Revenge fail

[Bloodyhound12]

can you guys make it so that we can bookmark players who attacked us. Im tired of trying to revenge someone but it says they're online or they have a shield on. Then when I wait and come back 10mins later they got raided so I cant revenge. With the bookmark the game will tell us when the player is available to raid

[devil9394]

Hello and welcome on the forums. Please read the sticky threads before creating a new topic, since you might find out the idea you are about to suggest has been ruled out. In this case, your suggestion cannot be implemented into the game because it was ruled out by SuperCell. Even if you idea is slightly different than the line below, it still falls under the same circumstances.

Currently Ruled Out:
Graphical Interface Related:
*Revenge list indicate online/shielded or currently attackable without having to click each person’s button

Read more about ruled out ideas here: READ BEFORE POSTING - Ideas, ruled out, subforum guidelines

[PvtLeeOwned]

Hello and welcome on the forums. Please read the sticky threads before creating a new topic, since you might find out the idea you are about to suggest has been ruled out. In this case, your suggestion cannot be implemented into the game because it was ruled out by SuperCell. Even if you idea is slightly different than the line below, it still falls under the same circumstances.



Read more about ruled out ideas here: READ BEFORE POSTING - Ideas, ruled out, subforum guidelines

His idea is nothing remotely like the ruled out idea.

[dennisjm]

Apparently even ruled out ideas are fare game.
It just takes ppl complaining enough and even ruled out ideas sometimes make it in the game.
(example Lightening storages .... )

In the case of revenge, I posted long ago with many other ppl who've done the same thing. The revenge panel is annoying.
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player is online"
Click
"The player has an active shield"
Click
"The player has an active shield"

There really should be a better way.

What we NEED, is an idea that solves the problem in a great way. I'm afraid I don't have one although I've tried on this topic and apparently it wasn't good enough. Perhaps someone has a better one.

[gamul1]

Hello and welcome on the forums. Please read the sticky threads before creating a new topic, since you might find out the idea you are about to suggest has been ruled out. In this case, your suggestion cannot be implemented into the game because it was ruled out by SuperCell. Even if you idea is slightly different than the line below, it still falls under the same circumstances.



Read more about ruled out ideas here: READ BEFORE POSTING - Ideas, ruled out, subforum guidelines

Here is what I really dont like about the currently ruled out thread.

It says "CURRENTLY" ruled out.

To anyone that takes things literally or reads it in proper english, it implies that while anything listed in here IS currently ruled out, they may also be considered at a later date. And, there have been a handful of examples of ideas that were listed under currently ruled out that later came to be.

So - a truly normal/sane person would read that as it is still possible. And, assuming Super Cell is a company that is interested in hearing its customers views (we know they are) - why WOULDNT people want to continue to request or comment on currently ruled out ideas so Super Cell knew it was still in high demand?

As you have seen me post - I hate seeing hundreds of threads asking for the same thing over and over again. But I dont believe Super Cells customers should be prevented from voicing their support for any idea. I just think there can be a better way to combine all these common requests so its cleaner.

And I have to believe having a cleaner method would make it so much easier for the mods too. But I could be mistaken there.

[AxionXD]

Only 3 ruled out ideas have made it out of that abyss.

1. Notification for Spell Completion
2. Name Change
3. Anti-Zapping

In the 3 year history of Clash of Clans, as far as I can recall.

Not exactly a "Ruled out ideas are all fair game" statistic....

The only other generally ruled out idea that may make it into the game due to complaints will be Heroes usable in war while upgrading. While I doubt they'll cave in as it does generate a considerable amount of revenue, it may be loud enough that they cave in.

Other then that, I don't see many other ruled out ideas making it into the game, particularly this one as the strain on the servers for every online person to have their entire defense log be pinged.... how often? every minute? every 30 seconds?

Even if it could ping everyone's defense log regularly, it won't make a difference. Revenges are difficult particularly because of the 7 minute (ish) buffer between when a player logs off and becomes available for revenge. In those 7 minutes, the player is placed in regular match making queue. Most who have an exposed TH in Crystal or above will get sniped and shielded long before the 7 minutes are up, every time.