TownHall in normal base mode.

[Reddigulous]

I would like to congratulate GoldRushBoss on his successful troll thread. I hope he got his thrill from it. From here on out I will completely ignore any thread started by him. I recommend everyone else do the same. Its the only effective way of dealing with troll threads.

I'm off to more constructive things...

[ColonelAwesome]

Wow, that was a very interesting read and very true. Which is why my idea has some very helpful features.

Like I said many posts ago, I use a protected TH and nobody attacks me and means I have to use 3rd party sites to hone my defending skills.

so 1 week I tried the TH on the outside, many people that attack me only had an handful of troops. That tells me all they are looking for is exposed THs

Surprised nobody seemed to notice this. I think you just admitted that you use 3rd party sites to improve your defendability. Very against the rules, very punishable by ban

[GoldRushBoss]

I've read through the whole thread, and I disagree with your proposed solution to the problem - as you see it.

From what I can tell, you have identified the problem as "Having TH outside to be sniped is bad for the game - there should be a way to make the TH more valuable / more important / defendable."

So, two positions ...

1. The farmers disagree with your premise that the idea of trading trophies for a shield is against the spirit or intent of the rules. It is certainly a different style of play than what you are proposing - but it could be completely intentional by the game designers.

2. Let's assume that your premise is correct - the goal of CoC should be to protect the TH at all costs. I don't think your "fix the star" system is the best solution for that. So, let's go with something a little different:

PROPOSAL: First, the TH could hold more loot. That would encourage players to protect their TH as they would a real storage structure. Could be 50% of what is available is actually in the TH (rather than a flat 1k). Farmer players would hate this, but it would change the focus of the game to protecting the TH. Also, perhaps a multiplier (as in Clan Wars) would help your perceived issue ... if you don't kill the Town Hall, then you only get 30% of the raided resources. (This makes farmers more offensive as you get much less for "collector raids" if you don't also get the Town Hall.)

Final thought: What you see as a game design flaw, others find as a tactic. Removing that tactic may upset more players than it helps.

My my idea does say the TH would hold more loot,

all your other points I have taken on board thank you.

[ColonelAwesome]

sinse i have been offline 2 more votes in favour of my idea THANK YOU for voting

2 more votes in favor, 26 more votes against

[Skeletor1598]

I do not like this idea. I have a hybrid base and usually break my shield so it wouldn't bother me much. However, farmers do this for a reason. I'm a town hall 7 and I have a lot to upgrade. I built a hybrid because I don't want to lose loot or trophies. Most people in my situation rely on losing a few trophies to defend their loot because of the fact that the upgrades we need cost millions. This would ruin the game for many people. Who cares if they have a farming base. You get trophies, they keep their loot, everyone's happy. Also, sorry about the long post. Just trying to elaborate on my point.

[GoldRushBoss]

I do not like this idea. I have a hybrid base and usually break my shield so it wouldn't bother me much. However, farmers do this for a reason. I'm a town hall 7 and I have a lot to upgrade. I built a hybrid because I don't want to lose loot or trophies. Most people in my situation rely on losing a few trophies to defend their loot because of the fact that the upgrades we need cost millions. This would ruin the game for many people. Who cares if they have a farming base. You get trophies, they keep their loot, everyone's happy. Also, sorry about the long post. Just trying to elaborate on my point.

Thank you for your feedback to my idea

[WarrenJames]

Whats bumping?

http://forum.supercell.net/showthread.php/14

Read rule #3 and #4

[GoldRushBoss]

http://forum.supercell.net/showthread.php/14

Read rule #3 and #4

Seen, only done it once so I guess thats not repeatedly.

[ColonelAwesome]

Wow, that was a very interesting read and very true. Which is why my idea has some very helpful features.

Like I said many posts ago, I use a protected TH and nobody attacks me and means I have to use 3rd party sites to hone my defending skills.

so 1 week I tried the TH on the outside, many people that attack me only had an handful of troops. That tells me all they are looking for is exposed THs

I think that is ready for a bad. Strictly against forum rules

(taken word-for-word from the forum rules page)
6: Discussion or promotion of products, free gem, or third party gem sites, competitors' games, illegal activities, music/intellectual property piracy is strictly prohibited. This includes any discussions to h a c k, exploit or run any Supercell games outside officially supported platforms.

[WarrenJames]

Seen, only done it once so I guess thats not repeatedly.

You have done bumps and spam posts more than once.
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...=1#post4529707
This should help remind you.

You do not need to repost the first post. This is not 4chan, or whatever kind of other message system you are used to. People normally read the first page, since that is the main point of the thread.

I don't know how many times you spammed and bumped your own thread, and I'm not wanting to go through all those pages to find out. Has to be at least a half dozen repost bumps, and dozens of spam posts.