TIps for mismatch complaints threads

[spazzdla]

Our clan has been dominating soooo SOO HARD since the patch.. it's almost boring. They usually can't even get half the stars against us................

We are matched against soo many TH9 / TH10 that are utterly useless...

Our clan is mostly TH8's, TH8 is our highest. Several 7.5's. After the patch we have been getitng a lot of clans with like 3/4 TH9/TH10s that are just so bad I feel bad. TH10 with no AA.......... TH9 with lvl 1 wiz towers..... TH10 without golems.. lvl 1 dragons.. no pekkas...

This patch punished rushers HARD.

[zerihal]

Well in my experience mismatches are now very common place... At least since the last big update to wars. We often find ourselves matched against opponents with much higher defences, heros and troops. On the odd occasion we will be the one that is much higher than an opponent, giving them no chance. Out of about the last 10 wars that we have had, only a couple of them were reasonably equal matches.

If you ask me, the matching system is broken. Shame really, CoC was a good game before then 😢.

[Flubber41]

Well in my experience mismatches are now very common place... At least since the last big update to wars. We often find ourselves matched against opponents with much higher defences, heros and troops. On the odd occasion we will be the one that is much higher than an opponent, giving them no chance. Out of about the last 10 wars that we have had, only a couple of them were reasonably equal matches.

If you ask me, the matching system is broken. Shame really, CoC was a good game before then 😢.

lets explore this then . You often have matches against opponents with overall better defences , better troops and better heros . A couple of easy questions .

1. Is there anything on your side that is better ?? More higher th ? ( largely irrelevant I know ) far better walls ?? I just find it astonishing that a matching system could ever match two clans where everything was better for one team .

2. Is there anything unusual about your clan ? Really high wall values , large gaps in th composition ,defenceless bases or numerous th8.5 or 9.5 ??

3. lastly how long do you let your searches run ? Do you restart??

[zerihal]

Yes, in last war the opponent was higher than us across the board. Ths either the same or higher, most walls higher, defences all higher, troops either the same or higher on some.

Not really and odd compositions, just pretty standard kind of clan really. Any members too low or rushed are not generally included in war.

War searches... Depends who starts it, but most just leave it to run until it finds a 'match'... Is this where we are going wrong?

[Flubber41]

Oh and my current match we have two each of th10 and they have 5 th9 to our two . They actually seem to be taking advantage of new builds as new xbows showed up in two of the th9 during prep day . Good timing for them and I assume they didn't count in the matchmaking . So yes that's 16 xbows to our 10 for people that count that sort of thing .


our top two seem equivalent in troops and their top th9 is pretty similar to ours but after that it seems that our higher th8 have troops better than their rushed th9 ... So overall they have stronger defences ( 3 more bases out of a war of 15 with xbows ) and we have a few guys with noticeably stronger offence ... Seems a fair match to me .

.

our match just ended in a 39-39 tie . In our last 11 wars we have had three ties, three, one star victories and 5 that ended up a bit more lopsided ( 8-0-3 overall. The lopsided ones ... five of 11 were either inactive, did not know how to Attack, had the wrong troops for war but great for barch or were hopelessly rushed ( five th10 s to our two but they had no one that could more than one star our th10s or 9s.

so my experience is close matches . That's why I have so much difficulty where people say they are constantly mismatched and am curious ...

Was our last match tough?? Sure it was .. Equal th10s And then 5 th9 to two is not easy but that is 8 top atacks for 7 bases. I might even say they had an advantage since their lower three 9s while " early " weren't particularly rushed .But they were early enough that we three starred two on the first try . But it wasn't by any stretch a mismatch . We had two different attacks that could have garnered an additional star but for an error . I suspect our opposition feels the same about a couple of their attacks . So a good tie !

Our last 4 wars were two ties , a one star victory and a 4 star victory. Right now I am loving the matchmaking

[MaxBusters]

People who dont understand mismatch issue after the upgrade are blind or just never hit one before.
As I said we have experience in clan wars, and I can see if its on par or mismatch right away.
My stats now after the upgrade:
2 clans we overpower, 1 clan was on par, and 5 clans much more powerful.

Its not only about th lvl, its also about heroes, troops and experience.

Right now (I clearly write advantages for other clan):
our 1 is about equal their 1 so they are on par
2 is younger th9 vs maxed th9, (read better walls, heroes bk10,q5 vs bk 10 q10, cc 25 vs 30, ac 215 vs 220)
3 is almost new th9 vs maxed th9 (except of walls, us bk10 q2 vs bk10, q9)
4 is almost new th9 vs th9.5 ( bk9, q4 vs bk10, q7)
5 is early th9 vs th9.5 (bk5, q3, weak walls vs bk10, q8 better walls)
6 is th8 good vs th9 (bk7 walls7 vs bk7 q5, 3 maxed mortars, 1 maxed canon, xbow 1 and 2), 20+ troops in army camp, 5+ in cc.

7 is th8 good vs th8 (bk 7 walls7 vs bk9, walls 6 and 7 mix)

So our 2-6 numbers totally low. Even 6 is higher than our 2, except of walls.


7 to 15 are on par, I did detailed review for everything.

[MaxBusters]

1. Is there anything on your side that is better ?? More higher th ? ( largely irrelevant I know ) far better walls ?? I just find it astonishing that a matching system could ever match two clans where everything was better for one team .
- There is nothing better, we have 1 less th9, our and their th8 on par. not better walls or anything.

2. Is there anything unusual about your clan ? Really high wall values , large gaps in th composition ,defenceless bases or numerous th8.5 or 9.5 ??
- No. We have 1 developed th9 in cw, see rest below.

3. lastly how long do you let your searches run ? Do you restart??
- I think about 20 min, I restared once, cause search was taking too long and moved one player out due to 2ad with TH8 (he was new).

I invite you Flubber41 to come visit us and our clan war, so you may check yourself.
If you curious indicate reason for visit. Otherwise you may be declined by team.
There is no chance for our low th9 2-5 to do any serious damage to their num 6 th9 including last one who is not rushed, and his last mortar and second xbow are in progress to max and lvl2. How come this happens?

[Flubber41]

Hey max busters .. I never doubted mismatches can and do happen and I would welcome the chance to see all the bases . This should all be simple math for a computer . If everything is better for one clan it's tough to see how things are " weighted " wrong since there is a fundamental bust .


any war where we knew from the outset we would win, it was because we faced rushed bases . We could see how the other clans extra infernos and xbows from more higher th could be considered by the computer to balance our generally better defenses and troops otherwise . It made a certain kind of sense .

so send me your clan name or clan tag and I will pop in.... I expect to find everything as you say but I am curious since I have not experienced a total domination matchup recently ... Maybe not ever . And we war as a 15 as well

[Gyllis1]

Hey max busters .. I never doubted mismatches can and do happen and I would welcome the chance to see all the bases . This should all be simple math for a computer . If everything is better for one clan it's tough to see how things are " weighted " wrong since there is a fundamental bust .


any war where we knew from the outset we would win, it was because we faced rushed bases . We could see how the other clans extra infernos and xbows from more higher th could be considered by the computer to balance our generally better defenses and troops otherwise . It made a certain kind of sense .

so send me your clan name or clan tag and I will pop in.... I expect to find everything as you say but I am curious since I have not experienced a total domination matchup recently ... Maybe not ever . And we war as a 15 as well

Hi flubber! We had a really bad on imo, u can pop in to see what u think. Clan name in the profile

[Rice1o5]

Nice post agreed