Clan war rematch!

[Steve]

This could work. This could really work quite well, I think. I think it would need a cooldown period between wars - say, 12 hours before the rematch war starts? Also, I like the idea of an automatic rematch request in the event of a tie.

[OzAudi]

Doesn't a preview solve most of the problems?

Nope. If people can’t recognize the members of the opposing clan long enough to deny admission to spies, how can you expect them to control entry into a rematch ?

And please, at least read a few of the existing threads before posting again. As I said earlier, I haven’t even started on potential exploits.

[rwelshjr]

There are a few wars that are really close or could have gone a different way if one thing had/hadn't happened.
Suggestion: Add an option to ASK the opposing clan for a rematch after the war is over
Edit:
1) You should only be able to rematch only once against the same clan as rematching again and again could lead to serious misuse.
2) The system of rematch would be the same as the one of finding a clan to war with. Except in this case the opponent would already be decided. This means that the number of players which participated in the war before would participate in this match. In a case where the previous number of members are not available, the leaders would get an option to call off the war or war with less people.
3) A clan war preview in which the leader can see the opposing players which are participating in the war. If he sees the war to be a fair one he would accept. This option, of course, would be available to the leader of both sides.
4) If the opposing clan declines the war rematch, the clan that sent the request would not be able to send the request to the same clan to avoid annoyance.
More suggestions for the betterment of the idea are wholeheartedly appreciated.

I think this would add an element of fun. One time only keeps it from becoming an exploit. Yeah clans would still need the ability to swap members and also have to match numbers in armies. Although a clan can create a mismatch that way the other clan has the rright to walk away if they see that happening.

Or just say that to be a rematch it has to be a pure rematch. Same guys. If either clan can't do that then no deal. That makes it very pure and simple.

Can't agree because people will know attack strats and base layouts

I think just adds to the intrigue. A lot of us have different layouts we swap around. Can swap here too. Or just move a couple traps. Or do nothing. They will not know you did nothing so will still wonder.

And if prior knowledge is advantage gained its gained both ways.

[Morias]

If a rematch is accepted its gotta be same people on both sides and a new prep day begins so everyone can change whatever they want. Only rematch once also with any clan.