Yes good as it is
Nope I agree it should not give 1 star
Its a poor idea..
since keeping bases out and sniping is a part of combat strategy..!!
If we remove the star from town hall, the importance of variety of bases will fall..!!
And it doesnt happen by chance....
it gives trophy pushers to boost their trophies.... and the defender to save their resources..
Mayur Garg
Clan Leader - ZaykXire
(See my post on New Spell - Mirage Spell)
Look at war bases there are millions. It will mean before going to attack you don't just need 5 archers but you would need to take a full army. Attack smart.Originally Posted by MayurGarg
Last edited by GoldRushBoss; May 9th, 2015 at 01:02 PM.
Oh, for TH Sniping's sake! Let me ask you. If you remove the 1 star/instant win gained from destroying the town hall, where would you designate that star?
and one thing about th sniping: it's a RAID, not a WAR.
by removing the star gained from destroying a town hall, you might just make a new clash of clans.
what's with TH Sniping that you don't like it so much? So much that you reject its concept?
TH SNIPING IS ACTUALLY A WIN-WIN SITUATION YOU KNOW. THE ATTACKER GETS TROPHIES BUT ONLY GETS UP TO 1000 GOLD/ELIX. THE DEFENDER LOSES SOME TROPHIES, BUT GETS A FREE 12-HR SHIELD.
what's your problem with TH sniping??? You're speaking like you've never TH Sniped to get some free trophies before.
P.S. I'm not angry. I am irritated, I do NOT know why.
ED... WAAAAARD... IYKWIM HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
attacking a th with 5 archers is more efficient than attaking it with 120 minions. attack smart, you say? destroying an enemy's th is attacking smart. it is also farming smart for the farmer, because he gets to lose less resources and get free shields.
ED... WAAAAARD... IYKWIM HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
You pretty much answered the Question yourself, that's my points it shouldn't be a win win situation.
Where re would you gain a 3rd star, really simple. 1 star 50%, 2 star 75% and all 3 stars 100%.
if you read my replys my base is setup so the TH is protected and nobody attacks me. So I don't need to protect my loot or worry about gaining a free shield.
Just so so sad to see guys going for league bonus & high leagues the cowards way. Fight it out and be seen.
Attacking a TH is not smart when it's a sitting duck. If you wasn't able to gain a star the cowards would move on.
Actually this topic is quite old, ive read about a guy(wont mention who) who started a thread like this though not exactly. He just stated that this game is about strategy in attacking and defending bases and that sniping underminds the whole point of the game.
I agree to a certain point. HOWEVER, clash of clans is an evolving game. Excluding che@ts, many strategies have been created by players who are smart enough to use the game rules to their advantage. One of those great ideas is farming. Or simply putting your townhall outside.
I said i agree with the attacking and defending strategy of this game thats why i keep on upgrading troops and buildings to make my base stronger, i agree with that someone who mentioned here that you have a choice, to attack a base even if he has his th outside. Like me, the reason i put the th outside is NOT to fully protect my resources, but to lower the chance of a stronger player finding my base and levelling it. I do farming with the full awareness that its a risk because if a stronger player finds my base, they will destroy it if i have sufficient loot, regardless where i put my townhall. They would still attack me even if i put it underground if that were possible. We farmers are simply hoping that some sniper out there finds me first and gives me a free shield, heck id even allow them to zap me. Thats way better than being fully destroyed by a much stronger player that i cant revenge. And lets face it, if a lower townhall has good loot, you'd still attack them.
ok, so your upset that your super mega awesome base is never attacked?
If you took the 1 star away from the TH, you would literally kill the game.
90% of the attacks would not happen, people would be waiting MONTHS for upgrades and the activity within the game would die.
I invite Super Cell to put in your suggestion.. if only to see how fast they could kill the game.
This game is so popular it wouldn't change a thing, it would change the way we attack and the way we defend our loot
I agree 100 percent. 2% wins make no sense.
Posting Permissions
