Training war troops in war village

[mhbaageel]

Summary:
Training troops for a war takes time and not allow the player to train his regular troops in shorter time to collect resources from his regular attacks. So this idea is to allow players who are part of the war to train the war troops in war village (I think this also will solve the heroes issue because they are alive there so they can attack as well). If the war ended while some troops not used, then refund them as elixir.

How it is different?
It keeps the war as an additional activity in the game without impact regular progress. The issue of loosing the troops in clan castle will be resolved also, so if someone attacks regular village, the player won't lose the troops in the war clan castle.

How it might Work?
The game should consider the village in the war map as a temporary standalone village belongs to the player. Therefore when the player joins the war he will go to his village in war map and train the troops in barracks as if he does in regular village, as well as the spells. Also he can request for troops to war village castle from war village castle, and this request should be shown in the clan chat as a high war request (high priority) may be in different color or icon, so clanmates should give highest priority to this request and not mix up with regular request. Put in mind that this won't affect the castle troops of defense, which still can be shown from war map as of now.
If the war ended and troops or spells still available in camps, barracks and spell factories then it should be refunded as elixir, while castle troops should be just disposed.

Notes:
- After the second attack the war village shouldn't not be editable anymore to train more troops.
- Barracks must not train more than camps spaces.
- Any upgrade in troops level should be reflected in war village troops as well immediately.
- War village and regular village resources are shared. So training troops in war village will reduce the total elixir in regular village.


Please participate to the idea. I like the constructive criticism.

[mhbaageel]

Any feedback.

[PvtLeeOwned]

I get the idea, but it does get complex and cumbersome when you factor in war donations. Should village troops still be used, or should the war base now also generate war donation troops?

The intent seems to be continuing to farm while war is underway. IMO farming suffers a little or a lot depending not on your own war attack, but based upon how active you are donating high level troops for war. To me, that trade off represents your commitment to the clan and to the war. I'm mostly ok with the way things are now.

[mhbaageel]

I'm not asking for new farming, the idea is follow same as it is today but just to allow training in war village for war troops.
Let me ask you some questions and let's see if separate villages are required.
1- all clan are part of a war and they are their barracks are full and you request troops for your castle, who will donate?
2- your camps are full and someone request troops not in your camp, what will you do to donate?
3- you received some troops in your castle and someone attacked your regular village, so you lost the castle troops, and you have to request again and wait for long time to get them again. Is this good?

Waiting for your feedback.

[mhbaageel]

Anymore feedback?