The Unfairness of Equal Xp Set by a Number of Players

[somethingtofill]

Your point is getting lost in the diatribes you keep writing. Try using a thesis sentence and a succinct conclusion to get your point across.

You seem to be upset over people getting donations of TH10 troops when the TH10 players are not participating in war. What happens when an all TH8/9 clan gets Perk 5 and start donating each other maximum level troops? Are they going to boot the TH10 players in their clan?

Your fear about "high level" clans booting "low level" players when reaching Perk 10 is wholly speculative. Maybe revisit this once it actually, if ever, happens.

[wretchedhorror]

Ehh - XP is XP and doesn't always relate to your actual skill.

I mean lets just take COD for example. People can reach max prestige only because they play a lot and naturally XP is gained. You don't need to be all that good- your K/D doesn't need to be positive. That is just how the XP function works.

[blackcollector]

You are making up your story as you go:

you started by : "It has come to my attention that the first top Lv.4 and 5 clans have not been other than clans full of low levels town hall players."

And now : "the things run in top elitist clans."

To my knowledge, the first level 4-5 clans were not elitist clans.

So back to the subject, in a 20x20 war, I don't see any reason why 20 TH10s should be rewarded more XP than 20 TH9 or 20 TH8 or 20 TH7 ... The fact that a TH10 "can" give high troops to help the low THs is not enough to make this "unfair". If a TH10 helps lower TH, good for him. If the intended goal is to take advantage of this in 6 months ... well, that is a long 6 months for perks that he has no use for.

Clan perks don't mean much. I love the discount on donation. I love to give 6 troops instead of 5. But that's about it.

[wretchedhorror]

Supercell made a huge mistake. The reason most mmo games don't last beyond player level 100 is because it takes too long for new players to catch up. It takes years to max a clan now.. Supercell is killing one of the biggest areas of the game, clan building. It was already hard for newer players to build clans but in a few months it will be nearly impossible.

If you kill the influx of new clans you also kill war. Simple math allows us the prediction that in a few months matches will be very hard to find... and supercell realizes it now.. What do you think they will do to fix this?

The clans that will get "killed" in this process are clans that shouldn't exist in the first place.

[TrainedNoob]

You are making up your story as you go:

you started by : "It has come to my attention that the first top Lv.4 and 5 clans have not been other than clans full of low levels town hall players."

And now : "the things run in top elitist clans."

To my knowledge, the first level 4-5 clans were not elitist clans.

So back to the subject, in a 20x20 war, I don't see any reason why 20 TH10s should be rewarded more XP than 20 TH9 or 20 TH8 or 20 TH7 ... The fact that a TH10 "can" give high troops to help the low THs is not enough to make this "unfair". If a TH10 helps lower TH, good for him. If the intended goal is to take advantage of this in 6 months ... well, that is a long 6 months for perks that he has no use for.

Clan perks don't mean much. I love the discount on donation. I love to give 6 troops instead of 5. But that's about it.

Why are you mixing two different things? Why the hell are you bringing the start of the post related to the Top Level Clans with the post talking about High Level Player Clans who are in words "elitiest clans." You then confirmed what it is clearly stated, you're just too dumb to read something and fully understand it. Sorry, but how stupid are you?

[QueenBeeq]

The XP system is new. I am sure SC plans to refine and tweak it. I just hope they also add XP outside of war too.

[Horus40k]

Why are you mixing two different things? Why the hell are you bringing the start of the post related to the Top Level Clans with the post talking about High Level Player Clans who are in words "elitiest clans." You then confirmed what it is clearly stated, you're just too dumb to read something and fully understand it. Sorry, but how stupid are you?

Bro... I'm sorry but you seem to disrespect everyone who challenges your ideas and concept. I read through this and laughed, you come across as an elitist TH10 Champ moaning people's clans are getting the same or more than you.
bro I have been a champ a year, I've been in lunar rising, I was a sky founder, been in bonbee Canada ..... And I can tell you bro... Your talking rubbish about what you state.
all of the clans I've been in over 3 years have nurtured lower players, we accept ANY donation as a gift, we do not compare our maxed out troops versus our members troops.
i now gem troops for members. Why, because I can. Do I put a tally up, no I don't.

you mentioned some ideas around TH10 about youtubers and helping others. I know youtubers that are th8, I'm personal friends with Daddy. You make TH10 Champs sound like egotistical morons.
you are entitled to your opinion, and you can rant about your Thesis but to be honest, your ideas are not nice.
we should get the same XP, do we get the same loot. No - as the TH10 generally, as you say yourself, sget 1.2 million versus the TH7 who will get half that if at all.

now I'm not flaming your rant bro not trolling you. But if you want a fair playing field then it needs to be fair for everyone - and not more fair for you and your clan.
go play your game and stop worrying about the newer levels who are having fun with war.
sorry just my 10pence worth ��

[TrainedNoob]

Bro... I'm sorry but you seem to disrespect everyone who challenges your ideas and concept. I read through this and laughed, you come across as an elitist TH10 Champ moaning people's clans are getting the same or more than you.
bro I have been a champ a year, I've been in lunar rising, I was a sky founder, been in bonbee Canada ..... And I can tell you bro... Your talking rubbish about what you state.
all of the clans I've been in over 3 years have nurtured lower players, we accept ANY donation as a gift, we do not compare our maxed out troops versus our members troops.
i now gem troops for members. Why, because I can. Do I put a tally up, no I don't.

you mentioned some ideas around TH10 about youtubers and helping others. I know youtubers that are th8, I'm personal friends with Daddy. You make TH10 Champs sound like egotistical morons.
you are entitled to your opinion, and you can cant up your Thesis but to be honest, your ideas are not nice.
we should get the same XP, do we get the same loot. No - as the TH10 generally as you star get 1.2 million versus the TH7 who will get half that if at all.

now I'm not flaming your rant bro not trolling you. But if you want a fair playing field then it needs to be fair for everyone - and not more fair for you and your clan.
go play your game and stop worrying about the newer levels who are having fun with war.
sorry just my 10pence worth ��

Let's start by "you come across as an elitist TH10 Champ." Then you go by saying "bro I have been a champ a year, I've been in lunar rising, I was a sky founder, been in bonbee Canada." Man the sweet irony, to a point he is right.. He stated it himself, "You make TH10 Champs sound like egotistical morons." Hahaha. Although your argument was in the neutral side, which helps your case that I can't fight your comment, well done, you made yourself sound like the things you called me. Perfect.

[lasmite]

Sharing your opinion is fine, but i fail to see you accept the opinions of others. Forcing your world view on others will not be constructive for the point you try to set.

As for your opinion, I do not agree. It is the lower guys in our community that really need and benefit from these clan perks. us town hall 10 players do not really need them. The hardcore war players do hardcore wars because they enjoy it, not because they want the clan perks. They want respect, and you do not need a fancy clan badge or number for that.

To me it seems like the fair system thats setup already isn't in your favour, and hence not fair. I ask of you to think again, but it will be up to you. have a nice day!

[Monkeyhole]

I'll ask again since my point got lost in the shuffle.

Who cares?
How does it negatively effect you by them gaming the system to raise their clan xp faster? They are not breaking any rules by not leveling up their town halls. The only people with any real complaint are the ones that get matched up against them and in the end it only really cost them an extra 50 xl