Make hoppers lose donated troops when they leave!

[ShameerMasroor]

Seeded from someone else and added a good thing in it. Make hoppers lose donated troops when they leave is a great idea to prevent hoppers. But doesn't that mean that Req 'n' Go clans will be useless, well there's a alternative to that. Clans can set whether a person leaves can keep the donated troops or not. Co-Leader's and the leader can set this. This means, Req 'n' Go clans will boom and normal clans can stay hopper proof. And what happens if your clan is "Lose Troops" and you donated to a guy and he leaves? He doesn't get the troops and your donated troops come back to you!

Tell me if you need more explaination...

[yanks8981]

Seeded from someone else and added a good thing in it. Make hoppers lose donated troops when they leave is a great idea to prevent hoppers. But doesn't that mean that Req 'n' Go clans will be useless, well there's a alternative to that. Clans can set whether a person leaves can keep the donated troops or not. Co-Leader's and the leader can set this. This means, Req 'n' Go clans will boom and normal clans can stay hopper proof. And what happens if your clan is "Lose Troops" and you donated to a guy and he leaves? He doesn't get the troops and your donated troops come back to you!

Tell me if you need more explaination...

I don't see what the problem is with clan hoppers. If someone joins and requests and you donate a handful of archers and he leaves, youre out a couple thousand elixir, which is absolutely nothing. If someone from your clan has a conversation with the new person when they enter, youll have a pretty good idea right away if that person is trying to find a new clan or just jumping around. There are bigger issues SC should deal with before trying to manage clans for leaders.

[Uthrac]

Seems like a clan management issue ...

If this is a problem for you, don't donate to new members for the first hour (or whatever period of time you think is appropriate, or until they donate a certain number of troops first, or whatever).

[btcc1721]

No.......

[ShaneHed13]

Regular clans are hopper proof, mine is, every clan I've been in is, why isn't yours?

"Dear Supercell, I want to play clash of clans how I want to play, and I want a way to prevent hoppers jumping in my clan and requesting troops without setting my clan to invite or telling my clan members not to immediately donate to newbies,

Yours truly,
Butthurt"

[chrispeterson]

stop donating to people who first get in if you don't know them.

[WarrenJames]

Give Wall Breakers and then kick with the measage "no beggers"

Or tell clan to give suspect hoppers to use them as unwanted troop dumps.

What I hate is ones that donate, to raise thier "Friend in Need" achievement, giving giants when I have a request message that says "no giants" in it. No friend of mine, and half the time I trash thier 'donation'.

[trooperc007]

Seeded from someone else and added a good thing in it. Make hoppers lose donated troops when they leave is a great idea to prevent hoppers. But doesn't that mean that Req 'n' Go clans will be useless, well there's a alternative to that. Clans can set whether a person leaves can keep the donated troops or not. Co-Leader's and the leader can set this. This means, Req 'n' Go clans will boom and normal clans can stay hopper proof. And what happens if your clan is "Lose Troops" and you donated to a guy and he leaves? He doesn't get the troops and your donated troops come back to you!

Tell me if you need more explaination...

Yes, I need more explanation.

How do you define a hopper?

[rwelshjr]

Seeded from someone else and added a good thing in it. Make hoppers lose donated troops when they leave is a great idea to prevent hoppers. But doesn't that mean that Req 'n' Go clans will be useless, well there's a alternative to that. Clans can set whether a person leaves can keep the donated troops or not. Co-Leader's and the leader can set this. This means, Req 'n' Go clans will boom and normal clans can stay hopper proof. And what happens if your clan is "Lose Troops" and you donated to a guy and he leaves? He doesn't get the troops and your donated troops come back to you!

Tell me if you need more explaination...

I can give you credit for your dedication to hopper hating. You have regularly suggested this idea, been told why its a bad idea, and then instead of learning anything you are back a week or so later trying again to push the same thing. (and frankly every time after your first is really just spamming)

I think you are so mad at them you are incapable of thinking of anything other than a way to hurt them.

But if your idea was put into play, what would happen is the same thing that you were told all the other times you suggested it. To avoid the loss the hoppers would damage your clan more than if they simply left before you are finally forced to kick them.

Oh, and not that you care for all the times you have been told this but it would also kill request clans.

It has also been suggested to you that you should adopt the ways to avoid getting hurt by them in the first place but I see you still reject that. You prefer getting hurt by them over and over and just being so mad after you can't think anything but having your mad on.

[ShameerMasroor]

You people are not just understanding, you can't stop every guy from donating. Some people who don't chat just don't get what I tell them. They donate whatever I tell them and kicking them is not a option. And as far as I define a hopper is a person who jumps clans in search of strong members who can give them high lvl troops. We are strong but some members of our clan don't understand...