TownHall in normal base mode.

[DARWINIANS]

Farming Bases are nearly impossible because without getting 1-star from destroying a Town Hall, attackers are FORCED to attack the whole base, totally stealing all the available loot and upgrading much harder without 12-Hour Shields. The game's okay with what it currently is right now. It's all up to the game's devs to think whether to change this or not. But since more negative comments are being added here, SC will rule this idea out.

More negative comments = Higher chance of an idea being ruled out.
More positive comments = Lower chance of it being ruled out; also does NOT mean a higher chance to be implemented as SC has to think about it first.

Anyway, back to the topic...
As said in the Town Hall's info; "This is the heart of your Village." Destroying the heart itself automatically gives you a win in battle. Also, upon the building's destruction, the defender is also awarded a 12-Hour Shield to temporarily prevent continuous attackers from devastating his/her base --- which means the player can take a good rest without having to worry about others from attacking their base. Simply not earning 1 star (or an instant win) after destroying the heart of the Village (which is simply the Town Hall), farming bases are completely useless as it would be hard to save resources because of other attackers stealing it over and over again.

TH Sniping is important for those who want to unlock the first star in the achievement "League All-Star" where players have to reach Crystal League, second star by reaching Master, and final star by reaching Champion. Also, the first star's Gem reward is 250 and it is needed by most players. 2nd star is 1k Gems and 2k for the achievement's final star. Without TH Snipers, it would be really hard to advance to Leagues (especially for those who were victims of DE Zapping) and force them to stay in that League for an extremely long time before advancing to the next one, then the next one, and the next one, 'till the last one.

[GoldRushBoss]

Farming Bases are nearly impossible because without getting 1-star from destroying a Town Hall, attackers are FORCED to attack the whole base, totally stealing all the available loot and upgrading much harder without 12-Hour Shields. The game's okay with what it currently is right now. It's all up to the game's devs to think whether to change this or not. But since more negative comments are being added here, SC will rule this idea out.

More negative comments = Higher chance of an idea being ruled out.
More positive comments = Lower chance of it being ruled out; also does NOT mean a higher chance to be implemented as SC has to think about it first.

Anyway, back to the topic...
As said in the Town Hall's info; "This is the heart of your Village." Destroying the heart itself automatically gives you a win in battle. Also, upon the building's destruction, the defender is also awarded a 12-Hour Shield to temporarily prevent continuous attackers from devastating his/her base --- which means the player can take a good rest without having to worry about others from attacking their base. Simply not earning 1 star (or an instant win) after destroying the heart of the Village (which is simply the Town Hall), farming bases are completely useless as it would be hard to save resources because of other attackers stealing it over and over again.

TH Sniping is important for those who want to unlock the first star in the achievement "League All-Star" where players have to reach Crystal League, second star by reaching Master, and final star by reaching Champion. Also, the first star's Gem reward is 250 and it is needed by most players. 2nd star is 1k Gems and 2k for the achievement's final star. Without TH Snipers, it would be really hard to advance to Leagues (especially for those who were victims of DE Zapping) and force them to stay in that League for an extremely long time before advancing to the next one, then the next one, and the next one, 'till the last one.

Wow copy and paste

point taken thank you.

[MrkSjr]

Wow copy and paste

point taken thank you.

i sense sarcasm, and the feeling of... "nothing-to-say"

[GoldRushBoss]

i sense sarcasm, and the feeling of... "nothing-to-say"

Nothing to say?? I said point taken.

your comment has no relevance to my idea

move on.

[DreamyoOOaS]

Nothing to say?? I said point taken.

your comment has no relevance to my idea

move on.

your own comments have no relevance either? so i fail to see why you're giving him ♥♥ when you're doing the same thing

[GoldRushBoss]

your own comments have no relevance either? so i fail to see why you're giving him ♥♥ when you're doing the same thing

Move on

questions relevant to my idea will be answered

[GoldRushBoss]

To stop TH snipers, I have an idea that may help (this excludes the war base). The TH in normal mode should not give one star, this stops TH snipers & players putting their TH on the outer base to prevent losing loot & gaining a free shield. And what's the achievement with a 2% win. People say this means the TH has no purpose, but without a TH you wouldn't get new items unlocked so this doesn't change a thing.


this will prevent those 2% attack and gaining a free shield without losing loot. I've seen many players get 1 star for a 95% attack but I've seen many many more get 1 star from a 2% attack.

my suggestion would stop this and make player attack and not cower.

no stars for the TH destroyed
1star 50%
2stars 75%
all 3 for 100%

Then the TH would hold a higher percentage of the loot available.

with this 2% would give you 0 stars and no trophies and no league bonus.
but it would give someone 2 stars that has taken out 3/4 of your base instead of just 1 building.

PLEASE RATE THIS THREAD ����

the exposed TH threads get a lot of attention 👍🏻 clearly an issue

[Nolanvw]

Dreamy-something something something: I suggest you don't waste your time with this fool. He's too ignorant and stubborn to take suggestions if they are negative. So we should all give up on gold rush. Everyone just ignore the thread. (And maybe, it will GET THROUGH TO HIM THAT NO ONE LIKES HIS IDEA AND HE SHOULD JUST FORGET ABOUT IT! HINT. HINT. )

[Ectar]

i love th sniping, its easy quick and i get loads of loot, if the th is undefended then why would i want to bother the guy who gave me an easy win?

you do realise that it's never going to change even if you post this every day right?

[Trivian]

What you demand is easy said for you as a TH 10. You are at the top of the food-chain at the moment, TH 10 is the first Townhall which really can defend himself successfully over a longer period of time.


I´m a mid to max TH 8 atm, and I´ve got my TH outside. I´m not such an addict who is able to log on many hours per day to gain those 2-3 million Gold for an Update. So I´m happy for every shield I can get while I safe the Gold.

Having the TH outside does not mean, that you get your shield immediately after logging off... If there is enough loot in my storages, mostly a good TH 9 comes to devastate my base...

Is ANY TH-level except TH 10 able to completely defend against a TH-level player above him/herself? NO, absolutely not, it´s always easy with TH 8 troops to destroy a TH 7 or with TH 9 troops to destroy a TH 8...

until I reach a certain point of ressources, normally a TH-sniper comes along, because it´s not that attractive for TH 9´s to attack me.

But when I have my TH inside, also the TH 8´s give it try all the time, an often they are not able to get a star, but they have stolen 50-100k loot for example. Then, this procedure is repeated 2 to 4 times until, finally someone achieved to give me a shield. And I lost 500k each and 5k DE... That really makes fun!!

With TH outside, I have the chance to get a free shield, but also I get a safe shield if someones is raiding me seriously and thats fine! The normal Clasher with TH 8 who tries to raid me is kind enough to give me that shield, because the 4 Archers more to destroy my TH is no problem for him(also it guarantees him/her a little compensation prize if he/she fails to steal my loot)

What you suggest would destroy the game for a vast amount of Farmers who are not able to raid for loot all the day, but have to safe their ressources for the expensive upgrades... A lot of people wouldn´t be able to safe 3 million Gold if I loose 500k Gold everytime they log off. And all those people would get bored when things get expensive and quit the game.