War idea, NOT RULED OUT

[Somethingrandomforaname]

So I know people have suggested it but no one comments and then the thread gets lost in the pages that no one reads like 5 and 6. So I'm suggesting it again, we should be able to have a war against one clan we chose every week once. But only if the leaders both accept and the clan analasis will search them to make sure they are equal, or it can auto chose the right opponents for an even match. If none are equal then the clan is rejected.or you could designate a rival clan that's always comparing stats with clan mail every week. For example my clan: quantum helix(lv.2) wants to war against the onowaynians.

[BladeLash]

TheShogunate is the rival clan of my BladeStorm clan (there are a bunch of BladeStorms) and we argue at school about who would win a cw so I wanna settle it once and for all!

[Somethingrandomforaname]

TheShogunate is the rival clan of my BladeStorm clan (there are a bunch of BladeStorms) and we argue at school about who would win a cw so I wanna settle it once and for all!

Thank you for commenting so others can read

[lanesteele240]

It is hard enough to get a match up as it is. Must less EVERY clan hand picking their opponents

[rwelshjr]

It actually is ruled out. You are talking about being able to pick war opponents. Most people know that any sort of picking war opponents is going to be a non started so whether they like it or not they don't see reason to comment or invest any time in it.

You have no place to complain about ideas scrolling off when you are so much part of the problem. You are on several threads as you have yourself a self bumping spree. Your ideas when they disappear with a lot of reads but no comments are simply not being found interesting. So self bumping them to the top is just spamming. I know you think your ideas are awesome and everyone is wrong for not being interested. But you should still respect their opinions more than you do when you keep sticking them back in their face without caring that you are instead pushing down other people's ideas.

[PrideFC]

On another game, you could choose who to challenge. One group was continuously challenged by a better group, and you couldn't turn down challenges in that game. It could become very unfair. Imagine a top clan (say Emirates) challenges some random low level clan. Ack. In the other game (call of mini infinity) the group eventually disbanded because of that. So no, not a good idea.

[rwelshjr]

On another game, you could choose who to challenge. One group was continuously challenged by a better group, and you couldn't turn down challenges in that game. It could become very unfair. Imagine a top clan (say Emirates) challenges some random low level clan. Ack. In the other game (call of mini infinity) the group eventually disbanded because of that. So no, not a good idea.

The OP is going to counter that by saying they would limit you to only doing clans of your level. So I will beat them to the punch and mention it here and now.

I think the big problem is that clans would work deals. They already have a good sized problem with random clans striking deals, it would get 10 times worse if clans that knew each other could do it. As far as limiting it to once a week all that does is say that they can only scam the system once a week. And that's exactly what they would do.

You could also have a bunch of guys that keep after every war regrouping into 2 new clans so they could do it more than once a week. No xp in that but for guys that just wanted loot.

So, no this is a bad idea for how exploitable it is and on top of that the OP is stretching things to try saying that making it only once a week makes it different.

[AxionXD]

Clash of Clans basic game mechanics has, from day one, prevented you from choosing your opponents directly.

I remember when I played the old game Mafia Wars. Sure, it was fun how you could pick other gangs to attack, have massive, long rivalries against certain gangs and even have alliances to gang up on certain gangs. This would change the dynamics of Clash way too much.

Personally, I'd find it fun, but I understand why they'd never do this.

[ARXShady]

I doubt this would work because if both clans have to be even, then most clans won't be able to be matched up with who they want. And like you said, since it automatically chooses the players, then what is the point of the new clan war feature where you can opt in and out of war.

[Osirus]

The ability to hand pick war matches would be mass abused.

-Create 2 clans and farm war wins and easy loot on one
-Force horrible mismatches
-Face the same crappy clan over and over for easy wins