Badges📛

[Dvs]

Supercell's reasons include: potential breach of privacy and their long standing policy, in all their games, of not posting stats that could be seen as negative.

These have been brought up in the thread before, but I have put them here again for you. So this thread as currently constructed is dead now right? You can see how your badge idea can't work due to it conflicting with other ruled out ideas and we are all going to go home, drink some beverage of choice and move on with our lives?

Thanks

It can be a blessing but a curse as well . I thought this how we played the game. Those who are more active get rewarded as to lvl up faster and those who play it less often are left behind.

[PrinceAwesome]

It can be a blessing but a curse as well . I thought this how we played the game. Those who are more active get rewarded as to lvl up faster and those who play it less often are left behind.

I don't even see how that relates to my point but thanks for coming out. Your idea isn't going to happen, sorry for your luck, enjoy the rest of your time on the forum hopefully contributing with other ideas that may work or to other people's already discussed ideas.

[rwelshjr]

If u really know what is problem for giving out such details pls tell.
And don't bother to reply back if ur not going to answer.

OK, had you read my fist post 9I think you were too busy plotting your retort to pay attention) you would have noted I did not want to say whether or not I agreed with SC's policy because it is a stupid argument. The reason I gave was because what I think of it is not important. All that is important is that they think so.

You though have been slow on the uptake so you have spent your afternoon arguing with Gilligan and Skipper over something that the professor actually decided.

[Robatomwarriors]

I like it. Medals if you like. Sounds a bit complex data wise. How about clan leaders can give access to clan decoration crystal gold silver and bronze. If you hop it lasts a week before reverting back to elixer. Let clans decide how to reward them.

[Dvs]

I like it. Medals if you like. Sounds a bit complex data wise. How about clan leaders can give access to clan decoration crystal gold silver and bronze. If you hop it lasts a week before reverting back to elixer. Let clans decide how to reward them.

I could say the same to u but actually not bad ur idea. clan leader or even a clan which is made up of freinds.what if the members just decide to give it to their friend's and don't want to give it to anyone. How can u say that they wont be partial to the outsider.clan members gives reward for ur contribution to the clan right? Even worse than I thought.lol

[Dvs]

There is zero chance that SC is willing to maintain a database of every stat you have had in every clan you have ever been with. With that in mind (and I believe your original intent) the badge would have to reset every time a player left a clan. For me (and many of the most dedicated and helpful players in the game) would simply show up as newbies all the time. We constantly leave to visit friends or help feeder clans, then return again. All this badge would mean is that players stayed in a single clan.

It really wouldn't have any value at all from a recruiting standpoint and it has no value from a "who do I promote" standpoint. Co-leaders should be promoted based on their conduct, not some statistic that can be easily manipulated. But here we come back to that pesky "clan management" topic that you hate so much. Know why? Because it IS the correct answer. It is the answer you need. It is the answer you are looking for. You just don't want to hear it.

Based on what I said about it above I really don't care if it is added or not. It would just be another meaningless statistic for most effective leaders to ignore. But being visible only within the clan I don't see what it would hurt. Just a waste of developer's time at worst.

They already are maintaining stats of every player profile. So the badge will not be a big problem.

[Robatomwarriors]

I meant no offence by the title, its a reference to a Mel Brooks movie. I think that's a sure fire way to get SC's attention.

What you are suggesting is a quick way to identify a players value to clan leaders. All the info is there. I think as the info is there we need to tie this in to better gameplay.

There is another post that is looking for an effective offensive stat. Trophies are not great for this due to other mechanics. What I would look for is something to differentiate players rather than Elder which is tricky due to the ability to kick.

As a refinement that hopefully ticks all the boxes. Having a clan award that shows your offensive capabilities would be useful. I also think town hall level is a factor, donations would be good to know.

So the symbol (badge) would have 3 shapes a square is no donations or less than 30. A circle is 30 or more and a star is more donations than requests. If it shows the town hall level in it, that's a good clue to the value of the donations.

The trick now is colour coding this for offensive capability. I feel clan war stars don't help enough as they can be easy or hard. So, max level army camps is one point; 25% complete research is one point; 50% complete research is one point; 75% complete research is one point; max level spell factory one point; max level clan castle is one point; 25% complete hero one point; 50% complete hero one point; 75% complete hero one point. 10 colours?
0 points = white
1 point = yellow
2 points = green
3 points = brown
4 points = blue
5 points = red
6 points = bronze
7 points = silver
8 points = gold
9 points = crystal
10 points=black

I would say for the symbol to be visible to the clan you need endorsed as a member by Elder or higher.

What do you think?

[Ninja352]

I would much prefer an in-clan level system (no badge though) based on total war stars gained in the clan, total donations made (including war donations) in the clan, and using both attacks in war (I don't like the heroic attack idea though).

I could see this being a huge benefit to the clans who actually give titles to players who deserve them.


Edit: Actually the Most Heroic Attack achievement could add to a player's in-clan level, but not a huge amount. Also I think the biggest factor should be the amount of 3 star attacks on players from 1 rank lower to any ranks higher, in war. Those attacks are what help clans the most, along with donations of course.

It would be levels that can only be seen within the clan. So it would only be relative. Farming clans would be fine because everyone in the clan would get their rank from donations. The longer you've been in the clan and the more donations you have means higher lvl. To help farming clans even more, receiving donations could give a little extra boost to lvl.

Here is my input from OP's last thread.

[Dvs]

I meant no offence by the title, its a reference to a Mel Brooks movie. I think that's a sure fire way to get SC's attention.

What you are suggesting is a quick way to identify a players value to clan leaders. All the info is there. I think as the info is there we need to tie this in to better gameplay.

There is another post that is looking for an effective offensive stat. Trophies are not great for this due to other mechanics. What I would look for is something to differentiate players rather than Elder which is tricky due to the ability to kick.

As a refinement that hopefully ticks all the boxes. Having a clan award that shows your offensive capabilities would be useful. I also think town hall level is a factor, donations would be good to know.

So the symbol (badge) would have 3 shapes a square is no donations or less than 30. A circle is 30 or more and a star is more donations than requests. If it shows the town hall level in it, that's a good clue to the value of the donations.

The trick now is colour coding this for offensive capability. I feel clan war stars don't help enough as they can be easy or hard. So, max level army camps is one point; 25% complete research is one point; 50% complete research is one point; 75% complete research is one point; max level spell factory one point; max level clan castle is one point; 25% complete hero one point; 50% complete hero one point; 75% complete hero one point. 10 colours?
0 points = white
1 point = yellow
2 points = green
3 points = brown
4 points = blue
5 points = red
6 points = bronze
7 points = silver
8 points = gold
9 points = crystal
10 points=black

I would say for the symbol to be visible to the clan you need endorsed as a member by Elder or higher.

What do you think?

I like ur idea.the donation idea that ur badges change's shape with ur respective number of donation's👍.but I'm not sure about the rest.

[Dvs]

Ur idea is a in clan lvl system.not bad its different.so if u leave a clan will ur lvl remain?
As for the most heroic attack I thought I had offered a solution that the thougher it was to get the most heroic attack the faster the badge will lvl up.