Clan Hoppers / Leeches - easy solution!

[garthepoet]

Dear Supercell,

I'm impressed with your constant, good updates. Keep 'em coming!

One of the biggest problems we experience in welcoming new members is that of clan "hoppers" or "leeches". These people join, request castle troops, then immediately leave after receiving some.

These selfish players really get in the way of honest new players trying to find a good clan. They also abuse the generosity of good, team-minded clan members.

EASY SOLUTION! If a player leaves a clan, their castle troops are deleted. Now they have no incentive to leech troops then leave!

Thanks for a great game and all you do to continually improve it.

[jacob123456]

Dear Supercell,

I'm impressed with your constant, good updates. Keep 'em coming!

One of the biggest problems we experience in welcoming new members is that of clan "hoppers" or "leeches". These people join, request castle troops, then immediately leave after receiving some.

These selfish players really get in the way of honest new players trying to find a good clan. They also abuse the generosity of good, team-minded clan members.

EASY SOLUTION! If a player leaves a clan, their castle troops are deleted. Now they have no incentive to leech troops then leave!

Thanks for a great game and all you do to continually improve it.

1. constant, good updates <---not exactly
2. even easier solution: use the common rule of "donate X amount before requesting"
3. what's to prevent them from using the cc troops and then leaving?

[godofleonidias101]

1. constant, good updates <---not exactly
2. even easier solution: use the common rule of "donate X amount before requesting"
3. what's to prevent them from using the cc troops and then leaving?

He is right plus what about someone going to an alliance clan asking for troops to help them in war? And also req n leave clans would tear apart.

[Troika68]

Maybe just have a policy that new clan members donate before receiving.

[Drackos]

I have a better solution.

Dont recruit hoppers. Stay out of global and stick to the forums. Anyone from global should of undergone a trial period before war. So really; this is your own fault and I'm rather tired of seeing threads like this in the forum "elixer walls pls." "Ban hoppers pls." It's your own fault for causing your own problem. We can't make you choose proper players. We can't make people stay in your clan. It's up to you as a leader to do so.

Your idea also kills request and leave clans. You're obviously a new player or you would of known this.

[SimonTheEpic]

The "invite only" and "closed" features have a purpose...naturally, if your clan is set as anyone can join, the clan will fill up until theres 45 people in the clan. However, most leave or hop, so thats where the other features come in.
Also, this idea will kill REQ N LEAVE clans

[schusterjo]

1. constant, good updates <---not exactly
2. even easier solution: use the common rule of "donate X amount before requesting"
3. what's to prevent them from using the cc troops and then leaving?


1. I agree
2. Whats to stop them from donating x troops the request x and x troops and leave. Or what is going to make every clan memebr check to see if they are new? Not really a solution
3. Exactly what I said.

Better solution is to turn names differnt colors such as blue for leaving 1 clan in 1 week, red for leaving 2 clans in a week ext...

[Deadtoast15]

This would ruin req n leave type clans forever. No.

[OzAudi]

Why do so many people think that others who play the game differently, but within the rules, need to be punished until they conform ?

Well OP, your response please...

[schusterjo]

Why do so many people think that others who play the game differently, but within the rules, need to be punished until they conform ?

Well OP, your response please...

Why do hoppers think they can ruin the game for others who are also playing by the rules? Hoppers ruin the efforts put forth by clan memebrs who ar trying to recruit good players.