The Unfairness of Equal Xp Set by a Number of Players

[CoCPlayer3574]

I agree with OP and think that the Xp earned from destroying a base should be dependent On the th level of that base. That would fix the imbalance entirely.

[SharkyFinn]

It has come to my attention that the first top Lv.4 and 5 clans have not been other than clans full of low levels town hall players ... A clan full of lv.20-40s with Lv.2-3 troops, players whose experience is limited to the game, and their attack being dependent of the high level troops donated by the few in the clan.

Now let’s talk about the high level clans that you really wish to be in, these guys have it hard.

I know this for a fact because I have 2 maxed TH7s that I hop around with. I was a member for 4 wars in ATHENA and a member for 3 wars in Brute Force ... I am just telling you how the things run in top elitist clans. They do not welcome people who can't contribute 100%.

I passed all these posts through Google Translate's "read between the lines" language setting and here's what is came up with:

I'm a TH7 who was kicked out of two level-5 clans after only a few wars for not giving 100%. I'd really like to be in a clan with TH10's or Champions or both, but they won't have me either. Supercell, please create a rule on behalf of TH10 clans that punishes TH4 clans for booting this TH7. P.S. You're all dumb morons who are stupid.

[Jwp721]

I think someone is putting way too much importance on clan levels. They don't give an advantage that can't be earned by both sides of a war. They don't hurt clans who have members with maxed troops. They just help spread the load during wars. My clan is more interested in the bragging effect with a higher level than the perks themselves. Think of the perks like icing on a cake. They are there if you care to get them. They are not deal breakers.

[kristinepixie]

I agree with OP and think that the Xp earned from destroying a base should be dependent On the th level of that base. That would fix the imbalance entirely.

I do not agree. I think that the same amount of xp should be earned regardless of TH lvl. To me there is no imbalance.

And the reason, lets give a game example:

• 2 different clans, both with 40 players, both do war matching 2x a week.
• Clan A: All TH7.
• Clan B: All TH10.
• Both clans have a flawless war record, zero losses.
• Both clans have been together with their core group for 6 months or more.

Why should Clan B gain more xp per war than clan A? Why should clan B gets to higher perks levels sooner? Both clans are working just as hard to win, with the same number of players and same number of wars.

The arguments thus far and my response:

• Because they are TH10? That does not make sense.
• Because somehow the TH10's must work harder to win? No, because you see, their troop comps and defenses are compatible with the enemy clan... And the TH7's have to work just as hard **at their respective TH lvl** to win against an enemy that is equal to them.
• Because TH10's expend more elixir to win in wars? Well that doesnt work either because you are also gaining more war loot when you get a star. A "great war loot" win for a TH7 is significantly lower than a "great war loot" win for a TH10. You might spend more, but you win a pile more too.

Did I miss anything? There were some petty arguments and idiocy so I skipped a few reply's.

[Jubi]

So how come your clan should get more xp because you have higher level players vs. higher level players? If your clan and my clan both won our last 20 vs. 20 war against a clan of equivalent strength to our own, then we fought every bit as hard as you did to earn our xp. How is that unfair to you?

[TrainedNoob]

I do not agree. I think that the same amount of xp should be earned regardless of TH lvl. To me there is no imbalance.

And the reason, lets give a game example:

• 2 different clans, both with 40 players, both do war matching 2x a week.
• Clan A: All TH7.
• Clan B: All TH10.
• Both clans have a flawless war record, zero losses.
• Both clans have been together with their core group for 6 months or more.

Why should Clan B gain more xp per war than clan A? Why should clan B gets to higher perks levels sooner? Both clans are working just as hard to win, with the same number of players and same number of wars.

The arguments thus far and my response:

• Because they are TH10? That does not make sense.
• Because somehow the TH10's must work harder to win? No, because you see, their troop comps and defenses are compatible with the enemy clan... And the TH7's have to work just as hard **at their respective TH lvl** to win against an enemy that is equal to them.
• Because TH10's expend more elixir to win in wars? Well that doesnt work either because you are also gaining more war loot when you get a star. A "great war loot" win for a TH7 is significantly lower than a "great war loot" win for a TH10. You might spend more, but you win a pile more too.

Did I miss anything? There were some petty arguments and idiocy so I skipped a few reply's.

I talked about TH9-10 clans that have been together for a long time and you're comparing it with a TH7 that has been that long... In my post I talked about the Top High Level Clans.. look at most of their member.. most of them do NOT break the 100 War Hero Stars, they barely been with each other for long. Some of those clans do not even have more than 70 wins. I am comparing these top clans to clans that has 150+ war clan and war with 40+ and yet these "High" level clans are full of low levels and got there first. As a low level in these kinds of "clans" there isn't much to attack. For example, look at TURKiYE and Hoppers. I joined Hoppers today and you know that 7 accounts in the clan belong to the leader and I check the last battles they had and the leader was OPT out of war. But I check the low level attacks and all they did was mass giants and 2 Lv.6 Balloons in their CC... This is what i am talking about.. a TH3-4 giving his clan the same experience as a TH9 - 10 would. This strategy is an exploit to the game and you fool are too blind to see.

[brainbounce]

What if a clan of all TH10 is fighting 10v10 wars? Do they deserve more XP than an all TH9 that fights 15v15?
You don't have to fight the clans you are complaining about, so why do you care?
"They shouldn't be at the top. My waaaaay better and more skilled clan should be at the top, but it's toooo hard."
Oh, the unfairness of it all!!!

LOL

[Derrick1992]

I talked about TH9-10 clans that have been together for a long time and you're comparing it with a TH7 that has been that long... In my post I talked about the Top High Level Clans.. look at most of their member.. most of them do NOT break the 100 War Hero Stars, they barely been with each other for long. Some of those clans do not even have more than 70 wins. I am comparing these top clans to clans that has 150+ war clan and war with 40+ and yet these "High" level clans are full of low levels and got there first. As a low level in these kinds of "clans" there isn't much to attack. For example, look at TURKiYE and Hoppers. I joined Hoppers today and you know that 7 accounts in the clan belong to the leader and I check the last battles they had and the leader was OPT out of war. But I check the low level attacks and all they did was mass giants and 2 Lv.6 Balloons in their CC... This is what i am talking about.. a TH3-4 giving his clan the same experience as a TH9 - 10 would. This strategy is an exploit to the game and you fool are too blind to see.

ALL OF YOU GUYS POSTING WITH DIFFERENT OPINIONS ARE WRONG MY THOUGHTS ARE RIGHT.

You're making a mountain of a mole hill. Why does this bother you so much? Because you were dismissed from two of the clans? I bet while you were with them you thought it was the best idea ever.

[TheDevilsLuck]

Well... I don't care what those clans do. They use cheap tactics to win and feel good about themselves. Doesn't make any difference to me. I'll never face any of them in a war.

[Indexer]

i work hard to maintain my 15 accounts for war ....