Balancing the Clan XP accumulation

[KickinChikin]

Twas simply a thought, I believe that it has changed the way many clans war just to get experience. And my clan is lvling up just fine ty. This is the forum for suggestions, right? Not a place to banter about unproven stabs about each other's clans and accounts.... That's what global's for. My thoughts and "suggestions"... My thread... Y'all may not being paying as much attention to what you read and see in COC and these threads as I have. But I tried to inform you of some of the things of seen. You say " clans that are larger AND win" I'm talking about for instance my son's friend's clan who has not won but one war since the update. However he has between 40-50 rushed not so active members that 1 star and maybe 2 star things, war nonstop and are already a lvl 4 clan well on their way to 5. While mine is active wars 2x a week... Just 3 stared an entire map for the 3rd time in a row and will only receive 165 clan xp for doing so. Never said "It's not fair, I'm gonna cry" just that I believe there should be a way to distinguish the AWESOME clans that do AWESOME things in clan wars from those who kinda half way do wars. Gotta problem with everyone having the right to their own thoughts, opinions and suggestions... Take it up with Obama. He'd love to take those rights away! 😉

[Ectar]

Aiming down, at least some of the time, isn't bullying, it's strategy.

If your #1 attacks their 1 and 2 and does well, then your #2 can attack their 3 and 4, and your #3 their 5 and 6, and so on. Conversely, if your top players aren't confident they can 2 star the enemy's top players, then maybe it makes more sense to send a lower player up to 1 star the top enemy bases, sacrificing a couple possible stars at the top, but freeing up your top players to go lower and 3 star bases that might have only gotten 2 starred if they'd wasted a bunch of attacks at the top trying to get 2.

None of this, however, should really have much if anything to do with gaining clan XP, which is why the XP system is set up the way it is.

that was my point, i think this post got away from me. but if you got more exp for 3 stars nobody would attack the top bases, i like the fact that its just one star as it encourages people to one star higher players, and also makes it less of a disapointment for them if an attack goes bad. also we are forgetting that often many people wont attack, no idea why that's a thing, we should look at a better way to recruit rather than a way to change clan wars, but the 1 star exp win is there to encourage attacking.

[awesomness2016]

I haven't noticed it change the way clans war at all. Maybe at toward the end of a war you know you're going to lose anyway, it provides an incentive to go for bases that haven't been beaten at all yet, but I don't see that being a bad thing. Otherwise, it seems like the primary objective is still winning the war, so I'm not sure how it has changed anything in that regard, really.

[Ectar]

I haven't noticed it change the way clans war at all. Maybe at toward the end of a war you know you're going to lose anyway, it provides an incentive to go for bases that haven't been beaten at all yet, but I don't see that being a bad thing. Otherwise, it seems like the primary objective is still winning the war, so I'm not sure how it has changed anything in that regard, really.

yes but the exp also is more of a consolation, why are we worried anyway, once everyone is level 10 they will stop warring and things will return to normal

[KickinChikin]

And I wasn't saying more experience for 3 staring each base... but rather that if your clan 3 stars EVERY base in a war. Similar to the bonus you get for getting more than however many stars it is but an extra "bonus" for getting ALL available stars on a war map. And maybe I disagree with the clan lvls being to encourage simply participating in clan wars. I believe all games, sports or any competition should be played to win not simply plaid to participate. I don't believe in participation awards, only awards and honors for winners... That , in my opinion, is a problem in so many parts of today's society not just this.

[awesomness2016]

If you 3 star every base in war, your clan is either predominantly TH8 and below, and/or you're sandboxing.


So what you're basically saying is you want to give lower level players/clans an advantage in gaining XP over higher level ones, and encourage unethical gameplay. Or did you just not think of that?


You're welcome to come over to my clan and see what our TH10s typically have to deal with. It will either be a reality check for you, or we'll learn something about 3 starring maxed or nearly maxed bases, for which we'll be eternally grateful.


Also...Republicans

[rwelshjr]

seriously? trying to start a flame war here?

No flame wars needed. After reading this thread I notice that despite the differing opinions everyone here has some degree of rightness to what they are saying. I agree with the issue that the OP is describing, but I also agreed with the reasons things should be left as they are and also the statements about the purpose of xp.

If we do a flame war it should only be for entertainment purposes.

Or here is a half tongue in cheek suggestion I put forth a long time ago...(that I let fade away after some took it waaaay too seriously)
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...light=disputes

[Ack94]

I think you're absolutely right because clan with 50 members, are getting benefits even if they lose every war, while the clan with a better winning percentage are disadvantages

[THEBIGCLASH3R]

I think you're absolutely right because clan with 50 members, are getting benefits even if they lose every war, while the clan with a better winning percentage are disadvantages

Just learn how to get more people in your clan....

[KickinChikin]

We have about 7 th9s and the rest are below that. 3 staring th9s doesnt take a rocket scientist and we use our attacks up top wisely, usually holding them off till last. I didn't say we always 3 star whole maps but rather that we do and have the last cpl wars in a row. I don't need a reality check... I've been in great clans with th10s that can 3 star other th10s, all be it's usually on the 2nd or 3rd attempt at that particular base. I also said "or so many wins in a row" your opinion can be your own. I never asked for your snoody butt to jump down my throat for mine and never did so to you for yours. Get over yourself and let the forum be what it was intended for.


Big Clasher.... Some do not want more ppl in their clan. I have a life... But I also like to win. More people means more time for the guy (or gal in my case) in charge has to be online making sure everyone has their war assignments and CC troops for war. Plenty more people would be in our clan if we wanted them.

On an end note.... Consolation prizes are for losers! The only true prize in any competition is a well deserved win!