Clan Modes - HAS THIS SERIOUSLY NEVER BEEN ADDED?!

[Benjam438]

Hi guys, I have a major problem and solution to the game right here! This is seriously worth a read and reply if you have anything to say. Also I would love to hear from any supercell rep.

THE PROBLEM: If you have a fairly popular clan like I do (The Golden Path ) you may know about this. There are 3 clan modes: closed, invite only and anyone can join. The anyone can join mode is just insane! I turned it on for 5 seconds and 5 people joined instantly, started spamming the chat with links for 'free gems' and left! Legit 5 seconds!!! I have my clan on invite only but this puts people off joining and if there are no elders online a good player could move on. Im sure many of you have the same issue and comment if you do.

THE SOLUTION: A new clan mode! No brainer! This mode would be called 'capped'. As the name suggests the leader or co leaders can set this mode and simply add an extra filter:
-Newbie delay time: Set the time between new players joining from 30 seconds to 1 hour or more possibly

MORE POSSIBLE OPTIONS (NOT WITH THE CAPPED MODE JUST GENERAL OPTIONS)
-Exp level min to join: Set minimum exp level to join as trophies are sometimes not enough
-Town hall level min to join: Similar to before but town hall obviously
-Clan activity: Set clan to 'dead', 'fairly active', 'active' or 'very active'
-Clan language: Not location, language as I run an english clan but I like Americans joining too
-Clan catchphrase: Pleeeeeeease add!!!
-Clan best replay: Leader can choose and pin the clan's best replay (nice idea but not vital )

Any advances on my clan mode idea or my options idea? Post them below :P

[RobTheDestroyer]

I actually like this idea. The 'more possible options' could be part of the clan advanced search.

[DubzCF]

Good idea, would be very beneficial to clans.

[JackRobinson9498]

Not a bad idea at all. I've always kinda thought that clan customization was lacking something.

[TheSixthBuilder]

Adding more join requirements is ruled out.

[Nicktheflick]

Love it and for its ruled out that's requirements not settings and clan info which is 90% of the idea

[MrkSjr]

THE SOLUTION: A new clan mode! No brainer! This mode would be called 'capped'. As the name suggests the leader or co leaders can set this mode and simply add an extra filter:
-Newbie delay time: Set the time between new players joining from 30 seconds to 1 hour or more possibly

this can be nice, a delay between joining players so the chat won't be spammed by "xxx joined the clan" or troop requests.

MORE POSSIBLE OPTIONS (NOT WITH THE CAPPED MODE JUST GENERAL OPTIONS)
-Exp level min to join: Set minimum exp level to join as trophies are sometimes not enough
this is ruled out.
-Town hall level min to join: Similar to before but town hall obviously
this too.
-Clan activity: Set clan to 'dead', 'fairly active', 'active' or 'very active'
yes, this is nice! my old clan was an active clan just a month ago, but then some members stopped playing. so it nearly died and they are trying to save it
-Clan language: Not location, language as I run an english clan but I like Americans joining too
maybe, but the location of your clan says enuf of your general language.. but with international clans... maybe
-Clan catchphrase: Pleeeeeeease add!!!
you can add a catchphrase to the clan description (but the font size is so small)
-Clan best replay: Leader can choose and pin the clan's best replay (nice idea but not vital )
yes. nice idea but not vital.

Any advances on my clan mode idea or my options idea? Post them below :P

my responses to each idea is in the quote

[Troika68]

In my experience, simple is often better. We can add all the options but there is a point of diminishing returns. I think the current system works pretty well IMHO.

[Kowalski711]

Agreed. On top of them joining, they immediately request faster then I can kick them... (9/10 people who join and request are hoppers)

Make sure to add that type of filter.

[Callywally]

I think SC purposely made the clan filtering slightly inconvenient to give growing a clan a challenge.

You don't want SC to be doing ALL the work, do you?