My list of win win ideas.

[Deesoul]

A lot of people have really good ideas that most people in the coc community would love, but wouldn't be implemented because Supercell is profit driven. If this has been thought of before I'm sorry.

What if the way leagues worked was kind of like war with large prizes and incentives?
Seasons would only last a few days and the leagle you start in is the league you finish in.

For example if at the beginning of the season you have enough trophies to be in G1 and you earn enough trophies to move up a league you'll still be in that league. At the end of the season they could have different rewards for different accomplishments. Most defenses/attacks won, most trophies at the end of the season etc.


Now imagine how many people would boost just to get at the top of the league and prizes would be relatively worthwhile like a few hundred gems for top placers or large loot rewards for accomplishments.

The league loot bonus could also increase with the clan level just the way war bonus does as well. Maybe have individual leagues along with clan leagues outside of the top 3 clans in the world tournament. At the start of the season, you're matched against another clan or group of clans that are of similar strength and compete who gets the most trophies, attacks, defenses won etc.


It's just for the vast majority of players, I believe Supercell failed to really justify the significance of earning trophies other than being matched against a different group of random players. Loot bonus doesn't pay out much until higher leagues and being placed in a league for two weeks that could change with a day of raiding doesn't make sense to even have rankings.


Incentives and cheap satisfaction will keep people happy. That's just my two cents. Love this game and I feel like they could really make a killing if they capitalized on their strengths more.

[Deesoul]

Bump
10 char

[itmustbeaustin]

While it is an interesting concept, I think as presented is has too many flaws, going just by trophies would make it incredibly lopsided, if a TH10 were to go down to Silver 3, they would destroy everybody in that group. What you could do instead is something along the lines of a week long league that you can pay an entry fee (in Elixir/Gold/DE at higher levels) to get into and for that week you could fight other clashers close to you in defense and offense capabilities, or you could just do the leagues by TH level.

[Deesoul]

While it is an interesting concept, I think as presented is has too many flaws, going just by trophies would make it incredibly lopsided, if a TH10 were to go down to Silver 3, they would destroy everybody in that group. What you could do instead is something along the lines of a week long league that you can pay an entry fee (in Elixir/Gold/DE at higher levels) to get into and for that week you could fight other clashers close to you in defense and offense capabilities, or you could just do the leagues by TH level.

That's what I meant. I guess didn't present it too well. Was kind of in a hurry. There has to be some kind of restriction or "fair" match making to make it work.
You're grouped with 100 random people in your league. I'm sure the development behind it would be hard to make hundreds or thousands of leagues that will take account of town hall level and or overall strength. It's not much different than war, but on a much larger scale. I think the entry fee would make it more manageable.

[rwelshjr]

It had to be self bumped so obviously not a good idea that people found interesting. it should be allowed to fade away.

[lanesteele240]

It had to be self bumped so obviously not a good idea that people found interesting. it should be allowed to fade away.

Two of my ideas only had a few comments and they sank out of sight. They made it into the game.

[Deesoul]

It had to be self bumped so obviously not a good idea that people found interesting. it should be allowed to fade away.

I was trying to think of a way to give leagues and trophies more value or at least a sense of it. I seriously don't see the purpose of a leaderboard.

[rwelshjr]

Two of my ideas only had a few comments and they sank out of sight. They made it into the game.

I have one of those as well. But I did not ever once self bump it. And maybe my thread is not even the reason they did it they thought it up on their own. Ad maybe yours too. We can never know.

If it fades its because the idea did not catch anyone's interest to comment. It lacked the staying power. So any time you see a self bump its a dishonest OP trying to create false interest in this thread by spamming it to the top again. He is a poor sport too, he can't respect that people weren't interested so he spams it in front of their face again to trying to force it on them. This is such a case.

[Kowalski711]

I have one of those as well. But I did not ever once self bump it. And maybe my thread is not even the reason they did it they thought it up on their own. Ad maybe yours too. We can never know.

If it fades its because the idea did not catch anyone's interest to comment. It lacked the staying power. So any time you see a self bump its a dishonest OP trying to create false interest in this thread by spamming it to the top again. He is a poor sport too, he can't respect that people weren't interested so he spams it in front of their face again to trying to force it on them. This is such a case.

Not any more on the forums. Tons of posts recently about ruled out ideas - like the one about a gem collector - the guy is arguing about how it can still make it into the game etc, so self bumping today is I think more needed then it once was......

[lanesteele240]

I used the. Search funtion first to see if some one started a tread on them. I have had 30-40 ideas( Some shared). But only two that made it.

One was the hero stat bar in the troop que and the other was larger darker print on stats in the player profie like gold grab.

So keep on trying. Dont worry about a popular tread. They do look at these 👀 i think