I edited the post to add and delete a few ranks, it seems a lot better now. And yeah Glaceon, I like to be organized haha
I edited the post to add and delete a few ranks, it seems a lot better now. And yeah Glaceon, I like to be organized haha
I like all of them except for the moderator, the clan leader should have these rights and duties.
I think we only need to add 2-4 co leaders into a clan who can kick elders, that will stop as many elders kicking people. U listed too many new ranking in my opinion but ya i like the idea of a new member not being able to donate until x amount of troops have been donated
I like this idea. IMO, Too many ranks though.
Clans would be good with:
Leader
Co-Leaders (only 2)
Elders
Members
New members (I like this idea best to prevent hoppers)
Innovative thinking to better the game for all.
I think this isall great. Maybe to be a member the donations might need to be higher depending on the clan. If its a full clan 20 isnt that hard and really doesnt make much need for that rule. If the leader got to decide it would be good.Originally Posted by ozvooky
Ooh that's a great idea! Having the leader post the amount of donations needed for the new member! Ill add that later!
This idea has been thought of and is on the list of ideas proposed to supercell, under clan related, in the sticky that should have been read. But it's a good idea.
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...out-guidelines
Probably a higher level, a higher Townhall, better walls and better heros.
Maybe co leader would have to ask leader before kicking
Yes I have read the post, I just wanted to go a but more in-depth wih it hehe. Oh and co leaders won't be able to kick the leader.
The idea of adding more ranks has already been proposed many times. Supercell is aware of the suggestion. Hopefully they decide to make more ranks.
I love the new member idea. It would cut down on hoppers.
I love the trusted member idea most of all because there are so many people that I would like to recognize as helping the clan but not necessarily give the power to kick people out or promote them. It would be an 'your an awesome member and we plan on keeping you in the clan you've passed the probationary phase of membership' rank.
I don't like the idea of the private chat. Anything said between the co-rulers and leaders should be able to be said to everyone.
I think it should be up to the clan how many co-rulers there are. If the clan wants 3 they should have 3. If the clan wants 20 they should have 20. I wouldn't recommend having 20 but it should be up to the clan.
I don't really think there needs to be a moderator.
One of the biggest changes to your proposal would be who could kick out who and promote who. I think that only the leader should be allowed to promote to co-ruler or kick out a co-ruler and that only a co-ruler or leader should be allowed to promote to trusted member.
We could also explore new names such as Leader, Co-leader, Senior Member, Member, New Member or Clan Master, Senior Warrior, Warrior, Clan Member, Peasant................... or whatever. I think it should be an Senior X, X combo with the co-ruler name so that the number 3 guys that don't have many specific powers to promote or kick people out still get a name that sets them apart like knight, warrior, champion, wizard or whatever as long as it also isn't gender specific. That way we could let say the 5 year old that plays know we think he is awesome but also keep him from giving guys the boot.
The more ranks to give out the better though.... maybe Leader, Senior X, X, Senior Member, Clan Member, New member
Here is my suggestion of what the new rank structure should be.
1) Leader (Clan Master, King/Queen, Ruler etc)
Only one who can promote clan members to the number 2 spot. No other changes to the Leader’s description.
2) Senior Elder (Senior Warrior, Assistant To The Regional Manager, Leader’s Counsel etc)
The purpose of the Senior Elder rank would be to act as a vice leader. It is designed as a rank for those 3-5 players within the clan with the power to promote, demote, and kick players out of the clan up to the rank of Elder. It is basically what an Elder is now. By linking the name of the number 2 and 3 players with the use of the word ‘senior’ in the title the number 3 player would feel that much more honored to get the number 3 position while getting much less power to do damage.
3) Elder (Warrior, Mage, Knight, etc)
The Elder rank would be the same as it is now except that elders would not be allowed to promote players to the rank of elder. They would only be allowed to promote players to Senior Clan Member and would only be allowed to kick out Clan Members. The purpose of the Elder rank would be to recognize players, give them a cool sounding title, and put them in a leadership role while minimizing the risk of damage they could do to the clan.
4) Senior Clan Member (Knight, Warrior etc)
A Senior Clan member cannot promote or demote anyone. They cannot accept or reject anyone from joining but they can invite their friends to join the clan. The purpose of the Senior Clan Member rank would be to allow the clan to recognize players as trusted members of the clan and to show them that you aren’t planning on kicking them out while not giving too many players the power to kick out other players or promote them. Each clan can make their own criteria for what deserves senior member status such as donating 400 troops in a season or donating more than they receive etc. Once promoted to Senior Clan Member a Senior Clan Member would be safe from being kicked out of the clan except by a Senior Elder or Leader.
5) Clan Member (Probationary Member)
A clan member is just that and may not accept or reject anyone from joining. They cannot promote or demote anyone and they cannot invite anyone to the clan.
1) New Member (Peasant)
A member is a New Member until they donate a minimum number of troops such as 20-50 during which time they cannot request any troops. This would cut down on hoppers.
Last edited by BrianLegendClan; June 23rd, 2013 at 04:24 AM.
Posting Permissions
