Show losses in Clan Wars!

[SuperDude3]

Hello forumers, welcome to my first ever Idea Thread! Very simple idea and concept, so I hope it'll be well respected!

I am currently in an elite small war clan by the name of Argon Legion
We usually war against other small war clans that are very experienced and therefore hold many wins. But sometimes we beat these clans so bad that I have to wonder: where the heck do these wins come from??

So here comes the idea...implement Clan War losses/a Clan Wars record to the description!
SuperCell already made some important and big changes to the description, but they left out an important detail: the actual losses, not just the wins

Feel free to comment, rate, and bump the thread so that SC can notice! This (IMO) is a great and simple idea that would be easy to add in-game

[Lyle44]

I would support this.
My clan is a usual 45 or 50 member war clan.
The wars are sometimes so lopsided im surprised they even had a war win let alone 100+

[scoop263]

As awesome as it is to know your joining a "winning clan". It's easy to find out if you don't mind randomly joining a clan for a sec and sneaking a peek at their war log to see how well they usually do. And if the consecutive losses is a deal breaker you leave. But the thing I don't like is it cant tell how many you won in a row. Or that those 10 losses were in the beginning of clan and now everyone looks at the clan as a looser. SO which would you rather join a clan with a better war record or a worse one? As for me it doesn't matter since I don't war.

It will just add to the long list of players requirements when picking a clan to join. And it will only widely favor clans with the best war records and hurt the ones with worse.

[SuperDude3]

As awesome as it is to know your joining a "winning clan". It's easy to find out if you don't mind randomly joining a clan for a sec and sneaking a peek at their war log to see how well they usually do. And if the consecutive losses is a deal breaker you leave. But the thing I don't like is it cant tell how many you won in a row. Or that those 10 losses were in the beginning of clan and now everyone looks at the clan as a looser. SO which would you rather join a clan with a better war record or a worse one? As for me it doesn't matter since I don't war.

It will just add to the long list of players requirements when picking a clan to join. And it will only widely favor clans with the best war records and hurt the ones with worse.

Hmm there are many problems with joining the enemy clan while at war (perceived as spying, and mess up donations at current clan) Also I don't see anything wrong with favoring clans with good war records, as they have earned it. I see your argument about just entering the clan and peeking at war record, but we shouldn't have to do that when it can just be in the description

[2200361]

Eh, I think it would be a decent idea, but I don't exactly see the point because you can just put it in the description... But its a decent idea...

Keep posting S more (Yum) Ideas in IFR... The game needs some exciting additions... ... Keep posting

[Kowalski711]

NO. This will blackmail clans that aren't as good at wars. People don't want to join a clan that has lost 7 out of 10 wars. SC doesn't want to blackmail clans so I highly doubt this will be implemented. When you implement such a feature, clans will not get people in. This would also mean less clans to war.

[SuperDude3]

Eh, I think it would be a decent idea, but I don't exactly see the point because you can just put it in the description... But its a decent idea...

Keep posting S more (Yum) Ideas in IFR... The game needs some exciting additions... ... Keep posting

Thanks! I will definitely be thinking up some new things, I know this one isn't that big but it's a start!

This idea is not bad at all! Nice handy little feature, good job

Thank You! Means a lot

[SuperDude3]

NO. This will blackmail clans that aren't as good at wars. People don't want to join a clan that has lost 7 out of 10 wars. SC doesn't want to blackmail clans so I highly doubt this will be implemented. When you implement such a feature, clans will not get people in. This would also mean less clans to war.

Ok, so first of all I don't understand how "blackmailing" clans is bad since this happens all the time, considering many clans don't have many wins and people still join.. Also my clan (and many others' clans) have a bad war record but still do War, and still get new members This "blackmailing" wouldn't be much of a problem since I see people on global always going to "War Clans" with a handful of wins.

[indirectMW]

Y u want 2 make my clan look bad?

[Bi11iam]

You have my support sir.