Back in camp

[BryanJohnson421]

It is not going to happen simply because people would drop to lower leagues where their GoWiPe armies wouldn't die, so they would constantly farm with strong troops.

How would that matter with the new multi player search enhancements last update and loot penalties?? TH8s will see more TH8s... and hitting a lower TH won't get you much... and if it is balanced, like you have to heal the troops with elixir after you're done raiding which takes time.... Like I said it would work with the correct balancing but it aint gonna happen. Supercell isn't going to waste their time on Clash... look at the last update, they are done with clash of clans. might as well give us on option to sell the fart machine back cause it is a waste of time and gold.

[devil9394]

How would that matter with the new multi player search enhancements last update and loot penalties?? TH8s will see more TH8s... and hitting a lower TH won't get you much... and if it is balanced, like you have to heal the troops with elixir after you're done raiding which takes time.... Like I said it would work with the correct balancing but it aint gonna happen. Supercell isn't going to waste their time on Clash... look at the last update, they are done with clash of clans. might as well give us on option to sell the fart machine back cause it is a waste of time and gold.

You have no idea what bases I found in Silver League as a th10 after the update. I literally murdered them with giants and archers and very rarely using spells, well imagine with this addition what would be in the lower leagues.

[Rahle]

Well first of all there would have to be a lot of balancing.... depending on the balancing could be a good idea or bad idea.
everyone that is totally against it isn't looking at the balancing part of it. There is 100 ways to make it balanced to were it won't be over powered.

What most people see is that the troop will be placed back into the camps full health and ready to go again.

With game balancing. say those troop instead of full health would still be damaged but placed back into the camps...
again more in-depth game balancing would be you have to wait for the troop to regen like the heroes using time and elixir to regenerate or just time. i'd say just time cause you already spent elixir on the troop.

I can go more in-depth but basically supercell won't go through the entire process of this coding cause thats a lot of coding. when it comes to Clash of clans they are super lazy. They would rather focus on newer games.

Example: troop AI (i'm sure they gave up)

Super lazy? Have you ever tried to appease millions of people at the same time? I think SC has done a great job with all their games. I am not prideful enough to say I have not played even hay day. It was a great game that I could play mindlessly without having to worry about life for awhile. Now problem with games like this is that not everyone will be happy with the changes. Always going to have someone say that some new thing they put in doesn't work the way they want. These folks are trying to put out a good game and make the money from it the way they should be. If they are unable to pop out a hundred new items for you to use everyday I REALLY doubt that is because they are lazy.

use your thinking head when you make comments like that please.

[BryanJohnson421]

Super lazy? Have you ever tried to appease millions of people at the same time? I think SC has done a great job with all their games. I am not prideful enough to say I have not played even hay day. It was a great game that I could play mindlessly without having to worry about life for awhile. Now problem with games like this is that not everyone will be happy with the changes. Always going to have someone say that some new thing they put in doesn't work the way they want. These folks are trying to put out a good game and make the money from it the way they should be. If they are unable to pop out a hundred new items for you to use everyday I REALLY doubt that is because they are lazy.

use your thinking head when you make comments like that please.

been a while since there as an OK update.. air sweeper really? Troop AI.... waste of space.

Dito on the "thinking" bub

[BryanJohnson421]

You have no idea what bases I found in Silver League as a th10 after the update. I literally murdered them with giants and archers and very rarely using spells, well imagine with this addition what would be in the lower leagues.

You need to give specifics bub.
are these th10s? they must be rushed... if thats the case then thats their bad not yours.

[SuperR0ck]

OMG!
I can't believe why so many people are against this idea.

The worst part is that no one of them provided a good reason to kill the army after a raid.

It's like "I won a battle, now I will kill my remaining army".

Using a strong troop or a mass attack are strategies you can choose.
You can choose between a massing Hog attack or a surgical gowiwi.

You build a dragon, 30 minutes, 36K elixir and then after a successful raid it's just killed.

I understand that some rules needs to apply to avoid exploits:
- You can't retrieve.
- You need to want till the end of battle (2:30);

One alternative:
- Instead of keep them alive, return the elixir spend of surviving troops.

This forum needs a to be better moderated by SC.
So many kids/trolls/yes-man throwing up words to the topics without any reasonable arguments.

[BryanJohnson421]

OMG!
I can't believe why so many people are against this idea.

The worst part is that no one of them provided a good reason to kill the army after a raid.


This forum needs a to be better moderated by SC.
So many kids/trolls/yes-man throwing up words to the topics without any reasonable arguments.

You and myself are on the same page, sir. They just say no and expect it to be set in stone. Like they settle all disagreements. If they don't say why they gave their answer I feel like I have to beat it out of them... Lol

[KIngcrool]

OMG!
I can't believe why so many people are against this idea.

The worst part is that no one of them provided a good reason to kill the army after a raid.

It's like "I won a battle, now I will kill my remaining army".

Using a strong troop or a mass attack are strategies you can choose.
You can choose between a massing Hog attack or a surgical gowiwi.

You build a dragon, 30 minutes, 36K elixir and then after a successful raid it's just killed.

I understand that some rules needs to apply to avoid exploits:
- You can't retrieve.
- You need to want till the end of battle (2:30);



One alternative:
- Instead of keep them alive, return the elixir spend of surviving troops.

This forum needs a to be better moderated by SC.
So many kids/trolls/yes-man throwing up words to the topics without any reasonable arguments.

And when People start taking max dragons to th 5 and 6 where it would be a shock if a single one died and farm there for a couple of hours nobody could upgrade anything the low guys would just be destroyed constantly. However getting a refund I could see happening before them surviving.

[BryanJohnson421]

And when People start taking max dragons to th 5 and 6 where it would be a shock if a single one died and farm there for a couple of hours nobody could upgrade anything the low guys would just be destroyed constantly. However getting a refund I could see happening before them surviving.

You're forgetting about the town hall loot penalty.. The th10s with max dragons wouldn't be taking anything from th5s

and I've farmed there since the last update, and I rarely even find a th7. I'm a th10

[BryanJohnson421]

And when People start taking max dragons to th 5 and 6 where it would be a shock if a single one died and farm there for a couple of hours nobody could upgrade anything the low guys would just be destroyed constantly. However getting a refund I could see happening before them surviving.

A good balancing for this exact argument would be, if you hit a th that's two level below you. You lose your troops.
So a TH 10 hitting a th8. Troops lost after the battle ends... TH 10 hitting th9. Troops saved but 50% health lost after the damage done to the troop of course.. TH 10 hitting TH 10 no health lost except for what damage the def had done to them. Then the troops can either head back in for another raid with the damage that they have or they have to regenerate like the heroes do.

no one is reading my previous posts. Balancing is what is needed for this to work correctly and farely. The quote above has nothing todo with the posts above it.