Attention Supercell and Forum Peeps!

[opum2]

I don't understand why people hate this so much.

[0jij0]

I know that what i say aren't from ur main idea
but this would happen
people will abuse that feature

[0jij0]

I don't understand why people hate this so much.

Man don't be angry we're here to comment ur idea and criticize it and if u think u know that we are right

[Uthrac]

I don't understand why people hate this so much.

It's not that your idea doesn't sound fun ... it's that there are unintended consequences to consider in that it can be abused. Generally, any ideas that players can abuse (i.e. to make a copy of a base they need to make a real attack on and practice against it) or would cut into SC revenue (i.e. if I can play with my friends and unlock anything, why play the on-line version?), then those aspects need to be addressed.

[opum2]

It's not that your idea doesn't sound fun ... it's that there are unintended consequences to consider in that it can be abused. Generally, any ideas that players can abuse (i.e. to make a copy of a base they need to make a real attack on and practice against it) or would cut into SC revenue (i.e. if I can play with my friends and unlock anything, why play the on-line version?), then those aspects need to be addressed.

The point about abusing it is true I guess.

[hawdog]

I don't understand why people hate this so much.

You're not understanding what people are trying to say.

It's not that people hate the idea, it's the fact that:

1) it offers an unfair advantage (you can build the EXACT base as the enemy you are going to attack in clan wars and practice on it on your dev account before actually attacking on your REAL account).
2) it will decrease the number of players and hours spent in the REAL game, thus decreasing SC revenue
3) it is fun for you and your friends to play around with, but offers SC no benefit and actually hurts them because of reason #2 above

It is simply not realistic for your idea to be implemented. It would be fun, but it won't realistically happen. Do you understand now?

Just like it would be fun for me to play a pick-up game of 5-on-5 basketball with my choice of my favorite 9 NBA basketball players, but realistically, it's not going to happen either. Just like your idea.