes, we do meet TH10s with low walls, but infernos and max pekkas and then take a hit.
IGN: czar, TH:14, BH:9
exp: 240 ,War stars: 3,000+, Donations: 600,000+
I vote for wall weight down!!!
I have a dream. Do you?
I think walls should still have war weight, but an additional level of every until of walls should not count more than 1 or 2 defenses. Walls are already very hard to farm. Don't make an additional disadvantage of upgrading walls by making it weigh an insane amount in war.
Last edited by jzitovsky; October 6th, 2015 at 06:13 AM.
LET HEROES BE USED IN WAR... WHILE UPGRADING!!!
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...hile-Upgrading
I upgraded a few walls from my maxed skulls in order to reduce my available loot. Those few walls cause my clan to continuously be matched to mid level th9s. I'm the only th9. I'm tired of seeing leveled xbows. I haven't added on single defense as I've been working on camps, storages, drills, lab, cc and queen. So my weight should be closer to a low level th 9, but not one single war since I became th9 have I seen a low level in my opponents. They do have pink walls though. Grrrrrr. Plus they all seem to have all troops available and leveled. War is really becoming more frustrating than fun. It's always tough at a new level, but this is getting ridiculous. Walls just weigh way too much and offenses weigh way too little.
Sorry.......I was more or less arguing both sides. I meant that although this would benefit me, most clans who don't upgrade for war or have weaker bases, would end up with terrible mismatches and would make war miserable for them.
I think there should be weighting on walls but it seems to skew the weighting too much. 1 entire wall upgrade appears to be equivalent to making xbows. Perhaps half as much would be ideal.
Posting Permissions
