Fast Clan Transfer and Designating Sister Clans ideas (with TONS of pictures!)

[luk3namop]

This is my first team reading through this post and I must say I am thoroughly impressed! Very well thought out idea! However, I do have a couple of questions addressing the transfer and switching clans ideas.

1) How does the game decide which clan is your home clan/how does it decide where you go if/when you are kicked from a clan? Will you just be clanless and have to rejoin a clan?
2) If a player is transferred, say they are transferred to a clan that wasn't already in their list of switchable clans (or better yet, their list of switchable clans is full), how will this he handled?
3) After a player is transferred, what is stopping them from just switching right back to the clan they were transferred from with that handy-dandy list in their bookmark tab? Will the transfer act as a kick (removing the clan from the list and requiring a 24 hr wait period) or something else?
4) Within an alliance, what ranks of clanmates can switch between the clans? I can think of a number of cases where an alliance wouldn't want members mindlessly switching back and forth at their whim.
5) If a player is kicked from a clan, it is removed from the player's switch list and requires a 24 hr wait period. What about the other clans in that alliance?

Thanks again for the great idea, hopefully these small details are addressed soon

[isaactan999]

Would be nice, making feeders suck

[4computer4]

I like the idea but there are some kinks as smasher said.

[AnthonyVince]

Looks good. You might wanna add a poll -> thread options -> add a poll
I remember way way way back when someone presented an idea like this, go lots of negative feed back if I remember right

Hm...nah, I only put polls on my troop and spell threads, not IFR or General, usually.

I definitely like part two and can see the uses - part one I'm not overly fussed but does still seem like a cool addition.

I'm not too concerned about it either, I just saw that a lot of people wanted it and decided to make a big thread about it. I honestly would like it to be added in, but I wouldn't die if it wasn't.

I did a thread 80% similar before. But you did edge out the rough spots. Good nonetheless.

Okay, I guess, thanks

I can see it now, in a few updates it is possible to do this, but, can you like, while in the main clan (meaning you won't have to leave it), make a feeder/sister/daughter clan and have the Co-Leaders as the leaders of the feeders etc? By that I mean if can it give you the option to have a co as a leader of the feeder

I'm not really sure what you're asking

This is my first team reading through this post and I must say I am thoroughly impressed! Very well thought out idea! However, I do have a couple of questions addressing the transfer and switching clans ideas.

1) How does the game decide which clan is your home clan/how does it decide where you go if/when you are kicked from a clan? Will you just be clanless and have to rejoin a clan?
2) If a player is transferred, say they are transferred to a clan that wasn't already in their list of switchable clans (or better yet, their list of switchable clans is full), how will this he handled?
3) After a player is transferred, what is stopping them from just switching right back to the clan they were transferred from with that handy-dandy list in their bookmark tab? Will the transfer act as a kick (removing the clan from the list and requiring a 24 hr wait period) or something else?
4) Within an alliance, what ranks of clanmates can switch between the clans? I can think of a number of cases where an alliance wouldn't want members mindlessly switching back and forth at their whim.
5) If a player is kicked from a clan, it is removed from the player's switch list and requires a 24 hr wait period. What about the other clans in that alliance?

Thanks again for the great idea, hopefully these small details are addressed soon

1) Kicked = You will be banned from that clan and all its sister clans for 24 hours, just like normal, and of course the war timer.
2) You can't switch to a clan that's not on their switchable list, as that is the first step. But, if you're asking about a leader transferring a member to another clan, that is totally separate from the list and the leader can do that as it has nothing to do with the member's own switchable list.
3) Yes, the transfer will act as a kick.
4) Anybody, I don't feel it should be limited to Elder + as I hate ideas that do that
5) All other clans in that alliance do the same, require 24 hrs to join again and are removed from the switchable list.

Thanks

Would be nice, making feeders suck

Thanks I wouldn't know as my clan does not have any sisters but I've seen that people hated doing it so I made the suggestion.

I like the idea but there are some kinks as smasher said.

Smasher never said there were any kinks, and you didn't even say what's wrong with it

[Cyber89115]

Awesome idea! Hopefully we will see this feature in a coming update! :)

[Garchomo47]

That is a Great idea, just like your other ideas

[KTsoccer]

It's just a little confusing and if it were to happen you should find a short and sweet way to explain it

[toggle57]

This is a feature that I have wanted since I started playing (2.5 years ago). However supercell seems much more focussed on adding new buildings and troops - which is understandable.

I found the suggested implementation overly complex and I always suggest that people leave the specifics of implementation to supercell... (they obviously know how to design a game).

For me... this enhancement is more about being able to manage sister clans with a single leader. This is perhaps best done with a new class of leader (but now I am designing).

I would really prefer to be able to monitor the chat of all feeder clans (i.e. another tab) without having to physically transfer across clans... but if I did transfer... I would not want to lose rank or donation stats - and I dont think other transferees would want this either.

Clans must also remain distict functioning units - outside of their associations however I strongly prefer centralized command and control... i.e. leaders and coleaders have their rank because they are trusted individuals. They should imo maintain this status and rights across all of the clans in the group.

The details of how and where supercell should put the adding, removing and transfering functions - should really imo be left to them.

just my $.02

[Tronixton]

I'm just going to say all that can be said at this point. Mostly directed to supercell

"Just do it!"
-Shia Lebouff

[iamsofancy]

This is the best idea I've seen all afternoon!!
You put a lot of effort into.
I guess this can help all clans