[Poll] Delete new clans if they aren't getting members (Please read before judging)

[CannonFodder413]

!!Mods, delete the thread please!!

Hi everyone, fresh spawn here! I read the stickies and searched for this and I didn't see it, but please tell me if I missed it. So here is the idea:

Many people want to be a clan leader, so they create clans. However, sometimes people don't join the clan. But the leaders don't want to give up on their clan so they keep it even though it is pointless.

!!Before you assume this is about disbanding inactive clans, I will tell you that it isn't!! My proposed solution is to give new clans 1 week or so to "search for members". During this time, they need to find a couple of other members. If they cannot find clan members after a week, their clan is disbanded and the gold is refunded. To stop people from just creating another clan after that, there is a one-week period where the creator cannot make another clan. Once those members have been in the clan for one week, the clan is "safe" and will not be disbanded if they leave. I hope you like this idea, and if you didn't, please tell me why.
Thanks for reading!

[Callywally]

Hi everyone, fresh spawn here! I read the stickies and searched for this and I didn't see it, but please tell me if I missed it. So here is the idea:

Many people want to be a clan leader, so they create clans. However, sometimes people don't join the clan. But the leaders don't want to give up on their clan so they keep it even though it is pointless.

!!Before you assume this is about disbanding inactive clans, I will tell you that it isn't!! My proposed solution is to give new clans 1 week or so to "search for members". During this time, they need to find a couple of other members. If they cannot find clan members after a week, their clan is disbanded and the gold is refunded. To stop people from just creating another clan after that, there is a one-week period where the creator cannot make another clan. Once those members have been in the clan for one week, the clan is "safe" and will not be disbanded if they leave. I hope you like this idea, and if you didn't, please tell me why.
Thanks for reading!

Could you tell me exactly why this would be needed?

[Uthrac]

Why does this matter?

If someone wants to sit alone in a clan all by themselves, then let them.

[CannonFodder413]

Could you tell me exactly why this would be needed?

I don't know, but a lot of people complain about it so I'm trying to make a good solution.

[Callywally]

I don't know, but a lot of people complain about it so I'm trying to make a good solution.

Well I think those people are complaining for a bad reason. Just ignore them, those solo clans aren't harming anyone.

[Litt50]

I think that would be unfair on new clans. I started off with just me and my sis. No one joined for 2 months. We were inviting like 200 people a day. Then suddenly a diamond member joined. Then loads of people joined, even tho he left everyone else stayed. Now I have 45 people in it! 077bond200 is my clan name. I know I put 077 not 007!!!!! If I could edit my clan name I would

[CannonFodder413]

I think that would be unfair on new clans. I started off with just me and my sis. No one joined for 2 months. We were inviting like 200 people a day. Then suddenly a diamond member joined. Then loads of people joined, even tho he left everyone else stayed. Now I have 45 people in it! 077bond200 is my clan name. I know I put 077 not 007!!!!! If I could edit my clan name I would

Yes, it is a little unfair to new clans. However, those people can just join an already-existing clan, and if you really want to be leader, you can recreate the clan 1 week after the disband.

[Callywally]

Yes, it is a little unfair to new clans. However, those people can just join an already-existing clan, and if you really want to be leader, you can recreate the clan 1 week after the disband.

But I think he was trying to say "what would be the point"?! Yes, you can recreate your clan after 1 week, but that'd just be an annoying hassle.

[Litt50]

But I think he was trying to say "what would be the point"?! Yes, you can recreate your clan after 1 week, but that'd just be an annoying hassle.

But then the cycle would just happen again. There would be hardly any new clans.

[CannonFodder413]

Thanks for the feedback. I understand that it wasn't the best idea and I'll delete the thread.